<p>
Surveying more people is not necessarily a good solution. If most (or even some) of the survey results are garbage, the collective result will still be garbage at worst and questionable at best. </p>
<p>What’s worrisome about the results coming out of Berkeley, Florida, Wisconsin, et al is that those are top schools. The administrators and faculty at those schools are far more likely to be familiar with their colleagues and practices at peer institutions. Quite frankly, I would expect an administrator at Wisconsin to be much more conversant with Michigan than someone from, say, Arkansas State…yet it was the former institution that ranked Michigan the lowest.</p>
<p>That’s not to say I don’t like the peer assessment results. With minor adjustments, I would mostly agree. I still don’t like or trust the methodology, however.</p>