Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

Currently, only UCI accepts SAT or ACT math scores (650 or 29 to place into calculus) for any kind of math placement. In all other cases, taking a math placement test (either campus-developed or outsourced like ALEKS) is required or recommended for math placement if one does not have accepted AP scores or college credit.

2 Likes

Could be, but the term is outdated per the American School Counselor Association. Some counselors would flame anyone who called them a guidance counselor. (I’ve seen it happen more than a few times)

Same with Washington as UW is mostly test blind.

1 Like

Maybe rather than burdening California high schools with an unneeded test, the UCs should just use parental income plus the quality of high school as a proxy.

A rich kid from a high performing high school who successfully completed a rigorous math program isn’t going to need much review, so the math professors will get their wish.

If the UCs mandates tests, students will force the high schools to run the tests.

1 Like

Yes. Because they are also applying out of state.

You think the students at low income, underperforming school have the pull to force their school to implement the tests? GMAB.

Out of curiosity I just checked availability for the next SAT sitting, near me. I am in Los Angeles County. There are currently zero seats available in Los Angeles County. Los Angeles County has about 10 million people.

Or they are applying to private schools. These are relatively well off kids who attend relatively high performing schools. They have access to the tests because they are relatively advantaged financially and educationally.

Predictably, these are families who insist that the SAT should be used by the UCs. Go figure?

2 Likes

Undertaking an activity without measuring the outcome is pointless whether the college wants to use the test result or not. Schools measuring their our own output is not a good situation. Incentives are not aligned. Testing is an essential need. Otherwise the quality of education will not improve.

1 Like

Yes- that is who typically would take the tests, as I already pointed out earlier, here: Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions - #2306 by jym626

2 Likes

There is zero evidence that requiring the SAT would improve the quality of education, or that it improved the quality of education in the many decades the UC’s required the test. Or that dropping the test has anything to do with creating the supposed drop in the quality of education. In fact the supposed drop in the quality of education seems to predate this change, and has many more plausible causes. It also seems the supposed drop is greatly exaggerated, and doesn’t seem to be unlike the challenges that even high performing universities have long faced.

In short, it seems like the cart is pulling the horse. Some people really want the tests, because they believe the tests will benefit those they believe are most deserving. This seems like just the latest rationalization to get to that desired result.

1 Like

It seems that these institutions want to improve the quality of the incoming students, not necessarily their own education. However, one could make an argument that the two are closely linked.

1 Like

Decades ago, when I applied to colleges, SAT or ACT was required at UCs and CSUs, and achievement tests (later called SAT subject tests) were required at UCs and some private schools.

But I recall having to go to high schools other than the one I attended in order to take those tests (one was a half hour drive on mostly freeway).

I also recall doing <15 minutes of test specific prep, which was doing the sample questions in the booklet with the sign up form. That was typical then, but apparently not now.

1 Like

Do we know as a fact that anyone who wants to take it cannot due to lack of space ? Serious question.

Well, at my kids’ high school there are always anecdotes of students having to go to Oregon or Nevada to take it, because they forgot to sign up in time. For financially comfortable families, this is merely a hassle… you can still take it on the date you wanted, and in the worst case you might have to set aside a couple days to fly somewhere and take a little vacation!

Of course, you can imagine that for a less financially comfortable student who attends an underfunded HS with barebones counseling, it might be more difficult to do things like: Find out about SAT dates and when you are supposed to sign up, have reliable internet access and time and space to study online, arrange and pay for reliable transportation to a test center (even if it’s “only” 30 min away), get time off work to go take it, etc.

1 Like

Yesterday I put in a random Bay area zip code for the August sitting and there were zero seats available in a 50 mile radius.

1 Like

addendum:
Looks like there are 3 sites in CA with some seats available for Aug 22 (DK how many seats) - they are located in Crescent City, CA, Coachella, CA and Mammoth Lakes, CA

My daughter graduated HS in a state where the ACT or SAT were graduation requirements. As such, they were administered in school, during a regular school day, for all juniors, and the one test was free. Serious questions - Why couldn’t all states/schools do that?

5 Likes

Because testing is not required for most CA colleges. This static analysis does not apply if testing becomes mandatory

All states can do that, it just costs money (and adds a day to the school calendar.)

I did mention above that IMO if the UCs do go back to test required, they would likely contract with CB for one school day test per year (run by the HSs.) One test isn’t likely enough for all students though, so weekend availability would also have to increase.

1 Like

It is a fact. This has been a problem since covid (not sure if it was an issue in CA before that.) Many HSs and counselors do not want to run weekend tests, and with the UCs/CSUs being test blind that gives them plenty of cover.

1 Like