If they want instate tuition, they could also just go to community college.
My question was, when thousands of schools are accepting and educating kids with wide ranging levels of preparation, why can’t Berkeley figure out how to do this?
Rather than answering the question, the responses indicate that “they” don’t belong at Berkeley . . .
The question remains unanswered.
Because Berkeley aims to educate its much-better-than-average students to much-higher-than-average standards?
Does everyone belong at Berkeley though? Or if one disagrees with the definition of Berkeley’s mission as attempted above, does everyone belong at an institution that is indeed driven by such a mission? Do we even need such institutions?
So does my rhetorical question-slash-statement above.
Should there continue to be a place for highly-selective (or highly-rejective as some like to call them) highly rigorous institutions in American educational landscape, or would it be better to have a more homogenized educational experience across the board?
@mtmind, we’ve been butting heads for a while in many threads on many topics, and contrary to what it might look like, I value and respect your contributions even if we disagree more often than not.
As they say, it is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.
I like to believe that I could formulate an argument favoring more equitable approach under the assumption that the primary role of “elite” educational institutions is to serve as social lifts for the greater shared common good - although admittedly not as convincingly as you would.
An argument contrary to that might rely on individualistic values of personal merit and individual success, but that is an argument that is easily diminished if not defeated by diving into discussions of social correlates of achievement etc. We’ve all been over this many times.
The way I personally see this is primarily through the lens of America’s global competitiveness. It may be tempting to view spots at the proverbial Berkeleys (or HPYSM or whathaveyou’s) as prizes to be given out or musical chairs to be danced around in a world where America’s position of scientific and technological dominance is undisputed.
But ultimately, my concern is that this is not the world we are living in, and that we are rearranging the chairs on a sinking ship of American education system to ensure everyone goes down together.
Of course, American global competitiveness requires both - a much better educated average, and an unsurpassable top. But while I think it is difficult to make an argument that the former of these goals depends on everyone getting into various Berkeleys (though it would be nice to have more students qualified to do so), I do believe the latter goal definitively requires that Americas most promising students are pushed to the limits of their abilities. Is there a place for elite institutions fulfilling this goal (even assuming we might not always agree with how we determine who is more or less promising)?
Can you assume my good faith (or at least entertain it if you are unable to accept it:), and see where our arguments might meet?
I think that they could do it. Two questions might be: Would they want to? What would it take away? There are tradeoffs all over the place for most things in life.
I never attended UC Berkeley (I did very seriously consider it at one point). At least in my experience at a different highly ranked university, if they is any education difference at all for highly ranked universities such as UC Berkeley, the difference is that professors can assume that every student is well prepared and academically very capable. This means that classes can go faster and cover more material. They can assign more homework and more difficult homework. Exams can be more difficult.
If you are going to lose 1/3 of the class, then you can’t do this. Then highly ranked universities become the same as more average universities, with only a name and a reputation as being different (and that could fade over time).
This might make someone wonder why any student would want more homework and more difficult exams. To me this is a bit like asking why I would want to play chess against someone ranked 1500 when I could instead play against someone ranked 1200. At some point some of us might just want to find out whether we can do it.
Personally I think that it is entirely reasonable for universities to exist that are aimed at the academically best prepared and strongest and most determined students. For public universities, this might only make sense in a state which is large enough for there to be multiple public universities, which certainly describes California. Of course the long list of excellent public universities in California provides lots of other options for students who find that UC Berkeley is not a good fit.
UC Berkeley does not need to be the university for everyone. This might be a luxury resulting from the fact that California has so many excellent public universities.
The main focus about UC has been early level math proficiency. The norm for highly selective private universities in US is to give entering freshmen a math proficiency test, then based on test result, goals, and other factors decide where student should start. There are typically a wide variety of different math starting points and different math levels of rigor.
For example, in a previous year prior to test optional, Stanford offered the following possible starting points in math. The kids with weak HS math preparation who are taking the online summer bridge (SOAR) are not slowing down the kids in more rigorous classes like the Math 60s series.
