Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

All true. However, the primary argument against standardized testing is that wealth drives performance.

However, the immigrant families you describe are still going to low income, under resourced schools, have the same teachers and same economic disadvantages.

The main difference is their parents focus all their energy on education which isnt related to wealth since they have no wealth. And many of these educated parents never had wealth, even in their home country.

2 Likes

There are many studies that show family income is correlated with high SAT/ACT test scores. The fact that some limited income families are education focused and/or some limited income students do well on the SAT/ACT tests doesn’t change those findings…the scores of those students and their family incomes are built into these analyses.

Beyond that, I don’t understand your point.

It sounds to me like you are saying limited income kids who, through the random birth lottery, don’t have education focused parents and/or who don’t do well on the SAT/ACT, should not have opportunities in higher ed that other kids have.

Here is just a small sample of the relatively well known affluence=higher test score studies.

A recent paper released by Opportunity Insights, a Harvard-based team of researchers and policy analysts, found that children of the wealthiest 1 percent of Americans were 13 times likelier than the children of low-income families to score 1300 or higher on SAT/ACT tests.

Statement source and Paper:

Family background factors like parental income, education, and race now account for over 40% of the variance in SAT/ACT scores among UC applicants, according to a new publication by CSHE researcher Saul Geiser.

The study is featured as the first chapter in a new book from Teachers College Press, The Scandal of Standardized Tests: Why We Need to Drop the SAT & ACT, edited by Joseph Soares. Teachers College Press has made a copy of the chapter available here(link is external) to help inform the current debate at UC over use of the SAT and ACT in university admissions.

Geiser’s chapter, “Norm-Referenced Tests and Race-Blind Admissions: The Case for Eliminating the SAT and ACT at the University of California,” summarizes UC’s experience with the SAT/ACT over the past 25 years and presents new trend data for the years 2012 to 2016. The new data were provided by UC Office of the President and update Geiser’s earlier study, published by CSHE in 2017, of test-score trends from 1994 to 2011. The updated sample includes over 1.6 million California high school graduates who applied to UC between 1994 and 2016.

Key findings:

  • Of all UC admissions criteria, SAT/ACT scores are most affected by family background. Compared to high school grades, for example, test scores exhibit much greater statistical bias against low-income, first-generation college, and underrepresented minority applicants. In part, this reflects differences in access to test prep and related activities designed to improve test-taking skills not taught in the regular classroom.

  • Test-score disparities have grown significantly in the past 25 years. Together, family income, education, and race now account for over 40% of the variance in SAT/ACT scores among UC applicants, up from 25% in 1994. (By comparison, family background accounted for less than 10% of the variance in high school grades during this entire time) The growing effect of family background on SAT/ACT scores makes it difficult to rationalize treating scores purely as a measure of individual merit or ability, without regard to differences in socioeconomic circumstance.

  • Fairness in testing requires that colleges and universities take account of socioeconomic differences in reviewing SAT/ACT scores to level the playing field for students from disadvantaged families. UC’s “holistic” admissions process takes account of family income and education in reviewing applicants’ test scores, but in California, Proposition 209 bars UC from taking account of race. California is one of eight states to bar consideration of race and ethnicity in public university admissions.

  • Race/ethnicity has an independent statistical effect on SAT/ACT scores after controlling for family income and parental education, Geiser’s analysis shows. The conditioning effect of race on SAT/ACT scores has increased substantially in the past 25 years, mirroring the massive re-segregation of California public schools over the same period. California schools are now among the most segregated in the nation. Statistically, race has become more important than either income or education in accounting for test-score differences among California high school graduates who apply to UC.

  • If UC cannot legally consider the conditioning effect of race and racial segregation on test performance, Geiser argues, neither should it consider SAT/ACT scores. Continuing to employ the SAT/ACT under the constraints of Prop 209 means accepting adverse statistical impacts on Latinx and Black applicants beyond what is warranted by the marginal utility of the tests to predict student performance at UC. Race-blind implies test-blind admissions.

