This is a heavily moderated thread with mass deletions that in my opinion were very much on topic.
UC BOARS abruptly cancelled the process they had created to reconsider tests and A-G requirements. UC Regents meet today and tomorrow.
The University of California admissions board has voted to rescind — for now — its plan to study whether to resume SAT or ACT requirements in admissions, a move that leaves one of the university’s most closely watched debates unclear a day before the Board of Regents meets in San Francisco.
UC’s Board of Admissions and Relations with Schools, known as BOARS, announced last month that it would convene two work groups through next year: one to weigh the role of standardized tests in admissions, the other to reexamine high school course requirements for acceptance to UC. At a Friday meeting, the board voted to pull back on the plan, and the links that explained it — which appeared on the UC website late last week — have been removed. There is no replacement plan as of yet, according to two members of the board who attended the meeting, and several UC professors who are aware of the decision and who have been advocating either for or against testing requirements.
Rest of the article here:
UC abruptly suspends plan to reconsider SAT in admissions seems to be the source page, without needing to go through a controversial archive site.
Your link is paywalled for me because I don’t have an LA Times subscription.
I had no subscription, but was able to read the full story through that link.
Well, just telling you what happens when I click on it…paywall. So, you might take it down.
I also can read the whole thing with no subscription. Super long captcha though
Could it maybe be because you have a free account set up with LA Times? And that comes with a certain number of free articles? That’s how WAPO does it now too.
ETA FYI this is what I get when I click the link:
So it sounds like the pro-test activists are going to try to railroad the change through, without any study as to whether the lack of tests caused the drop, whether reinstating the test will rectify the situation, the impact reinstating the test will have on the UC’s mission and admissions, and without providing any databased guidance on how to use the test so as to best rectify the alleged crisis.
How very “scientific” of them. ![]()
I have no insider info. I wonder if there is also pressure coming from the Feds? If they do vote to move to test optional or test required soon or let the colleges do what they want, I would expect lawsuits. Time will tell…
The video of the meeting will be posted here at some point: Past Regents Meetings, 2026 - Present | Board of Regents
nope. top of my screen says “log in”
I laughed out loud when I read this.
You seemed to have ignored how we got here. The UC Academic Senate provided a detailed study explaining how the SAT was highly predictive of student success, particularly among low income students. They were overridden by the UC Regents, which made their decision despite the results of that study.
It’s all such an interesting issue, with a hefty layer of politics and legal action too.
Are you thinking the Regents will return to a test required policy for all UCs?
If so, do you think the state should pay for an annual in-school SAT or ACT test for all public school students? I think state contract test prices are $30-$35 per student in other states, so CA would be looking at spending $12M - $15M annually for this. CA has never done this, I would be surprised if they do. Without it, they still have many of the same access issues.
That would surprise me, unless they are feeling much more pressure than is apparent to me. Perhaps from the feds?
According to a couple of online sources, CA spends about $21k per student per year in K-12 (student spending in high school is likely higher). The additional $35 per student for administering a test one time is a drop in the bucket.
Yes, I thought the same. But also some of the anti-testing Regents are gone.
I doubt they would try test optional based on the Smith lawsuit, but who knows?
I get that but they already have all the CAASPP admin costs. I assume that’s why they never contracted with SAT/ACT even when they were test required? Who knows? An in-school test would be the easiest path to increasing access should tests become required, or even optional for that matter.
No account of any kind at LA Times web site. Not sure why it would have paywall sometimes but not other times.
UC did studies a few decades ago indicating that the SAT was of very little added predictive value compared to using GPA and SAT II / subject tests. These probably have informed UC policies since then.
However, high school grade inflation may have reduced the value of GPA at the top end and SAT subject tests are no longer available. Although the SAT also has some score inflation in redesigns, and more intensive SAT prep has probably also had some effect at the top end, it may be the best of what is really a bad lot of academic stats for top end applicants. I.e. not good, but less bad than other commonly available measures.
Note that The College Board has found the SAT less predictive than GPA over the full range of college applicants, not limited to the top end.
To keep our forum constructive, please be mindful that kindness and respect extend to both your text and your emoji reactions.
No. I remember how we got here. In particular, I haven’t forgotten the tumultuous 6.5 years since the study you referenced, during which high school education was decimated by Covid (especially in disadvantaged areas) while the UCs extended their outreach to disadvantaged schools.
In other words, there are factors at play here other than just the lack of test scores, and a prudent approach would be to try to sort some of that out, including the items I listed, above. I prefer to look for causation rather than blindly assume it from correlation.
IMO, this claim is greatly exaggerated. The Jan 2020 study found SAT scores were moderate predictors of first year GPA and graduation GPA, and weak predictors of student retention and graduation. The study also found that after controlling for student characteristics, High school GPA was stronger predictor than the SAT of of first year retention, graduation GPA and four-year graduation.
The study itself provided no recommendation. The Report accompanying the study provided a number of recommendations, some of which were accepted and others of which weren’t. There was more to it than an up out down vote on the test scores.
For example, the Report recommended that the UCs expand the ECI admissions track beyond just accepting the top 9% of each high school class in the state, as determined by GPA in UC approved curriculum. Such a change would have increased access to admission to students from even low performing high schools without regard to test scores.
The report also warned that the demographic disparities in the test scores were such that they could be used to produce strong disparate impacts among demographics (thus undercutting the UC Mission to education kids from all communities.)
The Report also admitted that members had varying perspectives on the relative importance of two different admission goals:
- Admitting students most likely to succeed at UC; or
- Enrolling classes representative of California’s diversity.
In other words, the Faculty Senate realized there was more to UC admissions than just admitting the kids with the highest chance for success, but nonetheless voted to keep the tests until they could be replaced with something better and less regressive.
The Bd of Regents disagreed, and focused on UC Mission.
Update on the UC timeline, with some comments by the Regents chair yesterday.
From the article, this is also the first time I’ve heard this in recent times (with no source attribution):
The university system is also considering using the state-level Smarter Balanced exams — annual math and English tests taken by high school juniors — in admissions, but there are complicating factors with that alternative, including that not every out-of-state applicant takes the test.
