<p>Yes page 51 on this thread by TFACLE first/second deadline…that is the only case where the person clearly showed that they knew what they were talking about and had status change to complete but was unfortunately still rejected. Besides that there was one more somewhere but it seemed that it was possible they were confusing it with the green complete on the overall status page.
But yes it seems that chances are good that if they look at your transitional funding that you got accepted. Although definitely lots of people who see no changes but are still accepted. I guess it just depends on whom they get to first. However, I think there are many more people posting acceptances than rejections and therefore it could be that many people with completed tf still get rejected. So I think the answer is just to wait.</p>
<p>If u look through this thread in earlier pages from the time they got their tf status until the day they found out if they were or not accepted you’ll see it doesn’t matter.</p>
<p>I’ve been lurking through all 137 pages on this thread, and thanks all for your info and helping me pass the time. Now that I’m at the end figured I shd contribute as well so here goes… And in apparent CC tradition, I brought out my first user name ever as well lol.</p>
<p>5DL
Final Interview: April 3rd
TF Submitted: April 8th (post deadline, my status just updated from under review to incomplete - YES next to grants and loans, NO next to tax/fafsa so I will be correcting that later) </p>
<p>In my opinion, after reading all the threads, having them review your file seems like a good indicator, but not a guarantee. If they don’t, it may update the morning of. But also, if not at all, it leans negative but with exceptions. SO basically, we shouldn’t obsess over this like I have been doing anyways. Seems like most people get some type of review 7 days before the dl, but they’re doing some every day regardless, so again TF status changes mean??? But I am glad that they looked at mine lol. </p>
<p>Also, everyone in my final interview in Chicago did very well, with maybe 2-3 exceptional sample lessons (11 ppl, 3 men, 2 ppl of color). One used the most memorable visual aid ever (on measurements). And the other, gave candy and danced through the digestive track. Personally, I thought I did alright with each part, but I could’ve done better with everything. For example, I was the only person without a visual aid/handout. And one of my recommenders didn’t submit until a week late… So I have no idea, but hope I’m accepted and placed anywhere.</p>
<p>I listed about 15 locations. My HP were Chicago (I’m from here), Jacksonville, Rio Grande, Houston, Washington, Mississippi, OK, DC…</p>
<p>Good luck everyone! Only one more week to go. And I will be on the webinar as well tonight.</p>
<p>Hey Toots!</p>
<p>I didn’t even think about the whole minority thing which is a good point. To break my interview down there were 10 of us 9 women and 1 man. It was quite a few blacks I think 5 and one Hispanic who wanted to teach Spanish in Mexico! Yay her the lessons went good only half the people were on time! Me and two others was the first in the room they ask us to go wait in the waiting room lol we didn’t know. A girl came in 5 mins late then another came 25 mins and then one came lurking a good 35 mins later as well. The interviewers kept a straight face even when one of the late ones complained at the end TFA was to blame for her lateness bc the horrible directions given on our paper…lmao! It reminded me of the lady in the video the African one that went off on the teacher about the email he sent. She talked just like her with a little more attitude…all the other applicants looked at each other like really?</p>
<p>Welcome Toots! And thanks for your concise analysis of the tf status! Best of luck to all the newcomers!</p>
<p>I’m just happy I have this forum so I’m not waiting alone!
</p>
<p>Blessed, I’m equally as surprised as the other people in your group seem. Although coming late is bad, it is probably more forgivable than not having a positive attitude, and passing the blame. Even if the directions told someone to drive a clown car to the coast and then swim to Japan for their interview, I feel like getting flustered and letting that break their coolness and positivity would be a negative in their file, especially because TFA says they look for applicants who are flexible and can adapt. </p>
<p>This is also probably a good point to make, in case future applicants look at this thread: remain upbeat and positive the entire day. Participate, and act like you are happy/honored to be there. ESPECIALLY if something goes wrong–in that case it would show that you can remain collected in the face of difficulties.</p>
<p>I wasnt very impressed with the other applicants at my interview. 2 were no-shows and 2 were late. There were 10 of us, only one male. Almost everyone had travelled very far to get there. I was only 1 of 2 who actually lived in Philadelphia. I was also one of 3 who had been out of college at least a couple years and I was like the only one with essentially zero teaching exPerience. But I really dont think that made a difference…the others who were mostly elementary education undergrads seemed to sort of over-rely on the props they brought. Most of them had unclear or unstated objectives to their lessons. I know we’re not supposed to compare to others at the interview, I just found the demographics tO be atypical- specifically all these education majors driving for hours to get to Philly and using so many props that didn’t always aid learning. Its nice to learn about others’ interview experiences on here from other cities!</p>
<p>@Scootersloth Exactly! Not to mention when she came in I guess she didn’t want to sit where she was assigned which was next to me I had just finished my lesson she took my seat and grabbed her name tag which was rt next to her hence her seat lol I just smiled and sat in her seat slid my stuff to my new seat and carried on none the less when I finally got to my one-on-one the first thing my interviewer said was I’ve been watching you all day and seen you work very well with everyone and was looking very forward to our one on one…they really do look at everything…I mean EVERYTHING </p>
<p>And yes</p>
<p>@obiejess I am an education major as well I understand what your saying tho I didn’t even want to mention it to the other applicants but of course it came up I teach kindergarten now one applicant taught prek at a non profit organization but wasn’t an education major, one was a GED teacher from Athens the one who wanted to teach Spanish in Mexico it was like 2 who wanted to teach English but had other jobs unrelated and a boy from Morehouse who was in between going pro in basketball and doing this and going to law school …yea but only thing that bothered me during people lessons were their objectives I think they should of looked up what n objective was one said geography.another said subtraction but it didn’t even say what was to be expected…I guess it’s just me I just thought those were like topics not really objectives lol</p>
<p>Hearing about you guys’ experience makes me think that maybe applicants for the last deadline are maybe not as good as earlier deadlines? I applied last year and did not get in. I went to my final interview last year and was very very impressed by the applicants. No one was late, no no-shows, everyone was extremely modest yet excellent. Every single person ended their lesson right on time, except for me (maybe contributing to why I didn’t get in, among other factors). I applied first deadline last year.
