100%. And it seems the math professors have had enough.
You have some kids who took AP BC Calculus in 10th and 11th grade that are in the same classes with kids who cant do algebra.
100%. And it seems the math professors have had enough.
You have some kids who took AP BC Calculus in 10th and 11th grade that are in the same classes with kids who cant do algebra.
The same history, English, and other non math based courses. But does it matter in that case?
They largely will not be in the same math or math based courses.
Some classes can be graded subjectively; others cannot. So in my mind, math is very different than history or language, etc.
Yes, they would go to trade school. Kids who are “Twice exceptional” (have a learning disability AND an intellect off the charts) do NOT have an opportunity for a college education. I’ve posted before about a family member whose parents were told in the 9th grade “she should choose between interior design, cake decorating, or cosmetician”. Her teachers looked at her dismal test scores (and yes, a kid who struggles to read may have dismal math scores, dyslexia can be all encompassing) and decided that she’d excel at something “creative” (in that country, a euphemism for “poorly paid”).
She is now a senor exec at a global tech company. There are millions of gifted but lopsided people in the world, and the notion that society shouldn’t benefit from the giftedness because of one or more deficits in another area is a very extreme position to take. Her parents had seen her “creativity” manifest as strong spatial relations skills, uncanny ability in geometry (not in test situations where she’d reverse digits, but in real life) and got her an actual, rigorous education. I doubt she’d break 1200 SAT’s in a test situation, but leading a team of PhD’s (her current job) does not require an SAT.
I love SAT’s as much as the next person who got sky high scores with no prep, and had kids who got sky high scores with no prep. But that doesn’t mean that the tests are the be-all and end all of human intellect. And a kid in a school system- or country- that does not support kids with LD’s will never find out where the latent geniuses are hiding.
And I fully recognize my own privilege. There are plenty of dumb rich kids in America and to ignore that coaching gets them to an acceptable level of test scores is preposterous. Not “Cal Tech” level of test scores, but we can all name the 30 or so colleges beloved by the parents of dumb rich kids, and that’s where the “high scores are the result of coaching” meme was born.
From the Atlantic article:
“With one hand, I am teaching a complex integral, and with the other hand, I am telling them how to solve a simple linear equation like 7x – 2 = 5,” Stankova said.*
Isnt this 6th grade math? Professors are teaching kids who got into UC Berkeley 6th grade math and yet the university is rejecting thousands of kids who got 5’s on AP BC Calculus?
UC system is resisting the SAT because they know kids who cant do algebra wont do well, no matter how much test prep they get. And they want to pretend it’s not an issue?
It’s mind boggling they got a 4.0 GPA with A’s in HS Math. What are their HS teachers doing??
I wonder about grade inflation. Every school is different but my own student, at a top public, got an A in AB, bombed the test ( I think a 2) and had to drop her math class first year and take an easier one - over two semesters.
I’m sure she was grade inflated. What other possibility is there ? She’d say online school. Perhaps. But clearly she didn’t learn what was needed. Yet still did well in the course itself.
Lots of kids at schools without strong students or teachers are getting As.
Very different than 40 years ago.
Yet these were in colleges that used SAT scores, when most colleges were using SAT scores.
It seems that, somehow, SAT scores weren’t able to determine whether a person had the mathematical abilities to succeed in engineering.
Sorry, but those stories don’t increase my confidence in the ability of SAT scores to achieve what people seem to assume that they will achieve.
Perhaps it’s a matter of degree? (no pun intended)
The issue is with math education in the USA, not with how well it’s being tested. Math is being taught as template filling, not as problem solving. So long as American elementary, middle, and high schools think that getting better in math is simply a matter of doing more homework and memorizing more templates, America will continue to lag.
Me neither. Our family policy toward standardized tests is not to prep. Either you know the material or you don’t. Then again, I know plenty of rich families who do prep, including some cases where the improved score (along with being recruited athlete and/or legacy) made it possible for very unremarkable students to be admitted to Ivys/Stanford.
It is ok to be a low-scoring student. One of my children simply was never academic. In many other countries this could have resulted in access to a trade-school track gaining useful skills for a non-academic career. Instead my non-academic kid languished in college-prep classes that were not a good match. College-prep was all that was available, but not every kid is college material. Now this kid is attending a polytechnic school learning hands-on skills and is finally thriving. She and her friends are preparing for careers in carpentry, phlebotomy, pipefitting, art teaching, interior design, pastry chef. Being a cosmetologist isn’t an insult. And some of these careers are very well paid.
Oh, absolutely, on that topic, don’t even get me started (and no, btw, American students are most certainly not doing more homework than their international counterparts - source).
