Stuyvesant is a test in relatively high resourced school so it is per se different than non-test-in under resourced CA schools (and different from under resourced NY schools).
To me the UC discussion that has been happening here is not really about requiring test scores, which mtmind touched on earlier.
It seems to be about reducing/denying access to students coming from the 60%+ CA Title 1 HSs. I haven’t seen the data, but I doubt many of the students with relatively low math skills (or low reading/writing skills) are coming from strong CA HSs or from out of state. Again, access is part of the UCs’ stated mission, it’s the system’s responsibility to the taxpayers of the state. Changing that mission is a completely different discussion than requiring test scores IMO.
In the big picture, the pool of in-state students for the UCs is the pool. So, at a minimum, if all students had test scores, the bottom end of the range might look like it did pre-pandemic. Maybe it goes even lower, I don’t know…but I do believe that we have seen a decline in math and reading/writing preparedness since the pandemic (we have all seen data on this) so I wouldn’t be surprised to see college going CA students with average test scores below pre-pandemic levels.
If the UCs continue to prioritize access, holistic admissions, and enrolling students from HSs all across the state, then requiring a test score isn’t going to matter much…meaning the UCs, even UCLA and Berkeley, will still be admitting the relatively strong students from the title 1 high schools regardless their test scores.
I just don’t see the UCs dropping holistic admissions and spurning the top students at the title 1 high schools…beyond that being part of the UCs’ mission, it would be politically untenable. I mean, that concept is not even on the table for either of these working groups anyway.
So why are all these professors demanding standardized test scores? Are they a bunch of dumb dumbs that cant put 2 and 2 together? Do they not understand the UC mission?
Note that NYC public schools overall have about 72% eligibility for free or reduced-price lunch by the usual criteria, so Stuyvesant’s 49% eligibility suggests higher SES than that of NYC public school students overall.
For comparison, the US overall has about 53% eligibility for free or reduce-price lunch, and New York state has about 57% eligibility.
Of course, note that Stuyvesant is a selective admission school, unlike most public high schools.
Right. So maybe they know more about their students than we do and why standardized testing may be important. These are some of the brightest minds in the country so they must have some logical rationale.
Perhaps, then why not share that? By not sharing their rationale, they leave things open to interpretation. It seems to me they might be in fact be in favor of more stat based admissions. But holistic admissions is out of their control. As is the academic and demographic makeup of the pool of in-state applicants.
Ultimately, the regents, not the faculty, are going to have the final say.
I am sorry, but I don’t understand what you are asking. Too many moving parts and different contexts. Stuyvesant is the top school in a specialized track in a single school district. California has over 1000 school districts. Stuysevant is often praised (including by me) for providing a great education to low resource kids, but as @ucalumnus correctly points out, this isn’t really accurate in the context of NYC schools.
There are plenty of issues that deserved to be discussed regarding how to best allocate educational resources to young kids, but it seems a bit too far off topic for this thread. That said,
I don’t know if you followed the discussions of Thomas Jefferson a few years back, but the outline of the discussion resembles this discussion. One side thought it reasonable for the state STEM magnet school to take the the top kids from across the state of Virginia, with top students from each school represented. The other side thought the coveted spots should go only to the highest scorers on test given to 12 year olds, which of course meant that almost all the spots would go to kids from a handful of well-off, over-performing grade schools. The arguments made were, IMO, shocking.
And to add to mtmind’s fine post- Stuyvesant’s admissions policies are not without their own controversies. There are complicated issues around race, ethnicity, access, etc. These do not negate the fantastic (free) education that Stuy students are getting. But it does raise questions around which 2nd and 3rd graders are getting tagged (if only in the minds of the teachers and principals) as Gifted and which ones are not. Which middle school students are going to be on track for the accelerated math programs offered at most of the exam HS’s and which are not.
So peeling apart the onion on Stuy and comparing it the entire state of California seems like a curious exercise.
Correct. Certain demographic groups were outraged because they tried to get rid of standardized tests when too many of one demographic group were miles ahead in academic ability despite being economically disadvantaged. They couldn’t play the wealth card.
