I had assumed myself to have been a high stat person deferred due to lack of demonstrated interest as well (1590 SAT, perfect GPA, top of class) I tried to demonstrate my interest by writing optional essay and having an interview, but I guess it didn’t come across.
Tulane has been my top choice since the fall, and it’s disheartening they would assume I wouldn’t want to attend. Hopefully by showing my continued interest it will come across that I really would love to attend. Thank you for your comments!