So of course Target and Reach are not generic categories, they depend on the individual’s own qualifications. Here is one framework along those lines:
https://support.collegekickstart.com/hc/en-us/articles/217485088-Differences-Between-Likely-Target-Reach-and-Unlikely-Schools
Given this framework, a Likely for one applicant could be a Reach, or even Unlikely, for another applicant, and so on. And that is why normally we do need more information to go on.
That said, my understanding in this case, based on that counselor clause, is that the applicant’s academic profile would likely qualify them for Target status at almost every college which fit those admit rate screens for Civil Engineering, and similarly for Reach options.
But that raises another issue–really we would want to know the admit rate for OOS domestic applicants to Civil Engineering, or alternatively First-Year Engineering, where relevant. That isn’t always easy to know.
You also didn’t mention budget this time, but you have in the past. So I will ignore it this time too, though.
All this is just basically an excuse for suggesting none of this can be too precise.
OK, then as we have discussed before in other contexts, for engineering in general, and not least Civil, it can make sense to favor very large scale engineering programs, most of which are at public universities. Blue + Urban, though, will knock a lot of those out. Like close to Maryland, Virginia Tech and Penn State are extremely obvious choices for someone with a Civil interest. Blue + Urban though?
A bit farther out, would Michigan or Wisconsin count? Minnesota and Pitt, but those are Likelies, right?
And what about Georgia Tech? Atlanta is a big city, but is Georgia blue enough?
I actually think you might need to go all the way to California or Seattle (namely Washington) to really check all of those boxes (Target/Reach for OOS, large scale Civil program, blue state, larger metro location). Which is fine, but then maybe closer but a large college town in a purplish state, like Ann Arbor or Madison, would be preferable? It is a tradeoff issue at that point.
OK, then there are privates, but realistically, Civil at reasonable scale is not that common among privates, and particularly not Reach/Target sorts in more urban locations. Northeastern maybe. NYU I would consider borderline, but maybe. CMU–I honestly doesn’t know if I would recommend it for Civil. The rest I can think of fail the scale, urban, or blue state tests (unless you are thinking Texas is now blue . . . ).
OK, so maybe this is not a long list. And maybe that is OK? Like, suppose what happens is this kid gets into Minnesota or Pitt early, and then is waiting to find out about Maryland. Maybe they also toss in applications to, say, Cal, Washington, and Georgia Tech. And that’s it.
Kinda boring, but not necessarily in a bad way. Civil really isn’t necessarily about exciting college admissions anyway, it is about getting to a program that makes sense and then just doing a lot with that program.