This year I obviously applied last deadline. In my final interview, I was shocked at the significant drop in quality of the applicants. During break, the applicants were bragging about accomplishments that were clearly lies to make themselves look
‘better’. The general attitude was just different and completely put me off. Most of the people came off very arrogant and thought they were the best people that ever walked earth. And then when it came to the lessons, a bunch of the lessons had almost no interaction. Literally no one (except for me this time because I learnt from last year) was on time with lesson. Majority run out of time before getting to the assessment and a few were early. Quite a few tried to cover way too much in their lesson. If some of the people were not majoring in the topic they were teaching, we would not have been able to answer a bunch of the assessment questions. One girl was literally done in 2 minutes with her lesson O.O one or two clearly did not prepare much for their lesson.
Group activity was terrible too. People were just trying to talk over each other. No reference to the readings and no correlation between what one person says to the next person who talks. So it was clear people were talking not to come up with a solution but just to talk. And even more clear was they did not pay attention to what other people had to say. From my experience last year, I think in fact tfa is looking for people who are willing to listen in this activity and contribute just a few ideas. From what I saw, pretty much everyone was doing everything wrong throughout the interview. Even at the end when people were askin questions, the questions came off as if they were hinting that tfa teachers are way better than regular teachers. It was just an absurd amount of arrogance for the poor performance that the group had.
I had 8 people in my round (supposed to be 10, 2 didn’t show) and only one African American, 2 Asians, one male, rest are girls.
I know they say it’s not competitive with the people interviewing but I’m sure it makes a difference. I mean it’s human nature to compare and if you are in a room with every one screwing something up and all you did was not do anything very wrong you would already stand out. Versus if you are in a room with much more competent people, any little thing you do wrong is looked at.</p>
<p>Haha @sowhatdouknow- seriously, why so arrogant? You are 21-22 year-olds! I was literally shocked because I felt as though I’ve done so much research to determine if TFA was right for me. I’ve talked with several alumni, read Wendy Kopp’s books, read Relentless Pursuit, read all the controversies, etc. I also considered other routes like urban education masters programs, but heard mixed results. I’ve also applied with TNTP. But talking to the other applicants during lunch break, they didn’t know who Wendy Kopp was! I couldn’t believe it…I hope it is just a 5th DL thing, interesting theory!</p>
<p>@sowhatdouknow I think I read some things you posted before in earlier pages rt? I don’t think the fifth deadline is any different from applying the first deadline except for placements bc a lot were unavailable in the last deadline I seen a lot of people who I thought wouldn’t of made it that far but really u get to the final on everything u put down on Paper a lot of them bypass a phone interview like u said people in ur group talked them self up and even in my group the African lady that went off she said b4 doing this she had just came from Ghana teaching u could imagine how that looked in person but when you meet a person not only for the first time but have the chance to be around them for hours you see other traits…you’ll be surprise how many people are so unaware of that I read so many threads before my final interview did a phone conference thing and that stood out the most to me the lady said ur interview start from the minute u walk in the door I tried to treat them as I would treat my friends when It came down to lessons I helped them pass out their materials bc I myself knew I needed some help…</p>
<p>Wow, I can’t believe people would still go to an interview when they have not prepared themselves! My interview day was a lot more positive. My interview day had 4 other people (the other day at my location was full…just how our schedules work out here.) Everyone was laid back, friendly, and non-confrontational. Out of 5 (including me), there were 3 males and 2 people of color. I volunteered to present my lesson first, and was the only person who used colorful posters and a handout that clearly had a lot of time spent on developing them. Only one other person had posters, and it seemed that they were prepared fairly quickly. Most people had handouts (some better quality than others). Two people went over their 1 minute prep time, 3 people went over their 5 minute time for the lesson. 1 person just lectured for 5 minutes, and didn’t have any form of activity or discussion. No one was really terrible with their lesson, but it was very clear who spent the time to practice and develop an outstanding lesson. People were all very willing to listen and respond to others in the discussion, and I think we all exhibited great balance in that sense.</p>
