Because while you are now saying it’s about fit, your comments earlier about academics not good enough came off as - rank focused.
Miami admits 18% and considered a top tier school.
While 52% submit, it’s got a 1340/1450 SAT spread and 30-33 ACT spread. 58% are in the top 10% of the class and 83% in the top quarter. And the Frost School is renowned for music.
Penn State admits well over half. It’s SAT range is 1250 to 1410 and ACT 27-32. A much lower percent - 36% - submit. 37% are in the top 10% and 72% in the top quarter.
They are simply not peers. Miami is Emory light. More in line with Tulane, Rochester but yes because it’s big money, they will party but maybe not as good as Penn State, but flashier.
You now have said it’s not rank but program. So that’s ok. Your comments made it seem like you were looking at reputation rank.if she’s really researched programs and found the best fit her, then that’s great. That said, there will be many a kid at PSU that got into Miami and vice versa.
I’ll say this - Miami RD is a reach. So PSU in many ways would make more sense for your beyond reach list.
Here’s a link to top PhD feeders. Use the right side for per capita. I think you’d be surprised at the names.
A rank is too sell you, not for the real world.
You mentioned General Ed - some schools have less structure than others which may help. Rochester may be that for you.
Good luck