Thank you all so much! And I apologize for going silent–for some reason, notifications didn’t work for me!
He ultimately decided on Buffalo, though it was a close call. But in the end, he felt that he liked the campus, and it lacked the particular drawbacks of the other schools–in particular, Oneonta’s isolation, and the library situation at Geneseo. (Turns out he really likes browsing the stacks!)
Thank you all so much for weighing in!