Student IDs That Recognize High Scores Deemed Illegal

<p>at my school, we have these things called lunch passes which allow students to leave campus at lunch time. these are only given to juniors and seniors, but this year, our principal has allowed sophomores to acquire lunch passes at second semester if their freshman state testing scores were either advanced, proficient, or a level up from their previous scores (i.e. below basic to basic).
As incentive for juniors and seniors to do well on their tests, the score qualifications are applied to them as well.
Grades, attendance, and citizenship have always been and remain qualifications for maintaining lunch pass eligibility. </p>

<p>I, personally, being a sophomore myself, like this and dont think it really effects kids who score low in a negative way. I think it serves as incentive for them to strive greater achievement.</p>

<p>^My sentiments exactly about sports too (posts #57, #58, #60). Let’s do away with trophies, awards, and league rankings.</p>

<p>Alfie Kohn, a writer on educational and parenting issues, writes, “ Standardized tests tend to measure the temporary acquisitions of facts and skills, including the skill of test-taking itself, more tan genuine understanding” (Kohn 601). I agree with this because when I took the test, I did not score as well as I would have liked. The reason for this is because the test was not about what I learned in school. It did not reflect who I was as a student because even though I got good grades during high school, my score on the SAT did not illustrate that. I remember some of my other friends who told me that they as well did not score well on the SAT even though they had good grades as well. These tests measure superficial thinking, not the critical thinking that we, as students, were taught in school.</p>

<p>The only problem I see with this is the use of standardized test scores. I’d completely support a GPA-based system like this with a provision that students must be in good standing in terms of attendance and behavior.</p>

<p>This country puts far too much emphasis on athletics and hardly thinks twice before showering athletes with honors and privileges. At the same time, though, academic achievement goes mostly unrewarded (and often socially punished). Why is it acceptable to give honors and privileges to athletes but suddenly elitist to do the same thing for academics?</p>

<p>Just as some are better than others in sports, some are better than others at academics. There’s always going to be people of varying talents and abilities. That’s not a bad thing, and we need to stop treating it like it is.</p>

<p>Perhaps students would be more motivated to succeed if academic success actually obviously meant something. (It does as you move through life, but it often doesn’t look like it’s all that valuable while you’re in high school and academic success gets you branded as a nerd, as opposed to athletic success, which gets you essentially instant popularity.) My high school wasn’t like that, but the overwhelming social atmosphere in this country is one that favors athletics (which is ridiculous, because only a few extremely talented people can actually make a career out of sports).</p>

<p>It’s absolutely ridiculous to whine that your child feels bad because he has low grades and didn’t make the honor roll (regardless of whether it’s recognized on a list or an ID or anything else) - yet people do it, and people listen. To reward and praise those who did better inherently must acknowledge that some did worse. But it’s worth it, because those who did better deserve to be recognized for it.</p>

<p>It’s not the fault of the straight-A student that the straight-C student feels bad about his grades.</p>

<p>I think what the school wants to promote is “behavior” rather than the absolute end result. When I say behavior, it is attendance, showing up on time to every class, no drug/drinking violations, or even number of hours spend on volunteering…Most students are fairly average, there are not that many true genius or stupid people. If students show up to classes and pay attention, by definition they are going to do better, and that´s the kind of behavior which will serve them well in the future. </p>

<p>By just using the standarized tests as a benchmark for rewarding students, I don´t believe that´s the right message to send out. Supposedly, one can´t study for SATs, so what is the school rewarding? People who are better testers? I would rather use GPA as a benchmark because it is something a student could actually have some influence.</p>

<p>Look, athletes get their fancy letter jacket,
the cheerleaders get their social standing,
the better worker gets promoted at work,
and when you play a sport the WINNER gets the shiny trophy not the LOSER.</p>

<p>I think the card idea was great. Yeah, the losers feel bad, but if it’s legal in both life and sports, then why can’t the nerds get something?</p>

<p>Woah. This is my HS.</p>

<p>I’ve been MIA from CC for a while. I saw this post on the front page and recognized the article from Facebook posts from friends still attending that HS.</p>

<p>I’m a Sophomore at Cal Poly and I attended Kennedy HS, graduating in 2010. These cards began the year after I graduated. I have talked to students still attending and understand the general sentiment regarding these cards.</p>

<p>AMA (ask me anything)</p>

<p>@ those commenting on the letter jackets…you do realize that you have to buy them and they are usually like $200 and pretty much EVERYONE can buy them?</p>

<p>Okay lets put it this way: would nerds be satisfied if it were reversed and the jocks were given the IDs for their athletic abilities? </p>

<p>and I agree with everyone who says SATs (and GPA sometimes) don’t really reflect much. Take Einstein for example (someone we all recognize as smart). The man dropped out of school and yet he still managed to create laws that are still in use today…</p>

<p>heey every 1
I just want 2 know do amercian college axcept IGCSE results ?</p>