<p>UT,
I like the question and think it deserves a lot more attention from prospective students. Still, research and teaching excellence need not be mutually exclusive. You can find plenty of good teachers at colleges most renown for their research. Likewise, you can find research opportunities even at small LACs that are known for their teaching. </p>
<p>I am a huge proponent of checking out what current students and very recent grads are saying about the teaching at their colleges. There are lots of sources for this and I suggest that you look at several. My experience is that patterns repeat and schools that provide the most effective classroom learning are consistently recognized for this. Proximity/access to profs is a recurring theme as is the benefit derived from learning in a small classroom with able peers. </p>
<p>One exercise that I recently did for the USNWR Top 50 national universities involved combining two datapoints—the USNWR PA score for research accomplishment and the CP grade for teaching excellence. I summed these two scores and came up with the following scores and “ranking” for the best blends of research and teaching. Pretty crude stuff, I acknowledge, but maybe it will prompt you to investigate further into some of these colleges.</p>
<p>(CP grade scale was 5.0 for A+, 4.5 for A, 4.0 for A-, 3.5 for B+, 3.0 for B)</p>
<p>Rank , Combined Research/Teaching Score , College</p>
<p>1 , 9.9 , MIT
1 , 9.9 , Princeton
1 , 9.9 , Stanford
4 , 9.6 , Caltech
4 , 9.6 , U Chicago
6 , 9.4 , Harvard
7 , 9.3 , Dartmouth
7 , 9.3 , Yale
9 , 9.1 , Columbia
10 , 9.0 , U Penn
11 , 8.9 , Brown
11 , 8.9 , Duke
13 , 8.8 , Northwestern
14 , 8.7 , Carnegie Mellon
14 , 8.7 , UC BERKELEY
16 , 8.5 , Cornell
16 , 8.5 , Emory
16 , 8.5 , Johns Hopkins
16 , 8.5 , Rice
16 , 8.5 , Vanderbilt
21 , 8.3 , U VIRGINIA
22 , 8.2 , UCLA
23 , 8.1 , Tufts
23 , 8.1 , Wash U
25 , 8.0 , Georgetown
25 , 8.0 , GEORGIA TECH
27 , 7.9 , U MICHIGAN
27 , 7.9 , U Rochester
27 , 7.9 , USC
30 , 7.8 , Notre Dame
30 , 7.8 , WILLIAM & MARY
32 , 7.6 , U N CAROLINA
32 , 7.6 , U WISCONSIN
34 , 7.5 , Brandeis
34 , 7.5 , U ILLINOIS
36 , 7.4 , U TEXAS
37 , 7.3 , NYU
37 , 7.3 , Tulane
37 , 7.3 , UC SAN DIEGO
40 , 7.2 , Lehigh
41 , 7.1 , U Miami
42 , 7.0 , Boston College
42 , 7.0 , Case Western
42 , 7.0 , Rensselaer
42 , 7.0 , UC S BARBARA
42 , 7.0 , Wake Forest
47 , 6.8 , PENN STATE
47 , 6.8 , U WASHINGTON
47 , 6.8 , UC DAVIS
50 , 6.6 , U FLORIDA
50 , 6.6 , UC IRVINE</p>