Starting this daunting process

@AwayHeGoes I wanted to throw out a few other school ideas. They are ones I think you were thinking you’d have enjoyed AND maybe you think would be a good fit for your son’s personality. They are all very excellent schools and are competitive. They have outstanding students and really give them an education as good as they would receive at Top 20-type schools that have those incredibly low acceptance rates that make them tough for everyone.

There are just relatively few in the West, and those can be competitive because there’s a lot of competition, including a large number of CA applicants. I’m thinking of schools like Colorado College.

Maybe you could pick a region and try to find 3-4 days for a trip to a cluster of schools:

Denver area: University of Denver, Colorado School of Mines (engineering), University of Colorado, Colorado State. All are within a couple of hours. (Colorado and CSU are bigger schools, but it’s a great area with some schools that work, and stopping by Boulder and Fort Collins is just kind of a treat for the parents too–beautiful towns.)

Pennsylvania: It’s far away, which sounds like a downside. But it seems like Dickinson College, Gettysburg College, and Lafayette College would potentially be good fits. Great schools, beautiful schools (we love Dickinson), sports are particularly popular at them, especially Gettysburg and Lafayette. Dickinson and Gettysburg are very close. And Gettysburg is a nice old historic town. If you check these out, maybe Franklin & Marshall too. It’s in Lancaster, sort of the unofficial capital of Pennsylvania Dutch Country, which is a beautiful area.

http://www.dickinson.edu/homepage/284/about_overview

Massachusetts: Holy Cross and WPI. Academics at HC are as good as anywhere. WPI is less well known but is highly ranked, check it out on USNWR national university rankings. It has a very unique hands-on, projects-oriented approach, if that appeals. Grads have some of the highest starting salaries of any schools. We found the students to be very impressive. We all loved the campus–STEM school but more of a New England LAC vibe. These would require some strong test scores, which if that happened, Boston College might also be an option.

You can run the NPC to get an estimate on cost. I do suspect some of these would be pricey,

Good luck!

Agree with @aquapt’s suggestion re the SAT 2 (subject tests), if he’s interested in one of the colleges that require them. Junior Year is going to be busy, and there are a limited number of test dates offered, and you can take EITHER the SAT OR the SAT2 on one of those testing dates, not both. Many colleges don’t require these, but the higher ranked ones often do. You should google “colleges that require sat subject tests” and you’ll see links to prep companies that compiled a list of schools. If a school says it “requires”, "recommends " or “considers” them, he should take them. If he decides to take them he should definitely take the Math 2 test if he’s interested in stem. He should look at the list of other subject tests offered and see if he’s taken the course already so he can take two subject tests this summer and be done with them (unless he wants to apply to Georgetown, which requires 3).

My kid was very reluctant to start looking at colleges in sophomore year too. What helped was that I set up some road trips with him and friends, where we went to colleges about an hour away, did the tour in the morning, ate somewhere nearby for lunch, and went to a park or sculpture garden or other local attraction in the afternoon.

He was ready to apply to the first college we visited and no more, but I insisted on continuing. Our second college visit, he agreed that it wasn’t the college for him, he was able to identify things about it he liked and things about it he didn’t like, and he got excited about visiting more places.

He may be experiencing rejection anxiety. With B’s on his record, he may think that it’s impossible for him to be accepted anywhere he would like to go. Rather than being turned down, he’s setting himself up to just not ask. At least, that’s something I saw. Maybe your kid is different.

But with talent in two sports and support from his coaches, he has a lot of very interesting possibilities. Good luck with it, he sounds like a great kid.

@AwayHeGoes

My daughter did not really want to engage in the college selection process until the spring semester of her junior year. We had done some campus tours before that because we happened to be traveling in distant locations where there were college of potential interest, but that was largely driven by my research of what I thought she might like. Those campus visits did clarify some preferences with respect to size of campus and location so they were helpful when she got ready.

You have already gotten good advice about Fiske Guide, WUE schools, etc. My main piece of advice echoes @intparent - try to have standardized testing done by spring of junior year. Studying for SAT/ACT over the summer leading into senior year can be stressful and no fun. Also, have him do some prep for the PSAT, which he will take in the fall next year as some Western schools give big merit for National Merit scholars (UT Dallas, Arizona State, and others)

Your son would likely get in-state tuition at UNM (check out @DiotimaDM 's posts about her NMF STEM son who will be attending UNM on a full ride next fall), and depending on test scores could get attractive merit at Arizona State, which has an excellent honors program. UT-Dallas is another option. Many CA students who get shut out of the UC system but have good stats end up at these universities because they are good value. There also are many western states LACs where he might get merit discounting.

We live in the west and my child wanted an LAC. We were seeking merit and ended up focusing on midwestern schools in OH, PA, MN, WI etc. As mentioned upthread, the CTCL schools are great for B/B+/A- students and offer merit for students in that range. If he ends up wanting engineering, however, he will have to look to larger schools.

Good luck - and those college road trips can be a lot of fun, enjoy!

I will second our love for UNM. They have excellent pre-med and engineering programs, and they’re also highly ranked for things like photography, film and Flamenco dance. There’s a business school and a law school, too.

UNM scholarships: https://scholarship.unm.edu/scholarships/non-resident.html

UNM Cost of Attendance: https://admissions.unm.edu/costs-financial-aid/index.html

It sounds like your son would qualify for the Amigo scholarship, which is a 4-year OOS tuition waiver, plus a $200/year stipend. Depending on his ACT / SAT score, he might be eligible to apply for their competitive full-ride Regents scholarship. Financially, UNM is a good value. It’s less expensive than any of the Cal States, and the cost goes down even more after the first year because Albuquerque has inexpensive rents compared to almost anything in CA.

We never really looked at Arizona, but UT Dallas has good auto-stats merit, and so does Utah State.