The chapter concludes with an analysis of options for replacing or eliminating the SAT/ACT in UC admissions. These include test-optional and test-flexible, Strivers’ approach (statistically adjusting scores for SES), moving to curriculum-based achievement tests that reward content learning over test-taking skills, and employing tests for UC eligibility rather than admissions selection. Standardized tests are fairer and more effective as a tool for “certifying competence,” Geiser argues – assessing whether applicants are academically qualified – than for selecting whom to admit from among the pool of qualified applicants.

Full discussion/study here:

And another study:

1 Like

That’s not what Im saying. My point is universities have different academic standards. If students cant do 8th grade math, maybe they shouldn’t be admitted to a top tier university (at least not STEM) - not that they shouldnt have access to higher education.

If there are no academic standards, why not make it a lottery like I mentioned earlier.

4 Likes

Yes, and different universities have different goals and priorities. Like we often see with public vs private colleges for the myriad of reasons that we have discussed ad nauseam on this thread.

I don’t understand this…so you are saying weak math students can attend a top tier uni, just not for STEM? Then it would seem there is no problem with the UCs and their admission practices?

I have no idea what proportion of the 12% of UCSD weak math students that led to the formation of the working group 1 are going to end up as STEM majors, but I would expect not many.

Isnt that what the professors are asking for? Standardized testing for STEM majors? I dont think it’s the English teachers complaining about 8th grade math.

“UC Berkeley math professor Zvezdelina Stankova said in an NPR interview that some engineering students don’t understand how 1/2 + 1/3 = 5/6”

I understand why the professors are concerned. I don’t realistically think any student who can’t do the above problem is going to graduate as an engineering major. If they did graduate with an engineering degree, then UCSD is part of the problem. Seriously, the state of our education system at every level is sad and frustrating.

The point is not whether they’ll graduate with an engineering degree. The professors are concerned that several students are failing out of a basic calculus class when they are completely unprepared and they believe standardized tests would’ve screened them out.

1 Like

I don’t understand why the UCs can’t use the math placement tests they currently make many incoming first years take to weed out those that can’t do the above math problem. By weed out, I mean they can’t start as an engineering or math major if they can’t do math at the level required. That seems so simple.

2 Likes

No clue. If that was an effective solution, why would they be insisting on standardized testing. That’s my whole point. These professors are asking for a reason.

Since we are back to the profs asking for some mysterious reason, yet we should accept this because, well, they are profs, I will bow out of this particular conversation.

1 Like

Just because we dont know doesnt mean there isnt a legitimate reason. The UC committee is considering it. I doubt we’d have 1400 signatures and a formal review if they could use some alternative method like a placement test. Im just going with the most logical explanation that there’s a reason - we’re just not privy to it.

https://edsource.org/updates/uc-committee-will-consider-whether-to-bring-back-sat-act-requirement-in-admissions

1 Like

But if the UCs did this - required a math placement test to be able to enroll in the major they have been accepted into - is this really better serving students than seeing where the preparation is prior to acceptance? I think there would be a pretty huge outcry if students were precluded from enrolling in majors they were accepted into - and for very good reasons.

This article indicates that part of the disconnect isn’t just not being prepared for Calculus, which they have a remedial path to accommodate, but needing significant remediation that really precludes them from being successful in the STEM majors. Obviously the root of the problems are in secondary and elementary school - but admitting students who can’t succeed in the major doesn’t really benefit anyone.

UC freshmen increasingly are not ready for college math. Some professors want to require the SAT again | EdSource

1 Like

If they do go back to SAT/ACT required, they will likely go back to where it had relatively low weight compared to other factors, and we will return to seeing complaints from high SAT/ACT but lower GPA applicants getting disappointing UC results.

2 Likes

Sure. But if a kid who wants to study engineering gets a 490 on their math section - probably a red flag. I assume the AOs would scrutinize the rest of their application pretty closely.

1 Like

They admit by major, so all admitted engineering students are already starting as engineering majors. The system at the UCs and many other public universities in the US (and other countries, too, it’s the same in Canada at least…) is to give them a chance to sink or swim in the first year weed-out classes, then weed out the bottom X% of them by failing some. Then yes, they can attempt to switch to another major or drop out and spend a year or two at community college, etc. For better or worse, this is the way the system traditionally works (and I know this is not news to you, this is just a response to your comment). They expect a certain number of students to be weeded out this way, but the professors are upset because they are having to fail and weed out a higher number of students than expected.

