Trying to follow your logic here . . . it seems like you are saying that the tests are unnecessary at almost all of the colleges and universities in the county . . . kids with various levels of preparation, from excellent to substandard, attend and are educated, becoming engineers, scientists, teachers, etc.
Yet, it is a somehow a national educational crisis when the tests are not required at the tiny minority of the most elite schools . . . somehow it is impossible for these schools to educate their students without using the tests in admissions? Do I have that right? My question is, if ASU can educate its students without using the tests for admissions, why can’t Berkeley?
Even more so in the comments at the end. It disturbed me how much the students struggled with the Bleak House text, but it also disturbed me how the blog post readers discussed the students as though they were talking about zoo animals. (And then displayed their erudition to each other by doing things like quoting the Septuagint in Greek. That’s fun and all, I enjoy a good chat about the Septuagint myself, but it’s beside the point of college students’ reading skills.)
So, Zvezda Stankova really cares about students and also elementary math education. She is the founder and head of Berkeley Math Circle. I’ve known her (in a peripheral sort of way) for a long time, because our kids (2026 HS grads) have been in the same class in school since K. Back then, I remember how she put time into working with the school’s math department to make practical improvements. She has high standards for students, but she’s fundamentally a good egg, and I wouldn’t make light of her perspective even if you disagree with it.
Gotta push back here. Former Classics major who has been waiting almost 50 years for someone to cite the Septuagint in a non-academic publication geared to scholars of antiquity.
I studied it at Hebrew U as part of a Masters, and nothing would make me happier than to chat about it any time for fun… but, lack of knowledge of the Septuagint in the original Greek is not the reason these students had trouble with Bleak House!
But surely there is a part of you that wishes that somewhere in America a high schooler is thinking “Hey, why NOT study Greek instead of starting my own non-profit to encourage 6 year old’s entrepreneurial instincts so I can get into a good college”.
But will these professors be satisfied at these “other schools?” As @ucbalumnus and others have pointed out many times over, almost all the top universities have long needed math tracks for kids who arrive less prepared. This all predated test blind and test optional admissions.
Well not all of them are educated - ASU has a substantially higher drop out rate than Berkeley. 4 year rates are 81% vs 55% Money is often the driver, but preparation may also factor in.
She and 1000? other professors want standardized testing. That’s their request. She can go to a school that’s test required.
Will they be satisfied? Who knows. But it’s what they want and it’s obviously very important to them. She’s giving interviews and leading the charge on this topic.
I don’t know what will happen either, and the BOARS (part of the Academic Senate) recommendation isn’t due for eleven months.
I heard this quote today from an admissions/enrollment leader to a counselor: “Professors have to teach the students we have, not the students they wish we had.”
I did want to point out that along with BOARS working group 1 evaluating whether SAT/ACT tests should be considered in admissions (also evaluating using Smarter Balanced), there is a BOARS working group 2 that is looking at potentially changing A-G subject requirements.
Returning to test required or making major changes to A-G requirements will require Regents approval. The earliest the policies could change would be for the 2028-2029 application cycle.
Working Group 1 charge:
Charge: Workgroup 1 (WG1) will consider the use of standardized tests in the first-year admissions process. Compared to UC’s current test-free policy for standardized test scores, WG1 will investigate the advantages and disadvantages of relying on SAT/ACT scores and/or 11th grade Smarter Balanced Assessment ELA/Math scores for use in the admission of first-year California resident and non-resident applicants, as these tests may have evolved since 1) the STTF’s recommendations were provided in January 2020 and 2) standardized test requirements were eliminated for the first-year cohort entering in Fall 2021. WG1 will provide recommendations about whether standardized tests should be used for admissions or not. As part of their deliberations, WG1 will consider guiding principle #5 within Section II of BOARS’ Guidelines which states that “[f]aculty on individual campuses should be given flexibility to create admission policies and practices that, while consistent with Universitywide criteria and policies, are also sensitive to local campus values and academic priorities.”
Working Group 2 charge:
Charge: Workgroup 2 (WG2) will conduct an overarching review of the UC’s current A-G framework to determine whether A-G requirements adequately prepare first-year applicants for success after matriculation at the UC. WG2 will provide recommendations about whether the current A-G framework should be modified or not. If WG2 concludes that modifications to the UC’s current A-G framework are necessary, WG2 will recommend specific modifications as well as investigate the advantages and disadvantages of removing and/or replacing existing course requirements and/or subject areas within the A-G framework. WG2 will not consider the addition of new subjects beyond the seven (A-G) subject areas, nor additional courses beyond the 15 total, unless an equivalent number of subjects or course requirements are removed from the existing A-G requirements.
Obviously BOARS could recommend changes in neither of these areas, both, or just one. Then things will be in the hands of the Regents.
Am I reading too much into this, or is this a hint that BOARS is likely to recommend the policy supported by faculty at Berkeley/UCLA? Sticking with test-free at these campuses does not seem like it would be in like with the quoted guiding principle, considering faculty’s opinions on the matter.
UC originally gave the campuses the option of test optional or test blind during COVID-19-related SAT/ACT access problems. However, a lawsuit claiming that test optional was unfair forced their hand to make test blind the only option.
The referenced faculty senate task force review discussed above also gave a partial okay for test blind, but explicitly did not recommend test optional. As stated in the quote below, some members of the Senate Task Force recommended that UC go test blind prior to the new replacement tests being available, while others recommended waiting until new tests are available before removing SAT/ACT. However, the report more explicitly states that the Senate Task Force did not recommend going test optional.
Members of the Task Force differed on the question of whether to recommend that UC cease consideration of standardized test scores sooner — in all likelihood before availability of the replacement suite of assessments. The differences reflected uncertainty within the Task Force, given the data available to us, over the relative risks and benefits of possible, additional steps that UC should take to ensure that the population of admitted students reflects the diversity of the state.
.
The Task Force considered, but does not recommend, the following possibilities.
.
The Task Force does not recommend that UC make standardized tests optional for applicants at this time. UC should conduct additional research on the impact of going “test optional” before deciding whether and how to implement such a policy. STTF had pragmatic concerns about how campuses would evaluate and compare applicants who submit standardized test scores relative to applicants who do not; whether and how campuses would impute, explicitly or implicitly, test scores to applicants; and ethical concerns about how to treat students in the two groups fairly…"