<p>I think the lessons really reflect who takes the time to read the TFA materials and practice. TFA isn’t hard to interview for–they tell you what they want, and you just have to execute it. It is not hard to find additional materials that explain the interview and lesson more than what is on their website. For example, there are TFA lesson examples on youtube, people talk about it in blogs and on forums, and even a quick search will turn up the books “Destination: Teach for America” and “Teaching as Leadership.” (Teaching as Leadership actually goes in depth about good lesson plans and structures, and really helped me format my 5 minute activity.) </p>
<p>The interviewers give you a one minute warning too. I had come across this information when developing my lesson, and designed it so the one minute warning would coincide with me ending an activity and going into the closing/exit slip portion of the lesson.</p>
<p>It bothers me that in your stories it is quite apparent some people don’t spend much time preparing. I think that a final round interview is yours to make or break–and if you aren’t going to spend the time to “make” it, to prepare yourself to the best of your abilities, then why even bother with the whole process?</p>
<p>Blessed,
I don’t mean to offend you with what i said. I did see a drastic change in the quality of applicants this interview versus last years’ first deadline. However, that could mean a lot of things and it could definitely just be that I happened to get an amazing group last year or that I happened to get a less stellar group this year. Or perhaps my standards are higher this year. But I just wanted to throw my thoughts out since it seems that quite a few had a less than great experience with the other applicants. I want to emphasize that by no means am I saying any of us are less qualified. I think from the conversation here, it’s clear that we all put forth a lot of effort. I just wish we can all be accepted! Lol</p>
<p>@nothingcompares,
Has your tf status been updated since you uploaded the new documents? Mine hasn’t :(</p>
<p>@sowhatdoyouknow no change yet! I wouldn’t worry about it too much since it’s at least changed once! </p>
<p>Thanks for all the info everyone! I, too, don’t believe a change in tf status is an absolute predictor, but I’d rather have mine change than not.</p>
<p>@sowhatdoyouknow I hope we all make it as well! I wish I had the time to apply earlier that way if I didn’t get in I would have time to apply again! I just hate that if I don’t get it I would have to wait until next year…ugh that sucks!</p>
<p>Ohhh I just checked my TF I turned all my documents in on 3/25 so maybe that’s y it changed so fast?</p>
<p>@Blessed,
Question about your post saying that you wish you would have applied earlier so you could apply again if not accepted instead of waiting for the next year–I thought each applicant could only apply once per year? (Maybe I misunderstood your post, or maybe I misunderstood some information about applying.)</p>
<p>Hey everyone! </p>
<p>So I have also been kind of reading along the forum since I applied for the 5DL and I hadn’t said anything yet. I felt now was a good time to say something since everyone is in the same boat and I am kind of going crazy with anticipation! I had my interview last Friday. Everything went really well and I felt that all the other interviewees did good. I had two Hispanic (including myself) and three Caucasian women in total and everyone was super sweet and really nice. All of us showed up on time and our lessons went pretty well. I felt like I put a lot of preparation time into my lesson and so did the other girls except one who just lectured for about 4.5 minutes and then had us do our handout. I feel like our group activity was well balanced for the most part with the exception of one girl just saying “great idea” or “that was my idea too” most of the time. My one-on-one sort of threw me off a little just because we talked a lot about one of the classes I didn’t do so hot in. Anyone else get a question like this? Overall I felt like the day went really well. </p>
<p>A little background about me: I graduated from my undergrad this past August and I am hoping to teach elementary school. I am from Texas and wanting to move somewhere new.</p>
<p>My top five placement choices are:
- Washington, D.C.
- Baltimore
- Philly
- Colorado (I chose to have them tie)
- Dallas Fort Worth
- Massachusetts </p>
<p>My TF status is still “under review” but I wasn’t able to submit my form until April 6th and it said that if we wanted to have an answer by the 18th then we needed to submit by the 5th. I had to wait on a document and that put me back a little so I don’t know if I should even be hopeful that it’ll change before we find out. What do y’all think? Anyone in the same boat?</p>
<p>@ Scootersloth and Blessed,
We can only apply once a year. Doesn’t matter which deadline. This is for sure a fact.</p>
<p>Blessed,
From earlier threads, it seems that it doesn’t really matter when you submitted yours or which day of the week you interviewed. Yours changed the same time nothingcompares and mine turned to incomplete. I would think if we didn’t get our docs wrong, we would’ve gotten the complete at the same time as you. I submitted mine late (after my interview), and I still got the notification, also my interview was on friday so that’s as late as can be.
My guess is they have to do things quicker for this deadline than previous since everything is so crammed.</p>
<p>The only thing that matters is if you were accepted or not :p</p>
<p>Wishful thinking…</p>