In order of most to least represented:
- Harvard
- Stanford
- Columbia 4.MIT 5.Penn
In order of most to least represented:
No surprises there: HCPSM
Hah! As said in the movie Mean Girls, @Much2learn - stop trying to make “HCPSM” happen.
I think the big news here is Wharton - 16 of the 26 U. of Penn people on the list are whartonites. That’s crazy! It looks like Wharton continues to be one of the prize assets for the U.
@cue7 “Hah! As said in the movie Mean Girls, @Much2learn - stop trying to make “HCPSM” happen.”
They were talking about Penn in Mean Girls? Wow!
Even more ridiculous, just the other day, someone was trying to convince me that the P in HYPSM didn’t stand for Penn, but for some school with no top ranked Medical School, no top ranked Business School, and no top ranked Law School at all. Basically just an overgrown LAC. How crazy is that?
@Much2learn - and how crazy is it that, as recently as 10-15 years ago, having a liberal arts college surrounded by professional schools was considered a BAD thing, impure in some way? Even more silly, 20 years ago, going to an elite school to study for a “trade” was a faux pas!
How times change - and who knows how they will change in the future.
@cue7 “20 years ago, going to an elite school to study for a “trade” was a faux pas!”
Why study engineering or business when you could learn ancient Greek or Latin? It does seem silly today.
The idea was: College offered you the chance to learn things (like greek or latin or anthropology or whatever) that you couldn’t learn elsewhere, so why waste time learning a trade? Learning those subjects, then, would also inform how you’d think. You could then learn everything you needed to about a trade either on the job or through a company’s training program, but college would teach you how to think.
This idea, though, has frayed for a large number of reasons. Now, schools are touting their pre-professional or skills-based educational systems, and certain schools are benefitting from the pendulum swinging in this direction. (Schools like Penn, Northwestern, Cornell, etc.)
@Cue7 The two types of learning you are describing are not mutually exclusive. College can still teach you how to think and also teach you practical skills.
You probably mean 20+ years ago for your first point and over 30 years ago about going to study a “trade”. 10-15 years ago it was perfectly acceptable. Times change.
And why is that big news or makes any difference? This list overwhelmingly rewards entrepreneurial success. I bet you that a huge percentage of the people on that list are business-school grads. Still there are 26 Penn grads on the list.
@Penn95 - yes, the types of learning are NOT mutually exclusive, BUT, there was a thought that, back in the day, many places could teach you practical skills - and college was one of the only places where you could learn to think (and have access to subjects not found elsewhere).
Also, why are you quibbling over the timing? Whether it was 15 yrs ago or 20+ years ago, the fact is there were arguments made about how being surrounded by professional schools was a detriment to a college environment. I defer to your narrative here, as you pay much closer attention to details, but how does this make a difference? Yes, times change - but the point is about the change. Whether it happened 15 years ago or 20 years ago, the point is the pendulum swings. What’s dominant now may not be in 10, 15, 20 years.
Finally, how is it not big news that 16 of 26 are Whartonites? Yes it’s an entrepreneurial prize, and this mainly points, then, to Wharton’s strength here. BUT Wharton is just a fraction of the university, and it’s producing a disproportionate share here - that’s big news. Remember, Penn has other divisions that are entrepreneurial - the College, the Engineering school, the comp sci dep’t, etc. etc. - and the rest of the U did well (producing 11 on the list is no joke). Wharton dominated though. It’s not even that large (undergrad + grad is what, maybe 4500 students?), but it produced 16 winners.
@Cue7 The other parts of the university are entrepreneurial but not to that extent, I dont think it is surprising that 60% of the Penn people are business people. Penn is not an engineering powerhouse like MIT or Stanford so i wouldn’t expect the majority of the list to be Penn engineers. Just like most likely the list has more HBS graduates than Harvard engineers.
Right but there are other schools that have a strong entrepreneurial spirit - Berkeley, Carnegie Mellon, Duke, Michigan, etc. Wharton though, ON ITS OWN, still probably bests those other schools on this list.
That’s what’s most impressive, to me. For a relatively small school within a larger school (compared to all these others) - producing 16 is huge - the bigger story than the rest of the university producing 11.