Starting this daunting process

DS is current sophomore. Been spending some time here, educating myself about college admissions and selection. So far, he has little interest in beginning the discussion about college. It seems to overwhelm him. I know it’s important to him ultimately. Not wanting to put pressure on him I’ve been doing research and lying in wait, hoping he gets interested in starting a dialogue this summer.

He’s a good student and hard worker, highly responsible type kid but not “gifted”. He’s also a 2 sport athlete (baseball/basketball). His GPA is around 3.65 unweighted with four B/B+s in honors classes (Spanish and English) and the rest A’s at a well respected CA public high school. Getting A’s in Calc as sophomore and also A’s in reg Chem. He’ll take 3 AP’s next year: Calc, Spanish and US Hist. So he’s not an uber student, not an average student, but somewhere in between.

He has a big heart and is well respected by his coaches, teachers and peers and has received awards having to do with character.

But that won’t get him into most of our state schools, unfortunately!

We’re not wealthy but have some money for college that was started for him when he was born by a late relative. So we are fortunate there. Private school may be an option, but whether or not he is open to OOS remains a mystery.

Anyone out there have kids who are reluctant to begin the college discussion? I guess I’m concerned about having time to visit some places in the amount of time between now and fall of senior year—his sports schedule leaves zero time during the school year, with the exception of four days over winter break, and only the last three weeks of summer free.

When I was his age, I went to the best UC school that excepted me. There was no discussion of other options, no visits to other places. My experience was one of feeling lost in a sea of students and I fantasized about transferring to a smaller school, far away. My goal is to help my kids find that great fit.

Also wanted to ask if this summer is the time to start test prep for SATs, or is it better to wait until next summer, prior to senior year? We’ll probably offer a little bit of that to him, or encourage him to prep independently at home.

The situation in California is very gloomy from what I’m hearing. He’ll need to increase his options as best he can.

Thank you!

Do you see him doing intercollegiate athletics in college? You don’t make it sound like he’s on the Recruited Athlete path, but should you be looking at D3 schools where he can play and where his sports might give him an admissions boost? Or do you see him as more of a club sport or intramural athlete in college?

His stats sound solid, with high rigor. Do you have a sense of what he’ll want to study?

There are some really good opportunities at the WUE schools, and depending on where in CA you live, some of these out of state options can still be closer to home than the far end of California.

Wow I wasn’t familiar with WUE. That’s great.

D3 baseball might be an option but he’s no longer playing club ball, just high school. The basketball program requires a huge time commitment, and while he used to be more of a baseball player, he doesn’t want to give up hoops to get serious about it. I think he’d tell you he’d like to play in college, but I’m not sure how strong you have to be. He’s become more of a pitcher since he started high school; not sure he throws hard enough yet.

His favorite subjects are math and science. But those areas of study seems so crazy competitive. Other than that, he has no clear career interests (unless he could be sports broadcaster… :wink: ). His passions are sports related so far. Career assessments at school place him all over the place, from engineering to education.

Thanks for your response.

It’s a little hard to tell what to aim for without knowing where he’ll land as far as test scores. His grades are in that range where they won’t get him into competitive schools if his scores aren’t high, but they also won’t keep him out of a lot of competitive schools if he knocks the standardized tests out of the park.

It seems like his STEM grades are all great. It’s true that engineering and CS programs are very competitive, and the range of schools he applies to will have to be adjusted accordingly if that is the goal. But then again maybe he’s someone who would consider majoring in a quantitative field like statistics or accounting or economics… or as you say, education - maybe he’s the type to get a STEM teaching credential and also coach sports.

He will have good options, no matter what, even within California. There are still very good educational experiences to be had for mid-stat students in the CSU system. (And “mid-stat” may yet be a overly gloomy assessment.) And there are great STEM schools in the WUE program (Colorado State comes to mind, for example) And there are the private D3 schools where the combination of his academic and athletic qualifications could get him some nice merit aid. (In CA, Chapman, Redlands, Whittier, and Cal Lutheran… And Willamette in OR…) There are the less-competitive UC’s - Santa Cruz is D3 too, and there are some great programs at Riverside (the only UC with a business school, and it’s highly regarded) and Merced (which has the advantage of being smaller and less impacted). He might even be able to crack Cal Poly, depending on the major and on his scores… but having to commit to a major so young is not my favorite thing - how can they really know?

I don’t think there’s a need to go crazy with the test prep at this stage, but it might be good to try a practice test or two and get a baseline, and if he’s amenable, start a low-key routine of using the Khan Academy prep materials on a relatively painless schedule of a few minutes a day, or a couple hours a week. There’s a phone app, and he’s bound to have downtime when he could use that, little by little.