That second CNN link contains some pretty damning language with which I couldn’t agree more:
"In the United States, I don’t think we are getting a particularly good math and science education. What we know from the international studies is that other countries have much higher demands on their students, especially during the middle grades – grades six, seven and eight. In those countries, they study algebra, geometry, physics and chemistry. In this country, our kids, most of them at least, are still studying basic arithmetic and they’re doing very elementary, descriptive science; I call it ‘rocks and body parts.’
"In both mathematics and science, U.S. students’ performance ranges anywhere from simply mediocre to extraordinarily poor. And that is true in both our national tests as well as our international tests.
“One international study of 12th-graders found that for those students in mathematics who were at the highest level – the kids who take calculus, AP calculus or regular college-level calculus – essentially came near the bottom of the international distribution against their peers. In science and physics, we were dead last. So even those students who we think of as our absolute best are not competitive internationally.”
“Rocks and body parts” has been a go-to smack in our household for a while after I first read this.
But also, it surely doesn’t help to not even try to weed out those clearly unqualified - as UC professors quoted in The Atlantic piece above are now finding out.
So it’s not an either/or. It’s both/and. United states desperately needs better math and science middle&high school curriculum AND there have to be objective accountability measures on those things that can be objectively measured.
But then again, the entire generation is probably about to cognitively surrender to AI, and I am not sure what the humanity will do about that. May need a whole separate thread on it.
Our youngest had ACT 35 in 7th grade (his older brother “only” had 31 at that age).
No specialized test training, but certainly a lot of deep study of other things, for their own sake.
Yep. Certainly feels like a classic case of confusing correlation and causation, with cause and effect turned on their head.
There is nothing wrong with being a cosmetologist. But being tracked into a vocational program after high stakes testing shows that you are unable to do university level work– when in fact, with appropriate instruction geared to intelligent students with LD’s you ARE quite capable of university level work- I dunno, doesn’t sit right with me.
Do you want to systematically exclude exceptionally bright students from our university systems just because that’s how they do it in other countries?
Of course not. Isn’t that what ‘accommodations’ are for? At Stanford, something like 38% of freshmen get accommodations. Here is an article from The Atlantic on accommodations: Elite Colleges Have an Extra-Time-on-Tests Problem - The Atlantic
But helping certain students with accommodations does not mean that we shouldn’t use standardized tests in college admissions. Is that what you’re advocating for?
Can’t agree that people “assume” wealthy families pay for tutoring. The point was that if some students do “pay” for tutoring (which may include test taking strategies as well as content review), there is likely a disparity between those who can afford it and those who cannot.
If someone tests low, there are two possibilities — they have genuinely no interest in the material, and/or they have learning disabilities. In either case, they should not be going to Berkeley, to figure out if they are hidden geniuses. Whether or not they should go to trade school is a separate matter.
What? Assuming you are talking about SAT/ACT? There are certainly other possibilities…like they just didn’t learn the material, sometimes to no fault of their own (poor teaching, inadequate curriculum, access, etc.) Gentle reminder that SAT/ACT test what a student has learned, they aren’t aptitude tests.
I’m not suggesting that students who get a 500 in math (about the national average) should necessarily be math majors, but certainly some with ‘low’ scores can succeed in college. People know there are physicians who scored in the 1200s on their SAT, correct? Just using one example I know to be a fact.
One doesn’t have to be a genius to go to college. All students at Berkeley are not geniuses.
Big picture, some believe that public colleges, being part of their state’s education system, should step up and be part of the solution to K-12 shortcomings. That’s how Texas operates. And even if the UCs do go back to test required in a few years, I don’t think the top 9% rule will go away. So graduate in the top 9% and the student is guaranteed a UC admission, regardless their test score…Most often Merced, sometimes Riverside. This is how a number of Texas unis work, as they are test required.
First, that data is from 1991. The kids who were surveyed for that data have own kids in college. They were also self-reporting, and asking kids to self-report is a pretty bad way to collect actual data, especially when it comes to time spent on anything.
Moreover, what is more important is what students are doing for homework. They should be reviewing concepts and methods, rather than repeating the same questions in a dozen different ways.
Finally, I’m pretty sure that the claim is not based on any sort of real survey and on any actual data, but is the sort of thing that a person with an agenda “feels” is true:
These sorts of claims will usually compare the education that one gets in, say, a good High School in South Korea, and compare it to the education that kids get in an underfunded American high school. Plenty of High schools in the USA teach “algebra, geometry, physics and chemistry.” They have regular, honors, and AP classes for all of them.
You may have overlooked it in the original quote: algebra, geometry, physics and chemistry are middle school subject in many parts of the world.
Yes, for everyone.
Generally if you put a kid through high school, and test him/her on that material, and they do poorly, then it is likely a good test for the outcome of what might happen if you put them through college, and expect them to use the material they learned in college to do something with it. They have no interest, or have other cognitive issues. Putting them into college is a poor way of handling that situation, let alone into a rigorous college like Berkeley.
SATs are both knowledge tests and ability tests.