- Online Summer Bridge (SOAR math) – Extra pre-calc preparation prior to taking Math 19-20
- Math 19-21 – 3 quarter version of single variable calculus
- Math 41-42 – 2 quarter version of single variable calculus
- Math 51-53 – differential and integral calculus in several variables, linear algebra, and ordinary differential equations
- Math 61-63M – covers the material of the Math 50 series at a much more advanced level with an emphasis on rigorous proofs and conceptual arguments
- Math 61-63DM – covers the same linear algebra material as the Math 60CM series and otherwise focuses on topics in discrete mathematics, algebra, and probability theory at an advanced level with an emphasis on rigorous proofs
Whether exams, homework, and similar are more difficult than other colleges depends on other factors. At private colleges like HYPS… there is a strong pressure towards grade inflation with the overwhelming portion of students getting A’s, but exams can still be made difficult with a generous curve. For example, in the past, I’ve had exams at Stanford where 40% was an A. Having taking classes at both a UC (not UCB or UCLA) and Stanford, I’d estimate on average classes had more challenging grading at UCs when I attended, likely more rigorous on average as well. The issue wasn’t that UC students were more prepared than Stanford students. It was the UC classes seemed more willing to give students non-A grades, with less hand holding and more opportunity to fall through cracks with less rigorous support systems.
Berkeley has been the gold standard for public university STEM education for generations. Having our best students work with our top professors matters a great deal…for our economy and our national security.
Instead of focusing on admitting the Mechanical Engineering applicants who are actually highly skilled in mathematics, UC Berkeley has to decide between the ME applicant who swam, the ME applicant who did debate and the ME applicant who sang in the choir.
The mission of public colleges is different than that of private colleges, so I don’t see Berkeley or UCLA the same as HYPSM.
Beyond the typical college admission factors, UC leaders want students in the state to have access to the UCs. These schools are also looking to be engines of social mobility and to train state residents for jobs that the state’s employers demand. The UC first year review comprehensive review factors are here.
With regard to the access piece, one of the goals of each of the UC schools is to admit/enroll students from a large proportion of the high schools in the state. 63% of the public high schools in California are title 1 high schools, defined as those that have a significant proportion of low-income students. These high schools qualify for federal funding. Similarly, 64% of California K-12 students are socioeconomically disadvantaged (e.g., qualify for reduced or free lunch, and/or are migrant/homeless/foster kids.)
Often, students from Title 1 schools and socioeconomically disadvantaged backgrounds can be less prepared for college because of the nature of the K-12 school system they attended, their home situation…all the things we all know. If the UCs don’t enroll students from the Title 1 high schools, they are not going to succeed with their access or social mobility goals. They would also be failing their tax payers and residents.
Even if the UCs go back to requiring tests, I doubt much will change. All of the UCs will continue to admit/enroll students from a large proportion of the state’s high schools, because that is their goal/mission/priority…they can’t neglect the majority of the state’s students who are economically disadvantaged. If they did, they would be primarily enrolling relatively affluent students…that does not fit their goals, nor would that be politically acceptable, for obvious reasons.
I am not against testing at all, and generally feel colleges can have the policy they want. The UC leaders need to weigh many factors, and some of those factors have a natural tension between them. And politics, always politics. That’s why you never hear UC leaders say something like ‘we only want to enroll the best and brightest’.
Same here.
While ASU and other institutions are certainly education a wide variety of students, there is a significant difference in graduation rate between ASU and Berkeley. ASU’s 4 year graduation rate is on 52% with a 6 year rate of 68% and only 86% of first years returning for a second year. Berkeley is sitting at 81% for 4 years and 93% of 6 years and 97% of their freshman returning. While money is often a driver in these statistics, preparation can absolutely play a role.
Finding “highly skilled” in math students is not really what the SAT and ACT do, since their ceilings are not that high (their target market is the academic masses, not the academic elites). Any very highly selective college (or division or major in a college) will be comparing among an overflow of applicants at the ceilings of academic indicators (courses and grades, and SAT/ACT scores if used) who swam, debated, sang, etc.. At least the UCs are not using the purely inherited characteristic of legacy status, unlike most very highly selective colleges.
In any case, first year UCB engineering retention was back up to 97% for the 2023 entry cohort, after dipping to 95-96% for the 2020* to 2022 entry cohorts. So it is not like many UCB engineering students had trouble with first year math (if that was even the reason for non-retention of 3-5% of first years over the recent years), either during the test-required or test-blind admission periods.
*Note that the 2020 entry cohort was the last to be admitted under test-required, having completed their applications by the end of 2019, before COVID-19 disruptions came to the US.
Sounds like the students who are enrolling at Berkeley are graduating and succeeding. That seems like a good thing, even tho we know some of them were under prepared for college. That particular statistic would not make me think a return to test required admissions is necessary.
I am aware of that. What the SAT can do is weed out students that score below middle school math levels, which, according to actual UC professors, is a current problem for them.
First, I think many of the posters here are drastically underestimating the quality of students admitted to Berkeley, UCLA, and the rest of the UCs. There are standards in place, there are requirements. These kids are generally creme of their respective crops. The kids who are now being admitted are very similar to the kids who have long been admitted. Standardized test scores were relatively underweighted at the UCs long before the UCs went test blind. To suddenly portray this is as somehow a failing system is just not accurate. It is hyperbolic in the extreme.
