Truly sad, and pathetic.
Grade inflation and expectations. How often do we see here - get a B and your life is over. The Nashville teacher who quit - sad.
Obviously most don’t have the means to do this.
The AI thing I get. If you’re truly innocent, why accept guilt ? But few have money for lawyers.
Interesting article.
Maybe elementary school is the place to teach so you don’t have to deal.
So a third grader sticks his tongue out and the other kid kicks him and then tells teacher he got kicked.
On his report card, the teacher wrote that the boy was “working on his responses to peers when he is frustrated” and “developing his ability to listen to others’ perspectives and collaborate with humility.”
Now that’s AI !
Old days… “No kicking and don’t stick your tongue out at others. You both know better. Say you’re sorry. Go sit in the corner.”
I’m leary of AI checking for AI but honestly don’t know enough about how it works. I do know my DIL (college professor in history) is going “blue book” exams.
the AI one is legit complaint, honestly, I agree.
The complaining about comment about playing well with others ? OMG!!! yikes.
IMHO, this is the crux of the problem. Seriously, when did people become so rabid about their kids needing to be accepted to an elite school? It’s absurd.
Fueling this friction is the narrow path into a top U.S. university, argues Rowena Chiu, a Palo Alto school board member and mother of four. “To get your child into an elite university these days seems more impossible than ever,” she said. “I think that does trickle down into nervousness about a particular grade.”
The Disputed Project Submissions. For the major project at the center of the dispute, the student submitted multiple versions. The parent stated her daughter lost her original piece, started over, and turned in an incomplete replacement that received a score of 10. After the student missed Hardcastle’s retake deadline, the student completed a finished piece of artwork at home—after she had already been moved out of Hardcastle’s class—which the school principal accepted and independently scored. [1, 2]
Student supposedly had an “A” before the assignment which dropped to a “C” after receiving a failing grade (10 because you can’t give zero). Ultimately she got a “B” in the class after administration changed it after she turned in the project and it was graded.
Good or bad I’m not sure it was worth quitting over. Must be more.
Other than being constantly undermined and overruled by your bosses?
I am a parent, and there were rumors when I was in prep school of kids who paid others to take SATs for them back home in NYC (most of us took SATs at school, a few boarders took them “at home” in NYC- no clue if it was true, or just gossip) but people caring about elite schools is not new in certain circles, just WAY more widespread.
Of course there was always some of this, but I agree there has been a rise in what I would call an artificial scarcity, or alternatively “Hunger Games”, mindset when it comes to what count as acceptable colleges. And from what I understand of the relevant data, this trend is mostly concentrated in certain specific areas, communities, and social circles.
And then contributing factors include rising costs of living relative to professional salaries in relevant areas, not least when it comes to housing costs. So, there is some legitimate concern among professional-class parents in VHCOL metros that if the kids merely repeat the sort of professional path they followed, they will not be able to afford to buy into the same neighborhoods, schools, clubs, and so on. Indeed, to maintain the same standard of living, they may need to move to a different metro area entirely.
And then there is also the generally increasing inequality of wealth in the US, or indeed the world, which doesn’t just apply to, say, the top 10% versus the median, but also the top 1% versus the top 10%, top 0.1% versus the top 1%, and so on. And so, assuming you think like this to begin with, no matter how well you do, it is almost always possible to feel like you are falling behind someone else in comparison, even as others feel the same way when comparing themselves to you.
OK, so then if you are, say, a top 2-10% sort of parent by wealth, but maybe you live in a VHCOL area, and maybe you have decent visibility into top 1% families, and so on, and you are the sort of parent who is bothered by such comparisons, you may feel like your kid needs to go to a top 1% school so that they, and really you, can compete to move up to that higher level. And you may also fear if they aren’t moving up, instead they will move “down” as you see things. Like, actually have to go make their professional lives in Cleveland, or some other inconceivable place like that.
At the risk of displaying my ignorance, what does “VHCOL” stand for – Very High Cost of Living?
Yes. e.g. San Francisco, Silicon Valley, NYC
Yes, exactly. There is no precise definition, but the basic idea is there isn’t just a divide between some low COL and some high COL areas in the US. There are then some specific areas where the COL is notably higher than even most other high COL areas, hence very high COL, or VHCOL.
Long story short, housing costs are a big part of that difference, and then that factor really expanded out in recent decades. Like at the beginning of 2000, comparable houses were already more expensive in the SF metro than the Cleveland metro. However, since then, prices have gone up about 1.75X as much in SF as Cleveland.
