Students who are choosing not to attend a Christian college

My name is Liam Adams and I am a reporter from The Chronicle of Higher Education. I am interested in interviewing students who are specifically choosing not to attend a Christian college because of the college’s religious identity or a perception of the college being closed off to new perspectives on sexuality or non-orthodox religious perspectives. “Non-orthodox religious perspectives” can refer to a college who doesn’t allow for non-literal interpretations of the Bible or doesn’t welcome pluralistic discussions about the Christian tradition. If this is you, please describe this decision in the thread below.

MODERATOR’S NOTE: Liam has permission from CC to post.

Please keep in mind that the Terms of Service must still be followed in this thread as on the rest of the website.

From the leading tone of your question, I think we have the gist of your article …

@RecusantSam -Even if you see the journalist’s angle in his query, the article will be shaped by the students (or parents) who respond. When I was a journalist myself, I always tried not to be entrenched in the intended direction of any story before I discovered what my interviews revealed, and I think that all good journalists operate similarly. Here, too, the writer is soliciting actual applicant experiences and perhaps he will be surprised by what he learns.

I want to echo @Sally_Rubenstone . I am just as willing to hear about students who desire to attend a Christian college because of the college’s religious identity. My initial topic is an inkling I have found through the reporting I have already done and I am wondering if it’s true for prospective students or not. Thus, I am open to people answering my question with a “no.”
Also, my question applies to different kinds of Christian schools, whether that be Catholic, Evangelical, Methodist, etc. Thank you.

Do you want to hear about students who want to attend a Christian college or don’t want to attend a Christian college?
(Do you want them to define what they call “Christian” since many people disagree, ie., is a Catholic college a Christian college?)

  • If it is “not attend”, then it shouldn’t be in the Christian Colleges forum where by definition only students who want to attend a Christian college post.

@MYOS-I think that the journalist defined his interests clearly, and this is definitely the right forum for his post because students and parents who visit this discussion may simply be considering a Christian college or curious about Christian colleges and aren’t necessarily already committed to this path.

^I’m not trying to be difficult, I was asking to check whether it’s either or both because
this is the first wording

and this is the second wording

I read that s/he’s interested in both situations, is that correct?

@MYOS1634- The journalist was initially seeking students who’d decided NOT to attend a Christian college because of the religious identity. You’ll see that in his original post. But then, in post #4, he adds that he’d also be interested in hearing the flip side … students who DO want to attend a Christian school because of the religious identity.

While the focus of the article will probably be on students who ultimately decided NOT to enroll in a Christian school, I imagine that students who DID decide to enroll in a Christian school can provide helpful balance to the piece.

But currently this is a moot point because you and I are doing most of the posting on this thread, and no one so far has given the reporter any fodder for his story. :frowning:

Thank you @Sally_Rubenstone. I appreciate your efforts to clarify my questions. I will continue to pay attention to this post, but potentially try another forum. As you said, no fodder for the story so far. Thanks.

I am a parent of college students and offer my limited comment. Many traditional colleges in California such as the UC’s CSU’s, private colleges (Stanford, USC), have Christian clubs such as Intervarsity, Cru, Young Life, AACF (Asians), etc.). These student are able to interact with other Christians as well as non-Christian and reach out to the non-Christians. Also, being in a Christian college is almost like being in a “bubble” sheltered from the secular world.

Perhaps I’ll help - my two children, both from a Protestant background, looked at a variety of schools both religious and not. The oldest is at a traditional university because that was her best fit and she is involved in religious life on campus. The second is looking at schools and has some of both on her final list. Specifically, although we’re not Catholic, as a potential nursing student she is very drawn to Jesuit programs because of their philiopshy towards nursing. For her also, she wants a school that is balanced in view points and so far has looked for a balance of attitudes. However, both kids would be uncomfortable in a very conservative environment and yes, would choose not to go there. However, they would be drawn towards a balanced Christian environment. Hope that might help.

@liamadams flagging you to make sure you see these posts. :slight_smile:

In my personal opinion, avoiding a religious college because of the particular religious culture there isn’t an interesting story; it’s boring at best (different strokes for different folks), and at worst, risks denigrating some religious groups (bubble). From your original post, it seems that you are referring specifically to conservative Christian colleges and not, say, Jesuit universities.

(If you are interested in suggestions for other story ideas, I’m sure posters here would be happy to oblige.)

@liamadams , my son was offered a large merit scholarship to a Christian college. He strongly considered it, especially after the president of the college personally called him on the phone and offered to answer his questions. In the end, he decided that it was better to challenge his faith by going to a secular school. He is now a college junior and doesn’t regret his decision.

My daughter is at Notre Dame. It was the only school for her. She see’s herself as a feminist and pro-life. In her words, her Catholic faith allows her to be a feminist is the true meaning of the word; opposing violence, upholding human dignity and speaking out against inequality. ND allows her to be a feminist and pro-life. She had many choices when it came to picking a college. Many other institutions would allow her to be a feminist but would not support her pro-life stance. ND allows her the liberty of both.

Are you only asking for christian perspectives? If so, feel free to ignore because I’m not christian. I don’t know exactly what sort of information you want, but when I was making my transfer decision I had a few open minded jesuit schools on my list, but often those schools are harder to transfer into, and harder to finish on time from.

My niece is looking at med schools right now and is looking almost exclusively at faith based schools because she is anti-abortion and she doesn’t want to be put in a situation where she has to choose between violating her beliefs or being kicked out of the program. She doesn’t particularly care what faith the school is, as long as they will honor her faith.

I chose a Christian college because religion is such a big part of my life that I wouldn’t feel at home anywhere else. I was also attracted to the vast spectrum of religious classes offered there. I wouldn’t be able to dive as deeply into religion at another college. Finally, having a mostly-Christian student body is beneficial personally because it increases the sense of unity. This is probably the only time in my life I will have the opportunity to live in an environment surrounded by people who aren’t constantly challenging my beliefs. It’s not a bad thing to be peppered with questions about your religion, but it does get tiresome after a while.