Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

I am sorry, but I don’t understand what you are asking. Too many moving parts and different contexts. Stuyvesant is the top school in a specialized track in a single school district. California has over 1000 school districts. Stuysevant is often praised (including by me) for providing a great education to low resource kids, but as @ucalumnus correctly points out, this isn’t really accurate in the context of NYC schools.

There are plenty of issues that deserved to be discussed regarding how to best allocate educational resources to young kids, but it seems a bit too far off topic for this thread. That said,

I don’t know if you followed the discussions of Thomas Jefferson a few years back, but the outline of the discussion resembles this discussion. One side thought it reasonable for the state STEM magnet school to take the the top kids from across the state of Virginia, with top students from each school represented. The other side thought the coveted spots should go only to the highest scorers on test given to 12 year olds, which of course meant that almost all the spots would go to kids from a handful of well-off, over-performing grade schools. The arguments made were, IMO, shocking.