transfers and relationships

<p>You might have seen me post on transfer forums before, so some of you may know that I’m applying to Penn as a sophomore transfer. I’ve wanted to go there since my sophomore year of high school, and I have written my many reasons for wanting to transfer in my Why Penn and Why Transfer essays.</p>

<p>But, now, things have changed a little bit. At the end of my senior year, I started going out with someone from my high school who goes to Penn now. We’re still together, so he wants me to be there with him next year as well. What are your thoughts - would it hurt my chances of admission if he wrote a “letter of recommendation” in which talks about my good qualities and says why I would be a good candidate for admission?</p>

<p>I feel like anything he says that’s positive about me would help Penn know some more about me, but it might also lead them to think he’s the only reason I want to go there. Any suggestions?</p>

<p>Reccomendations from family members/friends/girlfriends/boyfriends are certainly frowned upon. Nothing from one of those reccomendations can be taken seriously, seeing as how they are expected to praise you. In my opinion, that would significantly reduce the integrity of your application. Instead, you might mention him in your essay. Not in regards to why you want to attend Penn, but instead use him as a way to show that you are aware what the environment at Penn is like, and that it would be a good fit for you.</p>

<p>lol bad idea</p>

<p>Bad idea imo. Really bad idea.</p>

<p>I talked to my boyfriend about this again today. Apparently he was planning to write a letter that was more him telling them how badly he wants me at Penn rather than focusing on my strengths and info my teacher recs would have. After a year of having been apart, him and I are both extremely lonely and unhappy. He seriously may be going through minor depression since it’s so tough for us to be without one another for so long. If he conveyed this in his letter and added a disclaimer saying I’ve wanted to go to Penn since my sophomore year in high school and that I applied there ED as a senior and that we met through our common interest in Penn, would it still be such a bad idea? Could it hurt me?</p>

<p>Definitely not. No matter what the actual circumstance, it WILL make it appear as though you’re only going there to be with him…just DON’T DO IT.</p>

<p>Focus on the academic reasons why you wish to transfer. All that other stuff you mentioned makes you look immature, too emotional and not a serious student.</p>

<p>Look, even if this person can write an honestly flattering testimony to your abilities, the admissions committee is going to see it as coming from someone who has an interest in the following:</p>

<ol>
<li>Not upsetting you by writing a bad letter.<br></li>
<li>Benefiting from your enrollment at Penn beyond that of the normal satisfaction a letter writer experiences.</li>
<li>Fulfilling an obligation (ie, feeling as though they just have to write a letter).</li>
</ol>

<p>This skews the perception of the letter’s content pretty sharply. Not a good thing, is it?</p>

<p>I’m in a long distance relationship right now, so believe me, I know what you’re going through.</p>

<p>Nevertheless - everybody else on this thread is right! A rec. letter from him will do nothing for you. Think about what a letter like that should convey - an unbiased opinion from somebody who has tested your intellectual ability and talent himself. A letter from him would convey the worst possible reason to transfer (to be with your boyfriend, as opposed to everybody that’s applying because Penn has amazing opportunities and majors) and would show that you have nothing better to say.</p>

<p>I am guessing you application is complete. I wish you the best of luck, but you need to leave it be. If I make it to Penn, I will be able to see my girlfriend every week, so I’m sort of in it the same way, but nothing in my application mentioned that. I focused on the academics potential and fit of my dream school.</p>

<p>Good luck!</p>