So, I’m reading some of the UC professors’ supporting documents. A lot of material is math specific (as that’s where the first set of data is coming from), but it seems like part of what they are saying is not just that “students are less prepared” in general, but that students’ math preparation levels are acquiring more of a “U-shaped distribution” with a “hollowing out of the middle” and an increase in students falling into the lower arm of the U.
These graphs are for just three years and of course they reflect Covid effects (especially here in California where the school closures were pretty harsh). However if student preparedness is in fact acquiring more of a U-shape with an increase of students falling into the lower arm of the U, I can understand why it could be challenging to teach in this environment.
It also makes me wonder where to look for corresponding data for other types of preparation (writing or other verbal skills for example)?
Looking over the charts, I believe “did not meet ELWR prior to enrollment” doesn’t necessarily mean students were deemed unprepared for entry level college writing and reading, it just meant that they did not have qualifying test scores to submit, is that correct? I’m guessing that many of those students simply had not yet taken any exam to test their preparation? (The second table addresses this in more detail.)
For those reading this thread who aren’t super familiar with UC policies and ELWR, note that students can meet ELWR prior to enrollment by submitting various types of test scores such as AP, IB, SAT, etc., but the majority of CA students don’t take these tests. Students can also meet ELWR by taking an exam (this part varies by campus), but presumably that would not happen until they are enrolled (I’m not as familiar with that part, as both my kids had test scores to submit).
The 2020 table indicates that most frosh satisfied the ELWR by means other than the AWPE (writing placement exam) that UC gave in the summer before frosh entry. I.e. the had some AP, IB, or ACT English score or college English course that qualified.
Note that UC discontinued the AWPE as a systemwide thing; each campus now has its own writing placement tests for those who did not previously satisfy the ELWR.
Yes, and thank you for adding “college English course,” because I omitted that. This would include DE courses. But the other thing to note is that at least currently, taking the writing placement exam is also optional. So a student might be strong enough in writing, but just not happen to take the placement exam, and then satisfy ELWR by taking a course in college. All in all, ELWR is a pretty uneven measure… but probably still the only UC-wide source of data on this type of readiness.
A lot of rankings are mainly about research output and faculty reputation, which have virtually nothing to say about teaching quality or the intellectual background of undergrads too..
Initially, the university planned to make the submission of SAT and ACT scores optional, as many other colleges did during the pandemic. Almost immediately, though, the University of California began refusing to accept SAT or ACT scores, even from students who wanted to submit them. The policy was known as “test blind.” University leaders wrongly claimed that it would make admissions fairer and more equitable.
They neglect to mention the change from test optional to test blind was because of a lawsuit and judge ruling. The reader can only learn that by clicking on the ‘began refusing’ hyperlink. “Began refusing” is an interesting choice of words considering the legal mandate.
Obviously I don’t know what will happen going forward, but all of the arguments in the test optional lawsuit also apply to a test required policy. Not sure that should/will impact working group 1’s process and recommendations, but interesting nonetheless.
The university’s trustees, known as the regents, have the final word. When they next meet, on July 14, they should have the courage to admit they made a mistake six years ago and reverse it.
I don’t think this is an option, or even on the table…any California people know?
The University of California is now rejecting students who would excel there, including low-income and minority students, and accepting growing numbers of students who flail.
Are there data that show the details of this? I expect it exists, but don’t know…anyone? Not looking for anecdotes from someone’s kid’s high school, but a repository of real data.
I was about to share the same link. So I will instead quote the most relevant part of this:
The committee concluded that scores on the SAT and ACT, the main standardized tests for college admissions, did a better job measuring student readiness for college than high school grades. High test scores were particularly good at finding talented students from low-income families and underrepresented minority groups. For these reasons, the committee recommended the system continue to require applicants to submit SAT or ACT scores.
This is the same conclusion that MIT came to.
The really sad part is that the Academic Senate had spelled it out clearly enough so that any reasonably intelligent person could understand it. And yet the Regents completely ignored it, to the detriment of both California students and the reputation of the UC system.
The UC Board of Regents initially recommended test optional, no? Then came the lawsuit, then the court mandate to go test blind.
Anyway, at the time the Regents were making this decision, there was very little opportunity to take an SAT or ACT due to Covid.
Looking at the current numbers of CA HS students taking the ACT (4%) or SAT (25%), there is still not great access…and those numbers are even lower in title 1 high schools, which make up the majority of CA HSs.
So the question is how to get more limited income/disadvantaged students to take the tests? If the UCs require tests will that be enough? I’m not sure…especially if CSUs stay test blind.
If UCs go test required and it survives legal challenges, then the next step is how to increase access/test sites.
Options are to increase testing sites by asking HS counselors to run weekend tests (requiring renegotiation of some union contracts as I noted above) and/or offering an in-school test day by cutting a deal with ACT or SAT which will be expensive (CA has never done that AFAIK) and/or using external sites (for example, ETS which now owns ACT has a number of external testing sites in CA for GRE, TOEFL, etc…but these sites are also expensive and I have no idea if there are enough to handle CA’s volume.)
If I remember correctly, I think the Academic Senate recommended replacing the SAT and ACT with a new test that was to be developed. The Regents scrapped that idea. I don’t remember the details of who recommended test optional, but I know that didn’t survive a legal lawsuit.
Yes that was part of it too, but a long term idea….which has since been completely dropped AFAIK. And for good reason. No need to reinvent the wheel…spending tax payer money to do that would be a poor decision.
Here are the details of the Regents recommending test optional, and then moving to test blind. The test optional years where challenged in court, which then mandated test blind immediately.
Separately Jed Applerouth has a balanced take on the UC testing issue. I can’t post the link but it’s called “Will the UCs bring back the SAT and ACT? What the Faculty letter means.” Applerouth is a founder of a test prep company, so not unbiased, but he presents a thoughtful analysis of the situation.