For example, in the UCSD study that initially started all this commotion (the report heavily relied upon in the letter), one in eight UC students didn’t meet their standard for high school math proficiency. 12.5%. Too high, yes. But this was during the worst of Covid and immediately after UCSD greatly expanded its admissions into low resource communities, to get in line with their mission. Perhaps most significantly, this 12.5% included not just STEM majors, but all admitted– art majors, dance majors, music majors, language majors, all majors.
So let’s not exaggerate what’s happening. It is not of the magnitude some are suggesting, and it not necessarily caused by dropping the tests nor will it be remedied by reinstating the tests.
Second, I think it comes down to divergent views of the proper role of public universities, or or perhaps education generally. In short, many here don’t seem to agree with the mission of the UC system.
Berkeley and UCLA are not MIT and Cal Tech. As others have noted, they are publicly funded institutions, and their mission is to educate and serve all of California’s many diverse communities. Not just the rich kids. Not just the kids of highly educated parents working in tech. Not just kids lucky enough to attend high performing schools. They also serve low income communities, rural communities, communities where parents have little formal education, communities where the quality of preparation is lacking.
Admitting kids from these communities isn’t just for the benefit of these kids, it is for the benefit of all of us. Our prosperity and security rely on finding and encouraging talent even among the less privileged.
Here is how the UCSD Senate-Administration Workgroup described it (in the report that started this latest math prep panic) . . .
Given that, as a public university, we are charged by the Board of Regents to serve all segments of California’s college-aged students, we cannot simply admit only from better-resourced schools, this would replicate privilege and fail to support our mission as an institution that promotes social mobility. From a more practical perspective, we would also be unable to meet our enrollment targets. This situation goes to the heart of the present conundrum: in order to holistically admit a diverse and representative class, we need to admit students who may be at a higher risk of not succeeding (e.g., with lower retention rates, higher DFW rates, and longer time-to-degree). The workgroup recognizes that there are not simple solutions but makes recommendations that attempt to find a middle ground.
So, yes, tradeoffs (of a sort) are made, but this has always been the case in the UC system (or at least this is how it is supposed to work), and it is probably one of the reasons why standardized test scores have long played a relatively minor role in UC admissions (and why the UCLA and UCB standardized test scores have always been much lower on average than other elite institutions.) Yet despite deemphasized test scores long before the the UCs went test blind, these are World Class institutions. I would argue this is, in part, because of their admission policies, not in spite of them.
Seems good plan if the goal is to segregate the UC system along the lines of wealth and educational advantage. You went to high school where? Congratulations! You are Berkeley material!
What percentage of mechanical engineering majors at UCB enter not being able to do middle school math? Or is this just another anecdote?
While we are at it . . . What minimum SAT score indicates competency with middle school math?
If the goal is to keep these kids out of calculus before they are ready, wouldn’t a placement test work just as well?
The Senate task force study referenced above found that the combination of SAT + SES only explained 4% of variance in graduation rate for students in UC system. Less selective colleges with a wider variation in SAT scores show a similar type of pattern. For example, the study at https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=7306&context=etd found ACT score explained 4% of variation in graduation rate at what I expect is Utah State.
That said, I don’t doubt that ASU has a far lower graduation rate than Berkeley and student preparation is one contributing factor. The study at Preparing to download ... was able to explain ~80% of variance in differences in graduation rate at different colleges. The most significant contributing factors are listed in table below, from high to low. By far the most influential factor in predicting graduation rate was % receiving Pell grants. I expect a more direct measure of affordability after FA would rank similarly high. 40% at ASU receive Pell grants, and 28% at Berkeley receive Pell grants.
Exactly! This is what smart students crave. It is the strong peer group that enables this.
In smaller states with only one major university, they attempt to replicate this with some success through an Honors College. The top students take honors classes together which are more demanding.
In contrast, the numerous UC campuses mean that the strongest students get concentrated into a few colleges. In contrast, Merced gets a student profile that’s weaker than the University of Iowa, in large part because of a low concentration of strong students. The University of Arizona would be a far better alternative, if affordable.
Of course smart students want this, this is one of the natural tensions of the competing priorities of a state school. In reality, stronger students do tend to congregate in stronger majors. And as they complete gen eds, the stronger students will end up in many of the same classes. Of course there are different levels of gen eds too, especially in certain subjects, like math.
UCB and UCLA can’t only admit the top stat students from the state, they specifically look to admit the top students from many/most high schools. (I don’t think changing this is on the table?)
