MIT is unusual among colleges and universities in that it (a) offers no math course below calculus, and (b) has calculus and multivariable calculus (and various science courses suitable for majors) as general education requirements. This is not true of most other highly selective colleges and universities (even those with extensive general education requirements like Chicago and Columbia). A humanities major at most colleges and universities need not take calculus to fulfill any graduation requirements.
Hence the minimum math readiness on entrance to MIT is significantly higher than at most other colleges and universities.
The UC professors are asking for it. And people are dismissing it like it shouldnt matter. Maybe it won’t matter but 1400 professors? are asking for the UCs to bring it back.
People want to believe what they want. If people want to say they know more about what’s going on in the classrooms, then go ahead. Professors are just grasping at straws because the SAT is just an exercise that doesnt serve a purpose (other than to help advantaged kids gain a greater advantage - am I getting this right?). Their viewpoints don’t matter. All that matters is the overall mission.
And if that’s the only factor, why is the UC system even considering it all? Just tell all those professors to go back and do what they’re told.
The UCSD report highlights that UCSD believes “the math preparation problem at UC San Diego is significantly worse than at other UC campuses”. The report indicates a contributing factor is the larger increase in low income students at UCSD than at other UC campuses as pictured below. LCFF high schools are low income schools for which >75% of students qualify for free lunch. From 2020 to 2024, the % LCFF students nearly doubled from 17% to 31% at UCSD, but decreased from 18% to 15% at UCB. UCSD had a far higher admit rate for applicants from LCFF HSs than non-LCFF HSs. This differs from UCB.
UCSD Math 2 is intended for students who aren’t sufficient in pre-calculus (what you are calling “7th grade math”) . LCFF kids compose the majority of Math 2 placement test results at UCSD . The portion of LCFF kids who scored at the Math 2 level dramatically increased in fall 2024 and fall 2025 classes for reasons that aren’t given in the report. Perhaps 2024-25 freshmen group has a higher portion of kids who missed before pre-calculus math during COVID and/or AI plays a role.
"We are University of California faculty from the social sciences, humanities, arts, business, law, education, and other non-STEM fields. We are writing to endorse our STEM colleagues’ earlier open letter regarding the math component of SAT/ACT and argue for also using the verbal reasoning component of SAT/ACT in undergraduate admissions. We first want to thank our mathematics colleagues for explaining the harmful impact that a test-blind admissions policy has had on math and other STEM education at the University of California. Some of us did not sign the mathematics letter because it was framed as a statementfrom STEM faculty, but we agree with its conclusions. As a complement to their focus on STEM preparation, we would like to highlight concerns from our own fields.
While our STEM colleagues understandably focused on problems caused by the absence of SAT/ACT-math in undergraduate admissions, we emphasize that University of Californiaundergraduate admissions would also benefit from considering the SAT reading and writingsection or the ACT English and reading sections. As carefully documented in Section III and the
various appendices of the Academic Senate’s Standardized Testing Task Force report [PDF], standardized test scores predict important outcomes like college grades and graduation rates."
“Most people” don’t set UC policy. IMO, this is a good thing since “most people” don’t seem to know much about how the UC system operate.
For example, UCB has at least one factor in common with California community colleges. It’s students:
Around a quarter of students at Berkeley started at community college and transferred starting their junior year (meaning the percentage is higher in the upper division.)
To give you an idea of the magnitude, every year Berkeley enrolls many more community college transfers than MIT enrolls new students.
Nearly half of students who earn a bachelor’s degree from a UC campus in STEM transferred from a California community college.
Imagine that . . . kids who started at CC make up a significant portion of every Berkeley graduating class. These are kids who didn’t go to a four year college, and they never had to take a standardized test to gain admission, (even before the UCs went test blind!) Yet they do well at one of the most prestigious universities in the world.
This raises a few questions.
How is it that Berkeley has long been considered one of the top University’s in the world when it has been letting in so many community college kids who did not excel in high school or on standardized tests.
Haven’t we been told that great universities are great because they insulate the most qualified/highest testing high school kids from those who weren’t as accomplished in High School?
Does this mean that Berkeley isn’t all that great? Or that perhaps some of the assumptions about great institutions may be mistaken, or at least not easily generalized to all institutions?
