Tufts vs. Alabama

I am a senior and am interested in engineering. I have a 3.99 UW GPA and 33 ACT. My parents won’t be able to help much at all with paying for college but they make enough money to disqualify me for a lot of aid. I have been accepted into Alabama and got the presidential scholarship plus another one, so my total per year would be about $16,000. I play hockey and have been recruited by tufts in the nescac, but to play there I’d have to take a gap year to play junior hockey. Tufts would probably end up costing around $25,000 according to their NPC. Disregarding whether I play hockey or not, is it worth it to take on about $40,000 more in debt to attend tufts or would I be better off in the long run with less debt? My ECs aren’t the greatest so I’m not sure if I could get into tufts without hockey. My Alabama scholarship stays if I take a gap year so I could still fall back on that if hockey doesn’t work out.

Less debt is always better. $40,000 is a lot of extra debt for a bachelors degree, and there are no rational measurable benefits to justify the cost. I would take Alabama!