The top students from the weakest high schools (which are the poorest, and often have high proportions of students of color) might fall in the 3rd or even 4th quartile at a high performing high school. Enrolling these students is part of the access mission of the UCs.
A majority of California students are Pell grant qualifiers, which means they can’t afford Iowa or Arizona.
In the big picture, and this is another issue the UCs face, the strongest California students who are Pell grant qualifiers can often attend a meet full need school for a lower cost than any of the UCs. So, some of those students choose to leave the state.
Separately, I pulled some historical data.
I can’t find UCB’s 2019-2020 CDS, the last one from before the pandemic, so I used 2018-19.
Mid 50% scores of enrolled students:
SAT EBWR 640-740 SAT Math 660-790
ACT Comp 28-34 ACT math 27-35
12.3% of the class scored in the 500s on math, 1.3% of the class scored in the 400s on each of math and ebwr.
I looked at UCSD’s 2019-20 CDS (since their faculty has raised the math preparedness issue)
SAT mid 50% 1250-1470. EBRW 610-710, Math 620-780.
So, 25% of the class had a math score below 620 (16% of the class scored in the 500s for math, 1% in the 400s.) I don’t know if today’s class distribution would look different if these students took tests. I expect it would be lower but who knows?
With the rise of grade inflation, math and reading/writing unpreparedness, I don’t think we are going to see higher enrolled test scores than pre-pandemic, should the UCs require tests again.
Fundamentally, requiring tests is not going to change the in-state pool of students from which the UCs are admitting and enrolling the majority of their students. The pool is going to score what they score on tests, and the schools will choose their students using their 14 factors which includes test scores, or not. To make things more complicated, that pool of students is declining. The UC system has a number of headwinds, it’s up to the leaders to decide if requiring tests fits in their overall plan.
For clarification’s sake . . . what are we talking about here?
Are we talking about figuring out a way to make sure the kids are prepared for the classes in which they will enroll? Or are we talking about keeping the kids deemed unworthy out of schools like Berkeley, so the worthy kids don’t have to deal with the distraction? It sure seems like it is the latter.
Also, if the hot house flowers can only learn in rarified environments, how is that schools like UCLA and UCB are considered first class educational institutions?
Like @Mwfan1921 I’ve looked at some of the CDS forms, and when the tests were required UCLA was admitting about a quarter of the class with SAT Math scores below 600. How could the hot house flowers with their high SAT scores learn anything?
If wealth is the primary determinant of academic success, how do you explain schools like Stuyvesant High School, where a large share of students come from low-income families? Approximately half of its students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, yet the school consistently produces exceptional academic outcomes.
If you give poor kids access to educational opportunities, including access to great schools, they will thrive. Stuyvesant is a good example of that.
An example on the university level is UCLA, the best public school in the nation (eat it, UCB
). According to the Chetty study, among “Elite” schools:
-
UCLA admits the highest percentage of low and middle income students by a significant margin.
-
Despite CAs pockets of extreme wealth, UCLA has the lowest median parental income, again by a significant margin.
-
UCLA is first among elite schools in the “Overall Mobility Index.”
This while admitting about a quarter of the class with SAT Math scores below 600.
I don’t believe that squeezing out the poor kids (who generally don’t test as well) would make UCLA a better institution.
@mtmind and other posters on this thread, what do you all think would be the academic outcome at the end of their 12th grade, if all the NY poor kids entering Stuyvesant as 9th graders and all the CA poor kids entering an under-resourced high school in California as 9th graders, are swapped?
To make my question more precise, let the academic outcome (this is admittedly a little vague, but what I have in mind is the mastery of the 5 core high school subjects, averaged over the group of kids, but you may also view it as the average SAT/ACT/AP scores or define it your own way) after 4 years be denoted as:
A = NY poor kids @ Stuyvesant
B = CA poor kids @ Stuyvesant
C = NY poor kids @ under-resourced CA HS
D = CA poor kids @ under-resourced CA HS
I suspect we all agree with @mtmind’s post quoted above that A > D. However, it is unclear where B and C, which are hypothetical scenarios, would fall. So, in your opinion:
-
Would B > C or B < C?
-
If you think B > C, would B ≃ A? Would C ≃ D?
-
If you think B < C, would C ≃ A? Would B ≃ D?
I’ve been following this thread but haven’t posted in a while. Curious to hear your opinion, and the rationale behind it if you choose to provide. Sorry I couldn’t think of a better way than using alphabets to phrase my questions, and sorry if I’m taking the discussion in an irrelevant direction. @mtmind’s and @CFP’s and @Mwfan1921’s posts make me think of asking this.
Mods: if this post is off-topic, feel free to move or delete it. Thank you.