He sounds like a great kid - try not to worry - he’ll have a lot of good options!

good stats so far and he can improve next year and plenty of private schools in CA and outside that would take him esp since cost isnt an issue. y9u should maximize his chances of getting into a good school since you will be paying full price. get to do ACT and SAT and let him do the stuff he likes…some LACs to look at in CA Claremont, Mudd, Scripps (and many more private schools) but if he wants to go outside there are plenty of options…and he still has a shot at some UCs

Hi, I’m a CA parent with one kid currently in college and now paying attention here again as my 2nd is finishing sophomore year. I’ve actually found between my daughter and most (not all) of the children of my friends, the kids have not been very proactive about researching colleges. Most of the kids didn’t want to think about it too much sophomore and even junior year, and only really got invested in the process once they were seniors. (Of course there are the exceptions… the kids who are very focussed like the ones who are on CC in 10th grade).

So a couple of suggestions for you. If it’s in the budget, working with an independent college counselor starting now or in 6 months can be helpful. We did this for our oldest. In January of junior year, my daughter had her first meeting with the counselor for a couple of hours. (I should say, she’d already had a couple of tours at this point that we did early on just so she could see a big UC and a small private school). They talked about her priorities for schools… major, school size, geography, level of intellectual difficulty, whether having Greek life or Div 1 sports teams to cheer for mattered, family budget, etc. At the end of this meeting my husband and I came back and the counselor presented the 3 of us with a list of about 25 schools to research further and strongly suggested we visit some of them over that spring break (which we did).

Now that I’m on kid #2 I have a better idea myself of what’s out there so I’m not sure if we are going to work with a counselor to help with the list, but we’ll probably still use one to help with essays. In the meantime, I’ve identified about 30 schools of various selectivities that might be a good fit for #2, partially based on threads here on CC and partially on what I’d learned from my daughter’s search and from talking to friends. I’ve been having #2 dip a toe in the water and read the description for 3-4 of those schools each week in the Fiske Guide (big book that has 2-3 page descriptions of something like 300 colleges). I started this early partly just to get him thinking without overwhelming him, and partly because we’ll be going to the East Coast this summer for vacation and I figured if he really likes a few of them we can go tour while we’re there. Next step I think, other than the tours this summer, would be just to wait and see how testing goes over the next 9 months (SAT subject test for math 2 in 2 weeks since he’s finishing up precalc, then PSAT in October and probably ‘first’ crack at SAT and/or ACT around January - ‘first’ in parenthesis since he did SAT in 7th grade for the CTY talent search).

If you haven’t taken an official campus tour anywhere yet, do that when you get a chance. Don’t overthink it about whether it’s a real option… at this point, you are looking for a baseline idea of, ‘can I see myself on a campus of 25,000 students? How about here on this campus of 2000 students?’

Previous posters had some great ideas for places to consider. A couple more that are ‘out of state, but not that far out of state’ that kids around here go to are University of Nevada-Reno, U of Oregon, and Oregon State.

I like the counselor idea. He may like that. As a parent I’ve tried to be very hands off with him, low pressure. He decides on his classes and sports, has always been a self-starter with homework—I’ve let him do his thing and it’s working out so far. But i can see how that approach might not be beneficial going into the college search process. I think he feels some anxiety about both the potential rejection and the prospect of leaving home. Tells me, “I really don’t want to think about that right now”. I’ve been reading posts on here trying to figure out when he actually HAS to think about it. So he doesn’t regret not acting sooner.

My husband went to an ivy and has spent years talking up how amazing it was. I had to sit him down the other day and pull up some stats, so he could see how different it is compared to back in the day. He’s made some frustrating comments about the kinds of schools he’d like DS to consider. I feel protective.

Our daughter is in middle school. When it’s her turn, she’ll draft a neat list of all her schools, spreadsheets of info. She’ll be asking us for visits to far away places. It will be a whole different beast.

It’s not ideal but we’ll have to do some college visits locally over summer. Not much free time otherwise.

Look through the “Colleges that Change Lives” for dozens of great schools that don’t require perfect grades or board scores. (ctcl.org)

My S17 was not at all interested in looking at colleges in his Sophomore year. When we looked at our first college just before his Junior year he just felt it was way too early and never even really considered the school. As Junior year went on we visited a couple of others, still felt it was too early and not very interested. Over the summer between Junior and Senior year he made a huge turnaround and realized colleges were important. Visited several and by the fall knew exactly where he wanted to apply. Every student is different. He knew what he wanted to do and what he wanted to major in and what kind of college he wanted to go to so his big list was set for a long time. He knew he didn’t want an uber competitive school. He wanted a school where he felt at home and where he could be a big fish. He ended up OOS at Kansas State over a lot of schools. They gave him great merit, easy to get into, great social atmosphere, great sports, great Honors college, great in his major (animal science - pre-vet). He just finished his freshman year with a 4.0 and LOVES it there. The academics are challenging for his major and he feels he is learning a lot. Just said this to let you know that even late bloomers (in college planning desire) can find exactly where they are meant to be. He just isn’t quite ready yet.

