California has had only about 400 or so SAT testing centers and far fewer ACT test sites across the whole state (that would have to change if there are new state system policies) so it can be very hard to find/secure/travel to a testing spot. The CA students with “perfect test scores” were likely taking standardized tests b/c they hope to attend college out of state. The state schools are not rejecting them in place of students who will have trouble handling the coursework. Colleges want their students to succeed.
Interesting table on the number of students who take the SAT, by state:
I’m not sure what you mean by ‘hometown’ (maybe home state?). Regardless, California students who graduate in the top 9% of their class are guaranteed admission to a UC.
That is most often Merced (R1, USNWR national uni rank #57 out of 434/there are about 2,400 four year non-profit colleges in the US), sometimes Riverside (R1, USNWR national uni rank #75).
Merced is under enrolled for undergrads, Riverside is in the midst of growing the size of their undergrad population.
I know some people aren’t happy with a Merced acceptance (top 13% USNWR, easily in the top 10% looking at the full cohort), but to say their state ‘doesn’t want them” is inaccurate, nor can I muster much sympathy for a student who can ‘only’ get into Merced of the UCs. Not to mention there are many excellent CSUs, some of which are also under enrolled at the undergrad level.
That table shows that SAT scores tend to be higher when a smaller percentage of students takes the SAT. This is rather unsurprising, since it reflects self-selection effects.
My point was to look at the small number taking it in CA. Many may not realize how hard it is to find and successfully register to take the SAT or ACT in CA.
% of SAT takers needs to be considered with % of ACT takers, since some states strongly favor one test or the other (and some use one of them as a universal state test).
California has only 3% taking the ACT as long with 26% taking the SAT. Washington appears similar, with 5% ACT and 29% SAT. Oregon and Alaska have 24% and 27% SAT, with 13% ACT.
People seem to assume some large number of California students take these tests and that is simply not true. Interesting that their numbers are similar to those three states. Those are not typically considered states where students are competitively vying for top scores and top spots as seems to be implied about CA
…and the SAT or ACT might just help them identify which kids require the remedial courses, so they don’t accidentally throw themselves to the wolves by enrolling in math courses that are over their heads and cause the profs (apparently) so much hand-wringing
UCs could choose to do that. Or they could use what they currently use for math placement…including Aleks PPL,other math placement exams/assessments/diagnostics, AP test scores and/or DE courses (different UCs have different practices). UCs could also use CAASPP if they wanted.
I don’t think UCs used SAT/ACT for math placement when they were previously test required…students still needed to take Aleks or whatever math exam was in place, maybe a UC expert from then can weigh in.
Given that so few are taking ACT or SAT in CA, this is going to be a major issue to overcome if the UCs decide to require a test.
Does anyone know the process of adding and staffing test sites? IE, is it mainly the SAT/ACT parent companies who handle it, or is it up to the states? Or do they work in tandem?
It is primarily on HS counselors to run tests at HSs (and HSs to open up their schools for free for test takers.) In addition to organizing the testing, counselors have to procure proctors for every room. CollegeBoard does pay a small honoraria to counselors and proctors, but nothing to the HS for use of the space.
Many California counselors, who are primarily social emotional counselors and not dedicated college counselors, are quite vocal regarding not wanting to do this work to benefit CollegeBoard. I agree this is one of many hurdles to requiring tests.
A few private schools in my area applied and got approved as test centers when it got too hard for kids to find spots at the big public school testing centers. It was not a big deal at all. Now there seem to be enough seats for the popular dates, the less popular dates, and even “past deadline” test takers seem to be able to find a convenient center if they’re willing to go out of their own town.
The proctors are typically NOT guidance counselors. I don’t know if they got a special waiver, but according to my teacher friends, any “instructional staffer or administrator” can proctor. So cafeteria worker no- gym teacher yes.
If California requires tests, the testing companies will make sure that testing will happen on a far broader scale. It is a bootstrapping issue. Nobody takes tests that are not required. And testing companies will not open testing centers if nobody is taking them.
Sometimes they are, regardless, that’s irrelevant. The test day coordinator, often a counselor (note we do not call counselors ‘guidance’ counselors any more) is in charge of getting proctors. And it can be difficult, I’ve done that job. There is nothing easy about running SAT/ACT tests, nor AP tests for that matter.
Further, in California, requiring weekend work for counselors/test coordinators will require union contract renegotiation in some districts.
As I (and others) have stated repeatedly on this thread, the testing companies don’t run the vast majority of tests, the HSs do.
Apparently about 26% of CA students take the SAT even though it is not required.
So there’s no “easy button” solution, like offering the counselors a decent monetary award for each testing site/exam date they manage? I would imagine that College Board (especially) and ACT stand to turn a tidy profit by expanding the testing apparatus in CA – so throw the counselors a nice bone for their help. (proctors too). It sounds like many aren’t too enthused to do the work, so maybe the invisible hand of profit can compel them.
Regardless, it seems they need to wait for the UC regents to provide a hefty demand increase by requiring an exam or at least going TO.
Who knows? ACT has lost significant market share and hasn’t provided counselors or proctors any incentives to run more tests.
I expect if California did go back to test required in a few years, that the state would focus on SAT, and maybe sign a statewide once per year school day deal with CB for testing, at least for the public schools.
They originally gave campuses the option of test optional or test blind when COVID-19 access problems first hit. But then a lawsuit came claiming that test optional was unfair to students with disabilities, with the result being that all campuses had to go test blind.
So the UC system going test optional is less likely than either staying test blind or going to test required.
Note that of the states with similar SAT and ACT taking percentages as California, the public universities in Washington are mostly test blind, while those in Oregon and Alaska are test optional.
Can’t speak to California. In my area, guidance counselors are still called guidance counselors, and while I’m sure it’s difficult, so is managing and maintaining a heavy travel schedule for soccer and tennis and football and basketball involving buses and chaperones and out of state tournaments- and somehow the school personnel manage to get it done.
I’m not implying it’s without its challenges. But there are lots of aspects to HS which are operationally complex which seem to happen seamlessly.