Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

If this is true, why are all these math professors suddenly up in arms? Shouldn’t they expect that some of their students cant solve a basic 6th grade math problem?

4 Likes

Yet there is so much data that show that’s not the case. Again, not sure what you consider a cutoff for a test score to go to college, but one just has to look at published data from some colleges that show no difference in college grad rates or GPA between test submitters and nonsubmitters. @Data10 has shared that data numerous times.

UT Austin’s results with the students from subpar high schools shows tremendous success in college as well…that’s why they continue to spend the time and money to educate these types of students, and certainly UT Austin is rigorous.

Do you have a citation for this statement?

I can’t speak to the math profs and the timing or nature of their issues.

Saying that a student with a low math test score shouldn’t be a math major is different than saying they shouldn’t even have the opportunity to go to college.

2 Likes

If you cant do algebra, no amount of SAT tutoring is going to help. SAT tutors are paid to help you with test taking strategies. If you cant grasp basic math, those strategies wont work. IMO, it’s disingenuous to say that it’s the test prep when they have much bigger issues.

And of course Khan Academy is free. Nobody ever mentions that in these articles.

No. But perhaps they shouldn’t take the place of someone who can in fact handle middle school math at some of the nation’s most academically demanding institutions.

Unless, that is, we aren’t really interested in having academically demanding institutions.

4 Likes

That’s for the state system to decide. To be clear, I see this issue differently for public schools vs private schools.

IMO public schools have the responsibility to work towards an educated populace, focused on educating those paying state taxes to the institution/system. And if that means remedial math instruction for some kids because of inadequate instruction in K-12, then it’s possible that a given state may think that is the best solution. Texas thinks so. There is nothing unique happening in California or at Berkeley.

1 Like

Yes and no. The way that the SAT is set up, you don’t really need to have any more than the most shallow understanding of algebra - just enough to know how to fill out the memorized templates. A person with that low level of understanding can get a pretty high score in algebra on the SAT with the right sort of coaching.

Of course, money can also buy you more time to work on your SAT scores.

While no amount of wealth can help a person who got a score of 500 on their math SAT get a 750. However, it can mean the difference between a 500 and a 650, or between a 650-670 and a 740-760. A mix of being taught the methodology and some tricks, getting some time accommodations, being tested in optimal conditions, etc., does make a difference.

Some methods of improving one’s scores are now cheap or even free, though it takes a certain amount of wealth to be in the situation to learn about these methods.

4 Likes

Since UT Austin admits by major, do they accept kids into their engineering or business program if they cant score 500 on the SAT math section? I assume that’s one of the reasons they have the SAT?

2 Likes

At what point does California require K-12 teachers to understand enough math to actually teach math… or inform all their students that Khan Academy exists.

1 Like

The colleges decide who is qualified to attend. If a student has a learning disability or anxiety disorder or what have you, that may affect their testing performance, the school can provide accommodations if they are “otherwise qualified” and admitted. Not everyone wants to be/major in the hard sciences. I am sometimes sorry that the vocabulary and essay sections of standardized tests are gone. Because there are those students who can demonstrate knowledge of math and science but who have poor writing skills. IMO tools like AI are Compensatory mechanisms.

Saying students with Learning disabilities shouldn’t attend top schools is myopic. Look at the number of students who have accommodations at top schools (there are threads on this topic). People can be 2e and successfully manage/compensate for their less strong areas. FWIW, Einstein was dyslexic

ETA: didn’t mean to reply specifically to @Mwfan1921

1 Like

I don’t know the answer to that. Again, I’m not saying a student with low math exposure/preparation/test scores should necessarily be a STEM major.

With that said, we do know some students coming from inadequate high schools have succeeded in these majors, as Texas has communicated.

You do know some students don’t have computer and/or WiFi access at home, correct? Then there are those who do have said access but have to care for their siblings, or grandparents, and/or work a paying job after school.

Access in K-12 education is a huge issue, and to ignore that by saying these students can just teach themselves on Khan Academy is…naive at best.

4 Likes

The USA lacks math teachers, and it lacks good math teachers even more. Knowing math is barely the first requirement for being able to teach math effectively. Underfunding schools cannot generally afford to pay good math teachers.

A person who has a good knowledge of math can find much better jobs than teaching high school for kids in a school district. Better pay, easier work, and easier hours. So good math teachers are expensive.

As for "informing their students about Khan academy? How widespread is that knowledge? How easy is it for high school students from low of even mid income families to have a few hours a day on a computer, quiet, and alone?

My wife has had worked with kids from underserved schools, and no, their teachers are not providing them with loads of information about ways to improve the SAT scores. One of the big divides between upper, mid, and lower income is access to information. Stuff that you assume is common knowledge is not.

5 Likes

And yet many of these students have a 4.0 GPA with A’s in HS Math. My point is California obviously knows this is happening and as you say, may be expecting UC Berkeley to teach them remedial math.

And the professors obviously have different expectations (like teaching college level math) because otherwise, this wouldnt be an issue.

1 Like

If there is a citation,’produced by the professional academia in this subject, I would trust it less

2 Likes

Time will tell what the UC administrators/trustees decide to do wrt testing.

Time will tell if California improves K-12 education, especially in the lower income and/or rural districts. That will take a lot of money, time, and focus.

What isn’t going to change is the UCs are there to serve their constituents by educating them and also to help the state meet its workforce demands.

1 Like

I look at people I work with, young and old, and it’s clear to me, many companies are over employed or could do more with less - from both a skills and effort POV.

Some of this will change because we’ve gone from an employees call the shots to employers call the shots - based on supply and demand.

Some will be because of technology.

But I do wonder if businesses are meeting their needs. They have employees doing things but are they really optimizing - through knowledge and effort - the needs of the business?

One thing that is clear to me is that by eliminating the need for any reasonable standardized testing, and depending on a school system that is incentivized to give you whatever grade makes them look good, we as a nation are just lowering expectations for all kids. And that is a great loss! However this action of removing testing is justified. If we are failing all these kids that are failing all these tests, we don’t even want to know about it. We want no accountability as a society.

3 Likes

Our education system has been failing many kids for a long time…the declines over the last few decades in math and reading levels/readiness and relative global performance at any K-12 level one wants to choose are well documented. There are so many issues larger than standardized testing…how we fund schools, how we train/incentivize teachers, how parents and students treat teachers, curricula across K-12, politics in the classroom/schools, I could go on, but not on topic for this thread.

An excellent education system can exist without college standardized testing, but it can’t be functional, let alone excellent, without addressing all the other things I mentioned. Even if one does bring back standardized testing to ultimately some relatively low proportion of colleges, that changes nothing about our failing K-12 education system. I agree with you it’s a great loss, and will be incredibly complicated to fix.

3 Likes

Believe it or not, there are students who score below 1250 on the SAT in high school who do very well in college and go on to excellent professional schools and/or jobs. I’d be glad to share specifics via message if anyone wants to message me.

2 Likes

Yes. If we don’t test anyone, the problem will go away because we won’t need to know about it :slight_smile:

2 Likes