That’s exactly what I’m hoping for momofcarly. Happy for you that your son found his spot. That’s all I want for mine.

Follow your son’s lead. If he’s not interested, don’t push it. It will only increase stress and it’s not necessary this early. Summer after sophomore year is a good time to buy a Fiske Guide (or similar) and leave it out on the coffee table. Let him peruse it when he’s ready. If he wants to do a visit or two, pick one large and one small school close to home. Hiring a counselor is premature (and not likely necessary if you’re able/willing to do your own research). The only thing a counselor might help with is managing your husband’s expectations – but you can do that by having him look on Naviance or here.

In terms of what he HAS to do, he doesn’t have to do anything right now. His sports schedule will dictate when he takes the SAT/ACT. He might want to take it a little early (fall of junior year) only because he’ll be busier with sports in the spring. Also near the end of junior year, he will want to ask teachers for recommendations. That’s it!

He sounds like a great kid – he will have lots of options!

You are doing great and asking great questions. It is very important to respect where your son is mentally and emotionally in the process. He’s still young. It all seems very far off from his perspective. Kids can push back pretty hard if they feel like they are being pushed pretty hard on it. They can feel like it’s some sort of grown up burden that’s being shoved on them, and for a long time from their perspective.

In terms of test prep, he’ll want to have done some work by the spring of junior year. Some would recommend lots and lots of prep, and that’s probably fine. I also think some shorter, intensive prep can get a student most of the improvement that’s there to be had. I was fortunate to have a friend–a dad–who did test prep. He met with students 1-on-1 at the local library for an hour at a time. He’s funny and knowledgable. My kids worked with him 3-4 times, and I think that was very helpful. Maybe you could find something like that. It’s expensive per hour, but if you can get a lot done in 4-6 hours, that might help you get some buy-in.

Do you have any trips planned over the fall? If so, maybe you could find a nice school that seems like it would be a good fit. Just do a casual visit, either a self tour or just the tour. Info sessions can be boring and maybe best to save if you are just dipping your toe in. If you can do it on a nice weather day, that’s a plus.

Colleges That Change Lives (CTCL) was a great recommendation, as was looking at the WUE schools. Note that many just reserve a certain number of spots, and it is often first come, first served. So applying early is important in that case.

Yes, the 50 or so most competitive schools are dramatically more competitive today. Take Vanderbilt. About 10 years ago, it’s 25/75 ACT range was 28-32, now it’s 33-35. The acceptance rates at these schools are often 1/4 to 1/3 the rate of 20 to 30 years ago. Your son sounds like a very good student, and he would likely be accepted at many, many excellent schools. The most competitive schools are just crazy for anyone, especially unhooked students. I used to note that every Stanford student (about six) from our area (East Coast) that I know who’s been accepted in recent years was a national level athletic recruit.

And, if I may, think of it as a fun process not a daunting process. We loved visiting parts of the country where we had never been. We did side trips, we discussed the schools but joked about the funny things. It was often a fun family experience. That can make it feel less pressurized too. Good luck and have fun!

Lots of sophomores are not very interested. I’d assume you mean he is just finishing his sophomore year. Here are some thoughts:

  • He should try to be done with standardized testing by the end of junior year. It is a lot less stressful going into fall of senior year with your scores in hand so you know what range if schools make sense. Most kids test a couple of times these days. A first attempt fall of junior year makes sense, leaving time to study and take again as needed.
  • Have a chat with him about college. Tell him it is a very large financial outlay for your family (as it is for all families today), so you will need his help and cooperation in the process of choosing colleges and applying. And that you expect him to start helping with it late this summer (last couple weeks before school starts). Then he knows he has this summer to relax, but you have expectations starting in late August.
  • Get a copy of the Fiske Guide to Colleges. Late in the summer, ask him to go through it and identify colleges that interest him. Be sure he picks a fair number of matches and safeties, not just reaches. Run net price calculators with him on those schools. Not sure how that money you mentioned from a relative is structured, but it could make the calculators inaccurate (they aren’t very nuanced). One of my kids loved looking at Fiske, and the other asked me to flag schools I thought would be good and then go over the list with her.
  • Plan some visits. My kids missed some of their activities (and even a little school) for college visits. Test dates can have that impact, too. Our priorities were clear to our kids — college preparation/ selection trumped ECs. Where possible we planned around ECs, of course.
  • Sounds like your H may bring some unhelpful viewpoints to this process. Managing that may be your biggest challenge.