Edited to add: It would arguably be worse for students at, say, UCB, if a student was admitted as an engineering major and enrolled on May 1, and then pre-weeded out by math placement tests in the summer and tracked into a non-STEM major. This student wouldn’t even be given a chance to struggle and possibly succeed, they’d be stuck with a major they didn’t choose and it would be difficult to then get back into the STEM major they wanted.

I appreciate there are no easy answers.

1 Like

The issue isn’t a dramatically increased number of engineers are failing out of classes. Example % of failing grades in 2019 and 2025 are below in example courses a Berkeley engineering student might take during freshmen year.

Berkeley % ‘F’ + ‘NP’ grades from 2019 → 2025
Math 52 (Calc II): 9% → 9%
Math 53 (Calc III): 3.5% → 3%
Physics 7A (Physics for STEM majors): 3% → 3%
Physics 7B (Physics for STEM majors): 2% → 2%
Engin 7 (CS for Engineers): 2% → 3%
Engin 26 (3D Design Modeling): 1% → 1%

The issue highlighted in the UCSD report was more that a dramatically increased portion of students are doing poorly on math placement tests such that they are not starting out in equivalent to Math 52 like the example above. Instead the portion of students starting in remedial math increased by a large factor. For the most part, these remedial math kids were are not engineering majors. In the UCSD report, 3% of Jacobs School of engineering students were placed in Math 2 (remedial math). The majors with largest number of Math 2 students were biology and psychology BS.

These Math 2 students often had limited success in later math courses as well, which often led to switching majors. For example, a psychology BS students might switch to psychology BA, which does not require calc. The report mentions that the rare few engineering students that start at Math 2 are unlikely to complete an engineering major.

1 Like

I think this may oversimplify the current reality and potential solutions. Starting in 2020 (because of a drop in math performance before the UCs dropped the standardized tests, Berkeley started a program where entering students could study pre-calculus over the summer.

Such a program combined with a placement test could rectify the issue you raise. Say for example there was a placement test available which filtered students into the pre-calc program, they could then continue on with the calc curriculum upon successful completion.

Also, I found this interesting . . .

Recognizing the scale of this challenge, the University of California’s Office of the President approached Paulin with a proposal to adapt “Foundations of Lower Division Mathematics” for high school students. The University of California system partners with a nonprofit, the National Education Opportunity Network, to make college credit-bearing courses available in low-income high schools. Knowing that some teachers wouldn’t have math backgrounds, Paulin broke down his materials into smaller pieces with detailed instructions.

“It’s an awesome model, and it was very fortuitous when they contacted me,” said Paulin. “This is very targeted, especially for vulnerable groups. It was a monumental task, but it all came together.”

Last fall, teachers at four schools used Paulin’s materials in their classrooms for three hours a week. “Foundations of Lower Division Mathematics” was part of a handful of courses — and the only one from UC Berkeley — that the state is testing(link is external) as part of a pilot project. Paulin expects the high school class to run again next fall on a larger scale.

Not sure if the program will be successful, but IMO this is an good example of at least trying to address the real issue – differential levels of preparation – without further scapegoating disadvantaged kids in order to further advantage kids who already have most of the educational advantages.

(edited ot fix date)

1 Like

Yes, there are definitely resources available to help students navigate the curriculum, and it’s not inconsistent with what I said, I think. My main point is that the strategy at these schools is to assume X% of students will be weeded out, and the first-year courses are designed to do some weeding… but the flip side of this is that everyone admitted as an engineer is given the opportunity to become one, if they can survive the weed-out lower division curriculum. That’s not at all inconsistent with giving students additional resources that will give them the opportunity to survive and thrive, including multiple on-ramps to the lower division curriculum. They will still have to make it through the lower division curriculum and there is still an expectation that some percent will be weeded out; that is, these institutions aren’t operating on the principle that everyone entering is going to graduate with their intended degree.

2 Likes

Are these placement tests given before or after they are accepted by the university?

There is no mystery. The professors (many of them) have made it crystal clear that they have witnessed a foundational drop in the college readiness of their students compared to the past when standardized testing screened out these students.

It is possible to be ready for a particular college or university and not ready for another.

3 Likes