Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

U Texas offers classes even lower than precalculus, because they have found some of their students need it. Admitting the top 5% of students at all public high schools across the state, including students who are disadvantaged and/or coming from under performing high schools, means UT Austin must have these offerings. U Texas is also test required, but that’s irrelevant if one is in the top 5% of their class. Point is…test required, and some of their students still need academic supports.

Perhaps some of the UC system profs should speak with Dr. Laude, a globally esteemed STEM education researcher who is a chem prof at UT Austin. They might learn something. Laude and UT Austin and academic support were profiled here: https://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/18/magazine/who-gets-to-graduate.html

UCB is much more like U Texas than Princeton or [insert highly rejective private school].

2 Likes

Let’s keep the discussion focused strictly on the SAT/ACT. Deep dives into high school and college course sequencing / offerings are outside the scope of the thread. To keep this thread clean, subsequent off-topic replies are subject to deletion.

1 Like

That is not what the article said. The dean of admissions at MIT feels that the SAT is an accurate predictor for success in college in general (any college, anywhere)…and….that MIT finds that general and broad correlation to be valuable in their assessment.

1 Like

Repeating this doesn’t make it any less false. The dean of admissions at MIT said no such thing in anything I’ve read (and you haven’t produced anything supporting your claim.)

MIT was not analyzing the value of the SAT for admissions to “any college, anywhere.” MIT is concerned with the special needs of MIT. MIT is careful to say this, repeatedly.

2 Likes

Reading all the recent comments…

  1. Different schools will have different academic landscapes, institutional priorities, and admission processes, and therefore it makes sense that they would have different testing needs. MIT has very specific academic landscape, priorities, and process; given this, they may find SAT/ACT to have high usefulness, while other schools might not. It seems like it should be uncontroversial that schools might rationally make different choices here!
  2. We keep talking about math class preparation and math SAT, but in the case of the UCs, let’s keep in mind that the UC professors have now extended their letter and signatures to cover the EBRW part of the SAT (and likewise for ACT). Of course these are professors rather than admissions professionals, and they might be mistaken in thinking this would help anything (and also admissions professionals might be mistaken about things). But if we are talking about the concerns of these professors, we should broaden our discussion past just math testing and “which schools have remedial math” and “which majors require calculus.”
  3. I think it’s worth looking over the “Documents” links on the UC professors’ web site simply to see what they are presenting as useful context and evidence: Documents
1 Like

UCB isn’t just being touted as a world class university, it is a world class university.

The quality of the university is not diminished just because it educates (to a world class level) a broader spectrum of students that you initially realized. That’s not failure on the part of UC, it is a huge success.

It is telling that you can’t accept it as world class just because it educates a broad spectrum of students. Seems the cart is pulling the horse in this sort of analysis.

4 Likes

And speaking of world class, I will also note that admissions processes vary widely in other parts of the world that have world class universities. Many are much more stats based. Some are holistic but more focused on students’ purely academic strengths (thinking here of Oxford for example, where you need to demonstrate academic strength in many ways, but it doesn’t matter if you also play the cello). Some world class university systems are extremely rejective, while others are much less rejective (but then may weed out a lot of students in the first year or so).

1 Like

I’ll rephrase my post to focus on SAT/ACT per moderator instructions.

It’s normal for HYPS… type colleges to offer a course for students from weaker math backgrounds who don’t score well enough on math placement exam to start at calculus. A list of enrollment totals in Math MA (pre-calc type class taken before calc I) at Harvard is below by year is below, with reference to how the total has changed with changes in test required / test optional status at Harvard.

Fall 2025 (SAT/ACT Required) – 11% of freshmen enrolled in MA/MA5
Fall 2024 (Final Year of Test Optional) – 13% of freshmen enrolled in MA/MA5
Fall 2021 (First Year of Test Optional) – ~13% of freshmen enrolled in MA/ESA (COVID deferred enrollment makes % unprecise)
Fall 2019 (SAT/ACT Required) – 10% of freshmen enrolled in MA/ESA

1 Like

The selectiveness / rejectiveness has a lot to do with the school size versus population size. For example, world class universities in Canada are huge, and Canada’s population is small, so they are much less selective / rejective than in the US.

They also do not require external standardized tests for domestic applicants, since they presumably trust the consistency of content and grading in high schools in Canada. They also seem to be SAT/ACT optional for US applicants, despite the lesser consistency among US high schools.

3 Likes

Yes, and then they don’t do much hand holding and they do some weeding. U of T for example has the rep of being “not so hard to get in, but harder to survive.” Anyway, the overall point is to decouple “world class university” from admission rejectivity and other admission policies, as different universities teaching at a high academic level may meaningfully differ a lot in those areas.

2 Likes

But this is precisely what many in this thread do NOT want to happen.

