What are your specific extracurriculars? I’m not an expert by any means, but I do think that schools prefer you to hold leadership positions in productive organizations. Like a chairman for Student Council, founder of a successful debate team, etc.
I would suggest taking the SAT with writing and the ACT with writing. This way, you can apply to some Ivies. Amherst, University of Michigan, Georgia Tech, and other schools of that nature strike me as good fits. I’d do research on the quality of the economic programs in Top Tier schools to help guide your search. Additionally, apply to maybe a few state schools or lower-ranked private schools as safety nets, given the unforgiving nature of admissions.