Here’s a link to a site that lists many auto-stats schools. The info is a couple of years old, so some of the entries might not be accurate anymore, but it’s a good place to start. http://automaticfulltuition.yolasite.com/

Also, your son is a sophomore, right? That gives him the whole summer to prep like crazy for the PSAT. If he can make National Merit Finalist, he’ll be able to choose from a bunch of full-ride scholarships, which is how our S got his.

He should prep as if for the SAT because the tests are similar. Get the Erica Meltzer books for the ERBW sections, and PWN the SAT for math. Khan Academy offers free prep online, but sometimes it isn’t sufficient to get the really high scores.

If he schedules his SAT right after the PSAT, he’ll be done with testing in one fell swoop.

If you like, I can detail my son’s prep routine for you.

Remember that a 15 year old has no clue when it comes to colleges. They don’t know anything about colleges (excep what they may have heard from sports) and have no idea what the process is.

  1. Attend a local college fair. Your county might have one. They are usually in the fall and spring. It introduces them to the whole college “thing”.
  2. Figure out how much you can afford/year
  3. See if his HS uses Naviance…it shows where students from his school went and what scores they had
  4. Look for STEM heavy schools

Lots of great advice here!

In terms of visiting colleges, this was our approach:

– Sophomore year visited a few in combination with family vacations OOS just to dip toes in water. The first visits make the biggest impression!
– Visited a couple more nearby in state options prior to Junior year in late August when colleges were in session but D’s HS had not yet started. This is a golden time to visit if you’re not playing a Fall sport.
– Junior year visited two more OOS as part of Spring Break. Most people I know did a lot more!!
– Lost steam summer prior to Senior year and Fall term and decided to visit rest OOS contenders in Spring of senior year after applications were submitted and she had more time. Ideally, we would have done them in the Fall but we just couldn’t make it happen.

ADVICE: if small colleges are on his list try to visit them in session. They can seem really dead in summer or winter breaks, whereas bigger schools tend to have some action all year round.

With baseball as a Spring sport, I recommend you try to hit as many as you can Fall of Junior and Senior years.

Good luck and try to enjoy!!!

A lot of 15-year-olds can’t even tie their own shoes – good luck!

Goodness, he probably just turned 16 and hasn’t had his first kiss yet. We as parents are smart to know the ins and outs of the college search at that point but I understand why he isn’t truly interested yet. I think most kids, with the exception of those that are being “groomed” for IVY or high stats schools, might be considering career choices, but most aren’t that interested in where/when/why/how. This is when the talks start…you have time but you already know much about your child…does he like large arenas? is he assertive or pensive? what can you afford? what are his strengths and weaknesses? Does he like cold (skiing) or warm (swimming) climates? Spring (and sometimes fall) of junior year is a good time to start visiting schools.

^^^^agree 99.9% with you. Only the first kiss at 16 part. I was shocked to learn from my nephews what’s going on out there. Not for all, maybe not the majority, but way more than I would have guessed. [-( X_X

He might look at Cal Lutheran. They won national D3 championship in baseball last year. Good mix of academics and sports. They even have D3 football… the Rams actually train on campus. The COA is high but the scholarships are substantial… brought price down to cheaper than UC. Small class sizes… however they do not offer engineering if that is a desire

Forgot to add that they are planning new science center likely complete by time he would enroll…and only need to maintain a 2.0 to keep the scholarship so there is little worry that student would lose the substantial scholarship (unlike most higher priced privates that often require 3.0-3.6 to maintain their scholarships which can turn into a big financial issue)

Thanks to everyone for these thoughtful responses. This site is great!

Had my first breakthrough of sorts the other day when I discovered that my boy had actually looked up a school online, after hearing that a kid that pitches with his coach was set to attend Lafayette… he was curious about where that was after hearing it was a good school. I have to admit I was thrilled that he took the initiative to do that. So much better when it’s their idea, not ours.

What is a little concerning for me is that, with two HS sports, there are not free days during the school year. Also very few free days during the summer (HS baseball and basketball camps and tourneys). Basketball runs straight thru Thanksgiving and Christmas, then baseball has tourneys from President’s Day thru Spring break. It’s very hard to opt out, if you’re committed to the team. We also have a daughter that is a competitive athlete, 8th grader. Lots of travel tournaments for her too, which leaves little time. And then I’m a school employee… so as much as I used to dream about taking my kids to explore schools, the reality is I may not be able to.

I’ve looked into a lot of the schools mentioned above and love them as suggestions. Son just had a strong finish of sophomore year, which is great. I’m going to sit down with him in the next week or so and begin a dialogue.

Watching the 5th graders at my school walk through their promotion got me misty this week. That was my kids only recently… I think it’s starting to hit me that my boy will fledge from our home in two years. He’s been my life’s biggest blessing. It will be bittersweet and probably quite hard on me.

It’s true how fast it flies by.

I’m a huge fan of Wisconsin state schools, if you have interest in going so far east. Your son can easily get in with his grades, the colleges have good D3 sports programs -UW-Platteville and UW-Stout seem to be the best for STEM academics should he continue to have interest, but most of them are good schools. There’s no merit to be had, but the sticker price isn’t painful for many income levels, even for OOS. Good luck!

Regarding visits for sports, it is much better to go in-season if it can be arranged at all. My DD was a volleyball player and we did the driving for our visits Sunday through Tuesday of her senior season (Fall) so we could be back for Wednesday games. We got half way across the country for an overnight one week where the first game was on Thursday. Do not be afraid to miss an early season practice or two if you have narrowed things down to a couple schools. Meeting the team, seeing the campus, watching a practice are huge. And when you stay over and hang out with the team it’s hard to hide any warts: 19 year old players are pretty transparent to other players.