All very good tips. Thank you so much.

Hopefully husband got the point. As luck would have it, he was recently approached by his alma mater to be an interviewer for local applicants. Needless to say, the kids he interviewed were proof enough. He came home speechless each night. Yep, I said.

You can also google colleges that offer generous merit aid. There are lots of terrific schools, including some of the CTCL schools, that offer generous merit aid and for a pretty broad part of the incoming class, especially some midwestern schools. I’m thinking of Denison University, Kalamazoo College, College of Wooster, and a few similar schools. Denison is beautiful. Kalamazoo pretty actively recruits male students.

Speaking of, US schools are now almost 60% female. STEM schools like RIT, RPI, Case Western, Georgia Tech, etc. still tend to be heavily male, but most of the rest, especially LACs tend to be heavily female often 55-65%. As a result, schools like these tend to have a higher acceptance rate for male applicants, and sometimes are more generous in financial aid. The dean of admissions at one school with 56% female students explicitly said that male applicants are at an advantage. It’s the opposite at STEM schools, and some schools with big-time sports.

[Re: the Claremont Colleges suggestion: Scripps doesn’t admit men; Claremont McKenna and Mudd are more competitive than the top UC’s. http://tsl.news/news/7540/ These schools may or may not be in reach for OP’s son when the time comes, but if admitted he will almost certainly be full pay - well over $70K/year - whereas they may want to be looking at schools where merit aid will be a realistic possibility.]

One question I would be asking, in the case of a STEM-oriented athlete, is whether he would be happy at a smaller STEM school along the lines of Rose-Hulman, CO School of Mines, RPI, RIT and so on. On the one hand, there are athletes at all of these schools, and he might find a tribe on the athletic teams. On the other hand, the prevailing “nerd culture” (which is heaven on earth for those who love it) might not fit his personality. Admissions-wise, these schools are a good fit for a kid with uneven stats that are stronger on the STEM side. But would he enjoy that environment, or would he be more at home at a more general-purpose school where his desired STEM majors didn’t dominate the culture?

College visits are really tough to get done with athletes! I had the same problem with my volleyball kid; we ended up doing our one out-of-state tour at the end of the summer, which was a compromise vs. going when classes are in session at the target schools, but it was better than nothing.

Actually… one place to start on the standardized testing would be for him to sign up for a seating of SAT II subject tests that will work with his sports schedule. He’s far enough along in math already to take the Math Level II subject test (the content will only get rustier for him from here on). He could also take chem, since he’s finishing that class with an A and not taking chem next year. (You can take three tests in a day but two is more humane). A lot of STEM programs want to see the Math Level II subject test, and this could help get him into the standardized testing groove and help you to gauge whether he’s going to knock his STEM-related standardized tests out of the park. It would be a good warm-up as far as familiarizing himself with the way these tests are administered. There are prep books for these tests that aren’t too thick and intimidating. Not worth a battle if he’s not receptive, but worth suggesting in case this feels like a relatively self-contained and manageable foray into testing for him.

Not sure if this makes a difference, but from what I have read the University of California schools don’t count freshmen year. So if his lower grades were 9th grade, that would change the picture.

OP, and a lot of those amazing students he interviewed probably didn’t get in, too.

College education in CA is far from dim. Most of the UCs are looking for a GPA over 4 and have grown to be HUGE and impersonal - which is great for the driven, self motivated students who earn admission. With 23 CSUs, there are a nice variety of public colleges that are open to most students who earn a 3.3 or better. a couple of the CSUs have become more competitive than that and several remain open to students with GPAs in the mid 2s.

Of course there are also hundreds of CCs and dozens of privates.

I think it really helpful to rough sort them, involving your kid. I’d start with big, medium and small campus - visit one of each, take a tour and get the vibe of the campus. Make them convenient to you, either near home or as a side trip on an already planned vacation. From there you can start a conversation about what he likes - and what you are comfortable with and can afford. In the meantime, he will be accumulating grades so you will be able to help see which schools he’s likely to make it into and you will get a sense of how likely he is to earn merit aid. That should give you w foundation.

Enjoy the ride.

My S18 would have had no serious interest his sophomore year, but he had figured out what types of schools he wanted to apply to, LAC’s with D3 sports. This was partially due to seeing where his sister landed (two years older), and that D3 athletics are a good fit. Maybe you could start with trying to identify if he prefers a school type.

We began making contact with coaches at the schools during winter break junior year. For him, this was even early - he knew it should be done, but it was a chore. After the first school visit in February of Junior year, he was more on board.

After changing his mind (unexpectedly), he is committed for next year and very excited. It’s a process, and my kids were drastically different throughout the process, even though their schools are similar types.

Both started their SAT/ACT in the fall of Jr year though. This worked out as a starting point for both.