This feeds into what I was describing, because if you are old enough such that you were able to buy a starter home in SF before the first housing bubble, or alternatively at least after the first housing bubble burst in the early 2010s or so, you were able to then ride up housing prices since then. But now you may be worrying about your kids trying to do the same thing at these elevated price points.
Which wouldn’t matter so much if professional salaries had also increased 1.75X in SF versus Cleveland since 2000, but they largely have not. I can’t look this up as easily over time, but right now a comparable surgeon, say, might make 1.3X in SF versus Cleveland (per salary.com data). Not bad, but not nearly enough to make up the housing cost difference, or the COL difference in general.
The horror of it all! ![]()
Yeah, the broad history of modern industrialized economies includes kids moving away from their parents to wherever their economic opportunities are best, and indeed possibly doing a major relocation more than once. And getting a good college education has often made that much more viable, such that college-educated young adults tend to be by far the most mobile major segment of the working population in modern developed countries.
But recently there has been some observable slowing down of this effect in the US. Again the possible causes are complex, and may well include some of these housing cost and general COL issues.
But things could potentially swing back. However, it could take a while, particularly if people would need to change some long-standing attitudes about where their opportunities were actually the best.
My sister taught 5th grade. When parents said their child ‘didn’t deserve’ a grade, my sister would just say ‘what grade do you think they deserve?’ Rarely did they say A. FIFTH grade. These kids weren’t going to Harvard. They weren’t even trying to get into a special middle school or competitive high school.
My daughter teaches art to middle and high school at a charter school. No homework so all work is done in class. Except some kids do nothing but talk to their friends. I think the lowest grade she can give is a 60 and she’ll do it. And their parents will complain. These are the same parents who came to Back to School night and loved the work they’d already done (cave drawings and she lit the room to look like a cave).
It’s sad because daughter is trying hard to make art fun. She’s doing ‘the history of art’ starting with the cave drawings and I know they’ve done Greece and Egypt, and now will move through all the other ‘ages’ until they get to modern art. They’ve spray painted things, made marbled paper with shaving cream. they could all have As if they just tried. Just a little.
Our kids didn’t get all A grades. All we asked them was “did you do your personal best?” Because that was all that mattered. So what if they got a B grade, or even a C grade (which both never got in high school but both got C grades in college).
Sue? Give me a break.
I know it’s not feasible in high school with teachers seeing over 100 students a day, but I loved that my kid didn’t have grades through middle school. They had a narrative, test scores and a portfolio. There was no way to inflate/deflate grades, I actually saw the end product and I got feedback from the teacher. It also prevented jockeying for class standing.
I hear the VHCOL argument all the time and I’m not sure I buy it. Or at least it explains one slice of the pie- but not all of it.
I live in an urban part of the Northeast, which is allegedly Ground Zero for ultra competitive academics, kids in fourth grade gunning for Harvard, etc. And yes, housing prices are insane relative to when we moved to the East Coast from a city in the Midwest- for kicks and giggles I sometimes look at prices and photos of houses in my old neighborhood.
BUT- you would be surprised at the number of people I know IRL who are just as delighted that their son is going to Seton Hall or their daughter is going to Quinnipiac or that their senior at Hofstra just got a student teaching job at the school system she wanted. No Ivy fever- at all. Normal people with normal jobs whose kids find a college which is affordable and meets their educational needs and then launches into some career or other- at times the kids take a decade for grad school or more training or several pivots. And at other times the kids find what they want in their early 20’s.
But I just don’t see the “OMG houses are so expensive unless my kid becomes an investment banker she’ll never be able to afford to live here”. Kids go where they go and settle where they settle. And thinking that you’ll have a finger on the scale for having a kid move back because you made sure they got all A’s and learned fencing in middle school is really delusional.
I will say that I admire the military families I know in this regard. Whether the kid is at, or graduated from one of the academies, or did ROTC, or decided after college graduation to do OCS, or ended up in JAG after law school-- these families don’t delude themselves that Johnny or Susie is going to be coming for Sunday dinner every week. They celebrate the “good” postings (usually means somewhere without active warfare, not a cushy neighborhood) and worry themselves ragged at the dangerous postings (don’t ask how families with kids in the military are coping with this “it’s not a war it’s an excursion” going on). But they accept their kid’s choice to serve and understand that Mommy calling the commanding officer to complain that the kid didn’t get ranked the way he needed to in order to qualify for Ranger/Seal whatever training-- that doesn’t happen.
There have been a few lawsuits filed for valedictorian & salutatorian title disputes, like this one in Texas. The student’s family that sued won the lawsuit & the student was named valedictorian.
2 families say their student at Spring charter school should be named valedictorian over GPA dispute (6/1/2026)