Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

Costs money to offer a “free” SAT or ACT, and not all states think that the SAT or ACT is the best way to do state assessment tests, including for students not going to colleges where SAT or ACT is used.

1 Like

Per the SAT site locator there are zero seats available in Los Angeles County, and zero seats within 50 miles of my location. The nearest available seat to my location is over 80 miles away, with NO public transportation option. Uber would be $200+. If the student happened to have access to a reliable car, it could be between 2-3 hours each way, depending on LA congestion, to an unfamiliar location. While it might be no big deal for some, it would be a major burden for families who lack resources.

This is just another of the many examples of how the SATs are a game for the rich. Making under resourced families play is just an indirect way of keeping them out. Why not be more direct?

1 Like

I graduated high school in California in the early 90s from an extremely low resource school with a drop out rate over 60% This was when the SAT was required and it was much, much easier to get a seat in those days compared to these statistics you’re citing. I don’t know anyone who had difficulty taking the SAT (no one had ever heard of the ACT when I was in high school in California).

I think California moving away from requiring the test is a huge disservice to low income students as it essentially severely limits access and locks them into California public options. My cheapest options by far were private, out of state schools that met full financial need.

2 Likes

Most students (low income or otherwise) are not getting admitted to those private schools with the best financial aid (assuming the parents are not divorced).

1 Like

Why would this be the case when around 2,000 colleges are test blind or test optional?

I get not having a score locks them out of test required schools, but that’s not many schools. It also might lock out these students at some schools that have merit grids which require a test score to maximize merit.

But, there are many schools with big merit money for test optional students, as well as publics that don’t have a tuition premium for OOS students, and WUE (and other programs like WUE.)

2 Likes

Point taken, but spots had become scarce for under-resourced kids before the UCs dropped the test requirement. (Maybe because the kids with resources take the test over and over again.)

Also, IMO California has enough to worry about without basing its testing policy on making it more convenient for outlier kids to go private, out of state schools, (especially when many such schools are either test blind or test optional.)

You are repeating what I posted to you up thread. As I said previously , The low number of students taking the SAT in California likely reflects the fact that the California university system does not require standardized testing for admission. Therefore students taking it are likely those applying outside of California (and those wanting to use scores for math/english placement purposes in the csu system).

Ok.

I actually think a test can be helpful even if some of the universities are test optional - and we’ve seen a dramatic pendulum swing toward the test after the huge swing during Covid making it optional. Evaluating a FGLI student in a low resource school is tough enough without a test. It’s not just grade inflation, it’s giving a baseline at whether the student can be successful. I lived a low resource school and am very familiar with what’s available and the type of preparation that can be lacking.

1 Like

Well most students don’t go to a 4 university at all, so the state can just push all students to community college. And I’ll point out that this is a thread on the need blind private schools going back to requiring a test.

IMO, several dozen (primarily) highly rejective schools going back to requiring tests is not what I would call ‘dramatic’.

I read 3,000 apps this past admission cycle for a highly rejective school.

Yes, there is rampant grade inflation, but it is NOT difficult to sort through students who can and can’t do the work…because we have school profiles and transcripts. The students who took rigorous courses are obvious. What can be difficult is choosing between the many applicants who can do the work, fulfill institutional priorities, and make contributions to the school.

If a given college also wants to use test scores as one of its admissions decision factors, go for it. But 2,000 four year colleges, including some highly rejective schools, don’t think they need test scores to thoroughly evaluate applicants. It seems to me the industry has spoken loud and clear about the relative importance of SAT/ACT tests. Will some more schools go back to test required? Probably. Will it be hundreds? Nope.

Separately, this thread has turned to discussing whether or not the UCs will return to test required in a couple of years. Maybe they will, maybe they won’t. But, the UCs (like all state schools) have different priorities and goals when admitting a class, as compared to the private highly rejective schools, especially those we have seen return to test required (the initial focus of this thread.)

One of the goals of the UCs goals is to admit/enroll students from many high schools and areas of the state (see list below), including students who are disadvantaged and/or from disadvantaged HSs.

I would love to see the data regarding the UC math underperformers…I expect many are from disadvantaged high schools. Even if the UCs go back to test required, I wouldn’t expect the need for supports in math (and reading and writing for that matter) to go away because the UCs will still want to admit students from many HSs/areas of the state, including those who are disadvantaged.

Current UC factors in admission:

Based on campus-specific institutional goals and needs, admissions decisions will be based on a broad variety of factors:

  • Academic grade point average in all completed A-G courses, including additional points for completed UC-certified honors courses.

  • Number of, content of and performance in all A-G subject areas beyond the minimum requirements.

  • Number of and performance in UC-approved honors and Advanced Placement courses.

  • Identification by UC as being ranked in the top 9 percent of their high school class (“eligible in the local context,” or ELC).

  • Quality of a student’s senior-year program, as measured by the type and number of academic courses in any A-G subject area in progress or planned.

  • Quality of their academic performance relative to the educational opportunities available in their high school.

  • Outstanding performance in one or more academic subject areas.

  • Outstanding work in one or more special projects in any academic field of study.

  • Recent, marked improvement in academic performance, as demonstrated by academic GPA and the quality of coursework completed or in progress.

