The Great Essay

<p>I came across this essay which touched my heart. </p>

<p>I want to share this essay with all of you. Please go through it and post your reflection down here…</p>

<p>[“From</a> the slum to the theatre”](<a href=“http://www.essayforum.com/scholarship-essays-22/the-slum-theatre-questbridge-essay-due-days-19184/]"From”>http://www.essayforum.com/scholarship-essays-22/the-slum-theatre-questbridge-essay-due-days-19184/)</p>

<p>Tells an amazing story, but is not the best written essay. do you know where/if he was accepted?</p>

<p>No idea…</p>

<p>Good story, from the looks, but too much of a complaining/whining tone. He’s making too many excuses for his poor scores. I read the first two paragraphs and the last and got sick of it. </p>

<p>Note: I grew up in rural China so don’t tell me that “oh, but you haven’t been through these challenges”. Trust me, I have, and in my essay, I did not insert any complaints, about 1 sentence describing the problem and instead focused on what I accomplished despite the challenges.</p>

<p>So…Good idea, badly written.</p>

<p>Interesting story, but the essay itself is a turn-off. I think it would have been better if the writer took most of the subjective sentences out and told the story as it was, to lessen the “complaining” factor.</p>

<p>It was ok… the part about the SAT was ridiulous though. “I now had to prepare for the test in 34 days”. WTH? Most people I know (including me) prepared for the test the night before and did fine… I understand that one has the right to study if they need to, but saying something like that is just crazy.</p>

<p>I admire his ambition and tenacity though.</p>

<p>Lol, that is possibly the worst line to submit in a college essay. Colleges know that students prepare for the SAT, they don’t need to be told. That line alone could kill an essay.</p>

<p>DreamsUnlimited, I can understand why this essay might move your heart, especially if you are an imaginative individual who always vividly picture what you read. I read that way as well, but because I have been through similar if not worse experiences, I do not feel the same way as you do after reading the essay. Considering the broad geographic and demographic range of students that admissions officers have been in contact with, I do not think they would be moved as well. So judging the quality I must say it is only mediocre if not excessive in certain unnecessary details. </p>

<p>It is a good essay, just not a good college app essay.</p>

<p>hmm, I seem to understand both sides of the spectrum, which can be interpreted by any admissions person</p>

<p>it shows the person’s struggles, determination, and other personal qualities. it is true that it may seem a bit on the “excuse” side for SAT and such. But, it also shows his situations, where so many hurdles come up unexpectedly during his studies, such as financial difficulties, lack of resources, etc. Hard to judge how the person did in his college acceptances</p>