This Professor of Biology at Cal State Dominguez Hills runs an interesting blog in which he states that his fellow professors who signed the CA letter to reinstate testing “need to do better” and that admitting only those students who can send in high test scores is a form of gatekeeping.
It’s elitist gatekeeping. It is literally gatekeeping, working to filter people out of the UC who have been gaining access. You don’t have to be a sociologist to know why some people are coming into college more prepared in math than others. It has to do with whether they’re first-gen college students, how much money their parents earn, and this is also connected to immigration status, ethnicity, and all that. By taking this position, UC faculty are asking the UC to exclude people because they were born into this world with less privilege.
If you’re concerned about the education of your students, you know what you’re supposed to do? TEACH THEM. Teach the students in front of you as they are, not as how you wish they are. I am ever so sorry that you’ve never been trained at differentiating instruction to students with different preparation levels, but teaching is literally the job. If you don’t want to teach, then don’t become a professor, even at a research university.
Faculty aren’t hired to set admissions policy or to engineer the economic future of California. We are hired for research, for teaching, and to run the university. But is this request about improving university operations or supporting student success, or fulfilling the mission of the UC? These folks claim that they’re about “student success” lol that’s the name of their website, but success of whom? Of the select few who had the advantage of getting strong math preparation in middle and high school?
By writing this letter, you’re publicly announcing that you think that your students aren’t good enough for you. That you think time and effort teaching is better invested in people who test better at math. Pearls before swine, amirite?
Do they realize that if they are concerned about student preparation and math literacy, that changing this policy won’t actually change math literacy? It won’t make a darn difference in the lives of these students. The same underpreparedness will continue to happen. It’s just that these professors won’t have to sully their own universities with these unwashed hordes of mathematically illiterate students. The rarified air of the UC will be pure once again. You know what’s worse? If there is an effect of this move on middle school and high school math to prepare for students for the UCs, this will make it worse because it will simply make schools double down on training students to excel at standardized tests rather than teaching them effectively. We’ve been down that road before, and you want to go back there? Man, y’all really don’t give a damn about the math education. You just don’t want to be bothered with math education. Make it someone else’s problem. Hey, you are living in a place with a math literacy crisis. Maybe that’s not the job you wanted but if you’re teaching STEM in a university in the US, with or without a test-optional admissions policy, that’s your problem if you’re in the education business.
“It’s elitist gatekeeping. It is literally gatekeeping, working to filter people out of the UC who have been gaining access. You don’t have to be a sociologist to know why some people are coming into college more prepared in math than others. It has to do with whether they’re first-gen college students, how much money their parents earn, and this is also connected to immigration status, ethnicity, and all that. By taking this position, UC faculty are asking the UC to exclude people because they were born into this world with less privilege.”
If they are so concerned about elitist gatekeeping why not make admissions random?
Why have any admissions standards? Wouldnt that achieve greater academic diversity since they’re supposed to teach whomever no matter how well prepared they are?
One of the many problems buried in the data is that not all “first gen” immigrants are the same. And so as not to run roughshod over our hard-working moderators, I will not specify country of origin or ethnicity or race in my post.
First Gen student A- Dad was a nuclear physicist in the country of origin, mom a concert pianist (I actually know this family. My synagogue helped resettle them). Both parents spoke English (dad more fluent than the mom) but the day they arrived in the US they spoke only English at home. Both parents worked blue collar/menial jobs in the US- low income, immigrant family.
First Gen student B- Dad killed by a militia unit in country of origin, mom kept chickens and a small subsistence type garden. Arrived as a single parent, spoke no English at all, got asylum status because husband had been helping a unit of Marines as a handyman/transportation aide which is what got him killed. Mom had no replicable skills in the US but got a job cleaning offices.
How can you paint both students with the same brush, even if they are both recent arrivals to the US with a family income at or below the poverty line? Unless we are to believe that a PhD in physics decided to never help his kids with homework, never read to the kids, never showed up for meetings with the teachers and back to school nights– or that the concert-level musician never read poetry or taught the kids to play an instrument….that somehow being immigrants and low income meant that they shed their former identities and forgot their elite educations back home?