  • Special talents, achievements and awards in a particular field, such as visual and performing arts, communication or athletic endeavors; special skills, such as demonstrated written and oral proficiency in other languages; special interests, such as intensive study and exploration of other cultures; experiences that demonstrate unusual promise for leadership, such as significant community service or significant participation in student government; or other significant experiences or achievements that demonstrate the student’s promise for contributing to the intellectual vitality of a campus.

  • Completion of special projects undertaken in the context of a student’s high school curriculum or in conjunction with special school events, projects or programs.

  • Academic accomplishments in light of a student’s life experiences and special circumstances.

  • Location of a student’s secondary school and residence.

2 Likes

Hi, why do you think certainly highly rejective schools are going back to test required? I am interested in your views since you are reading so many apps for a highly rejective school; what are the factors that lead your school to go down a different path from other highly rejective schools? Thanks.

I read 3,000 apps this past admission cycle for a highly rejective school.

Yes, there is rampant grade inflation, but it is NOT difficult to sort through students who can and can’t do the work…because we have school profiles and transcripts. The students who took rigorous courses are obvious. What can be difficult is choosing between the many applicants who can do the work, fulfill institutional priorities, and make contributions to the school.

IMO it can be for a few reasons…

-predictive power/their data show TO students not performing as well as test submitters (I would prefer the schools publish/share said data and whether any differences are statistically significant)

-political reasons, coming from the trustees and/or state education boards

-desire for fewer apps

-the it-allows-us-to-better-identify-underresourced-talent reason

-other reasons I don’t know about LOL

The identify underresourced talent reason particularly is specious to me…there is quite a bit of data that show disadvantaged students don’t take tests at a high rate, they don’t prep or have access to prep even if they do take a test, those who need test accommodations frequently don’t get them, and even if they do have a decent score, they self select out of applying when they see the high test score ranges at some of these schools. Even when counselors encourage them to apply.

Time will tell if these schools get the mix they want of disadvantaged, first gen, students of color, etc. they say they would like.

If you listen to admissions people who have been at long time test optional schools, eg. Bowdoin (not where I work), it’s clear they can successfully identify students who can do the work even if they don’t have a test score. My understanding is that 50+ years of data at Bowdoin show no statistically significant difference in college GPA, or grad rates, or other outcomes between test submitters and non-submitters. I wish they would publish that.

Bates (and other schools) have published internal data that show no difference between submitters and non-submitters: 20-year Bates College study of optional SATs finds no differences | News | Bates College

Some may say that Bates hasn’t been a highly rejective school for long, with substantial overlap in applicants from Ivies and other highly rejective LACs, so yeah, that’s why Bowdoin’s data would be nice to see.

2 Likes

But how are you identifying the students who had no access to rigorous courses? There is rarely one scenario that fits all students. I am sharing my experience. At a school with a 60% drop out rate and less than 10% of students going on to a 4 year institutions. There were 3 AP courses total. I have no doubt most private schools have more than enough applications from FGLI students at good enough schools. And you can pick those students and ignore the student with a less than rigorous high school course load and assume they can’t succeed. I have a vested interest at remembering the students who truly had a LOW resource high school - I was one and have no doubt my test score gave schools the confidence to take a chance on me despite my less than stellar preparation.

Bowdin is an interesting school to bring up - they have a huge benefit of selection bias as most of these students would never even think to apply there if they had ever even heard of it.

I’m not sure what you mean…they applied. Whether thru the efforts of admissions, or their HS counselor, or a CBO etc.

I agree with all of this. There are students who get overlooked, or don’t even apply. It’s why many schools are investing in admissions staff focused on rural and/or disadvantaged students. There’s also the STARS network of rural schools.

There is no doubt that there are students like you who had a test score that helped them in admissions.

Exactly. Whether test required, test optional, or test blind.

In the big picture, the college admissions is not student centered. Never has been, never will be. Colleges will choose the testing policy that best suits the college, and how they want to identify/fill their class.

I use Bowdoin as an example because they were the first test optional school (1969), and have the most experience with a TO model. There’s less of a selection bias today simply because of admissions outreach efforts and partnerships with CBOs and orgs like Questbridge.

Awareness of colleges beyond one’s community college or state flagship or the one with the best football team is often lacking among disadvantaged students.

Many of the private schools have dedicated testing days and cover the cost of the SAT (you can opt out). They also do not open those days up to outside students in my experience.

On the topic of test scores and reading ability, this article covers a study of the reading abilities of English majors in a program with an average ACT of 22.4 (~1120 SAT)

From the blogpost:

I can’t help but read the authors’ own rationale as Straussian —

Funny. I was thinking exactly the same thing about the blogpost, but for a different reason. The intellectual and cultural elitism pervades like Dickens’ mud and fog.

It is dramatic.

The overwhelming majority of the 4,000 or so colleges & universities in the US admit pretty much everyone who applies (Arizona State is somewhere around 100 in the US News rankings, and they admit 90% of their applicants). If you admit pretty much everyone who applies to you, there is no point in requiring standardized tests.

Like it or not, the national buzz around college admissions, the political interest in college admissions and the reason most traffic comes to this website is because of the interest in the highly rejective schools.

Just out of curiosity, what proportion of applications are just as good (or very similarly impressive…) as those you recommend for acceptance? IE, do you reject two and accept one – could you fill your class three times with similarly talented/accomplished applicants?