Hey, community college kids didn’t necessarily do poorly in HS! Some did well in HS and just had a more circuitous path to college like my sister who dropped out of Brown and then went to community college and then UCB, etc. And we know plenty of kids who deliberately choose 2 years community college for the low cost and convenience. My D26 had an older friend who is a MechE student now, she was a good student in HS but didn’t even bother applying to 4 year colleges because 2 years of CC was her plan all along.
Im still confused as to the point of all this if the UC administration will simply dismiss it. Im even more confused why they’re considering reinstating standardized testing when they ignored the faculty recommendations 6 years ago?
Pretty sure I didn’t say they “necessarily (did) poorly.” These are obviously very bright kids who didn’t immediately matriculate to a four year college for a variety of reasons. Or in your sister’s case, they did, but then still ended up in community college.
I meant to say that many of them did not excel in high school according to the standards being pushed here, and I think that is a fair assumption, outliers aside.
Of course, some did. But surely, the percentage isn’t all that high, at least not in many states. I think in CA it is higher than many (or at least that is my sense from people I know in CA where it seems relatively common to do CC and then a UC). I honestly don’t know one person who went to CC and transferred to a 4-year "selective” or even moderately selective (or selective at all) school. It is NOT a typical or even known path to me in practice (and there actually are good articulation paths in my area. I can think of one student I know right now in CC who could have had a path to a moderately selective college. Kid has some LDs and MH issues. In my peer group none….some had very successful careers in nursing or technical type things and found their career and niche later…
I don’t live in California, and have zero personal experience with UCB.
But a quick check of their website seems to indicate that you can major in Celtic Studies, Film, Old Norse/Danish, Slavic Studies, Social Welfare, and at least half a dozen more majors where taking TWO semesters of calc (like the MIT requirement) is clearly not on the menu.
To a non-CA person this seems to suggest a VERY different mission and admissions policy than MIT, no? So “most people think that UCB is closer to MIT”– I’m wondering if that’s “most people in Atherton and Palo Alto”, and not necessarily reflective of folks in Sacramento or Bakersfield or Irvine or the other cities where CA taxpayers live???
I could imagine a scenario where the kids applying for the film program (for example) have radically different profiles vs. the kids applying for CS. Not that they’re community college bound necessarily…. but very different.
Or is the hierarchy of “engineering and CS” at the top and everything else falls to the wayside going to be the strategy of a massive and comprehensive public research U in a state as big as CA???
Passions are running high on this topic — so I will make this my last comment. No one outside CA thinks that UCB is a place where you can get remedial classes. It is exceptionally tough to get into UCB for out of staters. And you are charged nosebleed tuition and board expenses for an exceptionally crowded experience. You bear it because it has great faculty and facilities. There are many other public colleges that could and do fulfill legitimate state of CA public interest and policy preferences. If it is being touted as a world class university, I am just a bit surprised that it has very different standards for different kids. Anyway I would never send my kids to UCB because it offers such poor value for money for out of state kids. My kids felt the same way. This state of affairs doesn’t improve the perception.
Just tiptoeing into the quicksand here to ask a quick question- anyone know how Merced and Riverside students are reportedly doing with their math preparation, since the ELC students seem to often get their guaranteed admission offer at Merced and Riverside. Just wondering….
For students who need to take calculus for their majors, Merced offers a one semester precalculus course, similar to other colleges like Princeton. Riverside seems to have more entry points for lower level math to prepare for calculus, with some sequences taking three quarters (one academic year) before being ready to take calculus.
Like most other colleges, calculus is not a general education requirement.
Thanks. Was wondering if the ELC students who didn’t get into UCB would be generally comparable in math prep as those who did get into UCB (and I realize that there are plenty of students who don’t pursue STEM).
But this isn’t unique to UCB. And time and again I am struck by folks posting on CC who are leaving Texas for Penn State, or want to leave Illinois for U Mass or fill in the blanks. For most people, attending someone else’s public U means either paying more, or putting up with bureaucracy/worn facilities, or taking a step back in academic strength. And yet thousands do it every year. And since you have a Rutgers grad in the family, no doubt your son knows at least a dozen kids who paid MORE for someone else’s state U rather than attend Rutgers– and frequently, that “other state U” was significantly less rigor, reputation, etc. than Rutgers. i.e. poor value for money for out of state kids.
However, some majors like business require calculus, although it may be a less difficult version. Perhaps Riverside needs a more extensive range of lower level math to prepare for calculus than Merced because Riverside has a business major.
But students in humanities and some social sciences do not need calculus for their majors.