I didn’t say we shouldn’t test anyone, please don’t put words in my mouth.
I think any testing that is done inside the school is pointless. Not trustworthy, especially in failing schools. I am not putting words in your mouth. Just trying to clarify issues. Also sending all these kids to Berkeley or a similar school is not a solution to anything.
Confused. I thought your exceptionally bright relative with LDs ended up at university. That she wasn’t excluded after all…?
Being test required does not mean that no students need math below calculus. University of Florida was always test required, but offers below calculus math courses (MAC 1105, 1114, 1140, 1147): Mathematics | University of Florida Catalog
Historically (NCLB is a good example), when the those with power and resources talk about making schools that serve low income kids “accountable”, that is another way of saying “we need to punish them for their failures”. Schools whose students do badly on tests are penalizing by having their resources reduced.
Instead of saying “this school is not doing well, we therefore need to provide more support for these students”, what usually happens is “these schools are failing their students because they have few resources so we will solve that problem by giving them even fewer resources”.
Just testing, “for accountability” is just as bad. It’s like having a doctor who looks at a patient, and their diagnosis is “you’re sick, goodbye”, or worse “you have a fever and are losing weight. I don’t know what it is, but it must be your fault, because if you wanted to get better you would. So I expect you to get well on your own, after you pay a fine for being sick. If you’re still sick next week, you will incur further fines”.
I think this is getting closer to the real issue here. Some are frustrated because they think spots are going to intellectually inferior kids . . .
Not in her own country…
What are per capita resources for poorly performing schools and well performing schools?
Are you claiming that resource availability has no effect on the performance of a school?
I am trying to see what the data says. Adjusted for state and other reasonable controls.
Please start a new thread if you’d like to continue discussing resources for K-12 schools. That discussion is getting very off topic.
TIA!
I’m glad she was able to access education appropriate for her abilities, even if it meant needing to travel in order to find a school that valued what she had to offer.
I do think that some of the anger of parents in California is analogous. They see how hard their kids have worked, how much they have accomplished, their perfect test scores, and yet their hometown school doesn’t want them and would rather admit students who can’t do middle school math. So they look out of state or even out of country (Canada etc) where admissions are straightforward. I can understand how from their perspective it would be upsetting.
ETA: I think there are also similarities between the reaction of parents in countries where there is tracking (What?! You think my brilliant daughter should decorate cakes?!) and the reactions of parents of highly accomplished students in California public schools (What?! You refuse to provide a math class that will challenge my kid? She’s able to do calculus but she’s stuck in pre-algebra with kids who can’t even do fractions?!)
The people banging the loudest drums are the UC professors themselves.
They’re the ones making the case for standardized testing so they dont have teach 6th grade math. Im sure that’s not what they expected when they joined the faculty.
You mean college math professors would prefer to teach students who were already proficient when they arrived? Whowuddathunkit?
The UC system doesn’t exist to make the lives of math professors easier. It doesn’t exist to only educate rich kids which huge pre-college educational advantages. It exists to educate a broad spectrum of students from across California.
Also, there is little reason to believe that whatever is happening was caused by dropping the tests, or will be fixed by reinstating the tests. Professors were already “banging the drum” about poor math preparation long before the tests were dropped. For example, a 2016 study at Berkeley indicated that many students entering Calc 1 were not adequately prepared, and needed to be taught basic concepts like fractions and exponents. Berkeley didn’t drop the test until 2021.
They could solely choose students that meet a minimum standard.
There’s a huge difference between already proficient and 6th grade math.
They cant solve 7x - 2 = 5
So teach 'em!
That’s what Berkeley is for!
Who is they? I don’t think UC policy should be based on extreme outliers/anecdotes.
It’s in the Atlantic article:
The bottom 25 percent of students were not just struggling with the coursework, Stankova told me; “people were in freefall.” Teaching was becoming impossible. “With one hand, I am teaching a complex integral, and with the other hand, I am telling them how to solve a simple linear equation like 7x – 2 = 5,” Stankova said.
Also found this: In an interview with NPR, UC Berkeley mathematics professor Zvezdelina Stankova shared a specific example that went viral. She noted that in engineering lectures across multiple UC campuses, professors were being stopped by students asking why 1/2 + 1/3 = 5/6. (https://www.instagram.com/reel/DZBXRRcpuOM/)]
Fractions.
Sorry, but I don’t believe long term UC policy should be set based on anecdotes from the height of Covid (2023), especially when said anecdotes are obviously hyperbolic. Complex integrals? This was supposedly Introduction to Calculus. If she was teaching complex integrals to students with highly variable preparation, she is the problem, not the test policy.
As I already mentioned, “fractions” were already an issue in 2016, when tests were mandatory.
And then of course there is the still unaddressed causation issue.