To be fair, I didn’t read @neela1 as saying that UCB (for example) should necessarily change its admission policy in order to remain in the ranks of world class universities, instead the comment seemed to me to express surprise and perhaps also curiosity, “hmm, how can it be a world class university if it’s admitting students in this way?”

Seems to me that universities with high academic standards can handle the problem of less-prepared students in many ways; they might be highly rejective and just not admit them, or they might admit a wide range of students and weed some out and kick them back into the community college system, or they might admit a wide range of students and try to figure out how to educate them all despite different preparation levels.

Let’s go back to the fundamental question: What actually happens if they reinstate a test-optional policy?

Students with lower scores simply won’t submit them. How does that solve anything? Their scores remain unknown, so there’s no additional transparency.

The concern from some is that high-scoring applicants would gain another advantage in the admissions process, giving them one more checkmark in their favor—and potentially taking a spot away from someone else. Some high performing kid from Harvard-Westlake got a 1590. What do we do with this? Should we ignore it?

On the other hand, what if the UC system made testing required?

I assume the UC administration is reconsidering the issue because of public pressure. Otherwise, it’s hard to explain why they’re revisiting a policy they rejected six years ago. They’ve gotten a ton of negative press from the UCSD report.

What happens if they went test required and 20% of their students couldnt crack 1100? Theoretically, they wouldnt care because the mission is their mission. But if they didnt care, why are they potentially bowing to UC professor demands?

Wouldnt the professor be thinking: This kid cant do basic algebra, what did they get on the math section of the SAT? Then they’d be upset the school didnt use the data to screen out applicants.

I remember about a decade ago a study which showed average/mean SAT scores by major. If memory serves correctly, it only studied big, comprehensive, public U’s.

The education lobby was furious because the Ed school had the lowest (at the time) numbers, and they kept claiming that “early ed” concentrators were bringing their numbers down (as if that helped). The engineers were furious because Philosophy had higher scores than they did- because everyone knows that engineers are the top dogs. The music folks got to argue that SAT’s were irrelevant– talent stands alone. And Yo Yo Ma doesn’t need math because he invented his own “String Theory” (ha ha ha). Etc. Lather, rinse, repeat. Nobody was happy with the findings, even the disciplines that came out on top– apparently the philosophy majors in America don’t have any lobbying organizations, and since they aren’t concentrated professionally (tend to disperse into 20-25 different fields after graduation) nobody seems to care about them.

I found- and still fine- the entire exercise amusing. I am sure that at some point, every public U has a student majoring in “Recreation Management” who had the statistics to not get weeded out as a physics major. And that there is “Mass communications and public relations” major out there who could have cut it as a theoretical mathematician. So once in a blue moon there is an outlier or 3 or 5. But it isn’t news to anyone who hires for a living, or works for a living for that matter, that “academic prowess as measured solely by one standardized test” (I’m not claiming that SAT’s capture every form of intellectual achievement- but they DO capture one particular datapoint) is NOT distributed evenly among 18 year olds. Or at age 19 when many college sophomores are switching majors when the one they thought they wanted as freshman prove to be wrong, too hard, too boring, too much work….

Anyway, carry on with “weeding out”, as if it were a neutral phenomenon like ice forming at a certain temperature, regardless of who is holding the cup of water….

Not sure what you are getting at here? At an institution that isn’t afraid to grade harshly, a student certainly might get weeded out in humanities because they can’t handle the work there, if that is what you meant. But that is still consistent with an overall strategy of that university being “we handle poorly prepared students by weeding them out” (and diverting them either to another major or to community college, etc.)

1 Like

I agree with you. I suspect there are many on this thread who would find it hard to believe that someone got weeded out of Renaissance Studies or Classics. Because the true weed out classes are organic chemistry, topology, string theory, etc.

I don’t think test optional is on the table. In 2020 the UCs were prohibited from instituting TO by the courts in response to a lawsuit (Smith v. Regents of the University of California), and that’s why they went test blind thru 2025.

https://publiccounsel.org/press-releases/milestone-settlement-in-higher-education-reached-between-students-and-university-of-california/

If the UCs go test optional or test required, I expect there will be lawsuits. A quick google search shows a number of orgs have signaled that.

UCs are less likely to go SAT/ACT optional than to stay SAT/ACT blind or go back to SAT/ACT required, due to a lawsuit on the matter.

Absolutely it can happen in classics, and weed-out can also happen when students are not prepared for the style of education in a particular university system; for example we often hear about US-educated high school students going to the UK and getting weeded out because they didn’t know how to study for UK-style high stakes exams.

1 Like

Definitely, “weeding out” happens in any major, though not necessarily as a result of intentional policy. But it does not get as much attention in lower demand majors like classics or physics as it does in higher demand majors or where there is intentional policy (nursing is a common example of the latter).

But does requiring SAT/ACT scores and considering them competitively for admission matter much in terms of “weeding out”?