U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

Those two majors, in particular, tend to be confounding factors because so few LACs (or relatively few) have strengths in either of them. The practical effect of only being compared to a handful of peers should result in a nullity, no?

Id think that the Ivy league schools would have immense advantage because their graduates get hired at a much higher rate regardless of major (more elite firms, more networking, connections etc). So if you’re a philosophy major, you could get a consulting job but if you went to a different school, firms may not even interview philosophy majors.

Basically, nothing’s going to change in the National University rankings. They have far fewer anomalies to deal with than the National LACs.

That’s going to be up to US News to decide. But I see nothing about them limiting comparisons to otherwise similar institutions in their press release. So I think it is entirely possible that, say, Accounting majors at Richmond will be compared to Accounting majors at every college with Accounting majors–assuming Richmond has data for their Accounting majors.

As I touched on earlier, I think the biggest advantage for Ivy League schools is that they are more selective and tend to have a higher concentration of high academically achieving, gifted, motivated students.

For example, a typical non-selective directional state has lower average post-grad earnings than a typical Ivy League colleges, including when controlling for major. Does that difference in earnings between non-selective colleges and Ivy League colleges primarily occur because the latter can get consulting jobs? Or does the differences in earnings primarily occur because the colleges have a dramatically different composition of students?

The colleges that have the highest reported earnings in philosophy on CollegeScorecard are listed below. Note that at the overwhelming majority of colleges, sample size is too small to be valid. Earnings information is available at <10% of the 4-year colleges offering a philosophy major.

  1. Penn
  2. Cal Poly
  3. Boston College
  4. CUNY John Jay
  5. William & Mary
  6. Fordham
  7. UCSB
  8. UT Austin
  9. Chicago
  10. UNC: Chapel Hill
6 Likes

This seems like a potentially good bet to me, that this measure will benefit all the colleges where most of the HASS majors still go on to lucrative careers in law, medicine, business, and so on.

1 Like

Philosophy is probably not the ideal choice for discussing this issue because there are not many Philosophy jobs at all.

With something like English, though, it makes a big difference if those people are mostly going into, say, K-12 education, or instead something like law or business.

3 Likes

And some are in NYC. If placing in NYC, it’s different than placing in Raleigh or Richmond from a cost of living POV.

If this turns out to be a separate section where readers are invited to search for individual majors, fine. The mystery is how all of those preliminaries will play out on the Main Event?

So the general idea seems to be if all your majors, whatever mix that might be, end up top 10% earners for their respective majors, that would be good for your generic ranking. All bottom 10%, bad. And so on.

But the details are going to be important, and we don’t know those yet (and may never know in fact).

That makes way too much sense to possibly be how USNews implements this.

2 Likes

While school name can have an impact, I think the far more notable impact on earnings is the individual students. If you take a highly motivated, high achieving student who was accepted to Harvard and chooses to attend a public on a full ride scholarship to save money that gifted, high achieving student doesn’t have the same low average expected earnings as the typical student at the college. Similarly if you take a not-gifted, not high achieving typical student at a directional state and put them in Harvard, that student does not have the same average expected earnings as the typical Harvard grad. Differences in student body are a critical influence on why median earnings tend to differ between more selective and less selective colleges.

That said, median earnings of English majors at Ivy League colleges tend to be modest, with only a small portion going in to elite finance or consulting. For example, Yale’s post grad outcomes stats show the following for English majors:

  • Median Earnings – $55k
  • Most Common Job Function: Writing (15%), Teaching (14%), Law (10%), Consulting (6%), Finance (6%), Office Admin (6%)
  • Most Common Employer Industry: Education (24%), Publishing (13%), Law (10%), Tech (7%), Communications (7%), Finance (7%), Consulting (6%)

On CollegeScorecard, median 4-years out earnings for Yale English majors is listed as $62k, compared to a median of ~$50k for English majors across all 4-year colleges.

3 Likes

Another useful way of telling us that gym teachers in Oklahoma make less money than civil engineers in Boston.

1 Like

For those who would like to lnow more about the survey instructions, respondents are asked not to rate institutions for which they lack sufficient familiarity.

That’s why the “statistical transformation” details will matter. Will that be scored as a big difference or a small one?

Current overall ranking positions sometimes correlate poorly with earnings information. For example, Trinity (currently #37 overall) grads surpass Bowdoin (currently #5 overall) grads in earnings for both economics majors and political science & government majors four years out from graduation. Does this mean that Trinity will rise to, say, 34th? This is feasible, but remains to be seen.

In another post @dfbdfb noted us news rankings are toxic for the middle class. This is a good reason why.

But higher earnings also assumes people want money.

I don’t know @dfbdfb, of course, but I’m assuming he can make more in the private sector than as a linguistics prof (I may be wrong) but that he chose academia as a career, knowing what may be given up financially.

That’s a win but not when people like me or various surveys - payscale, wsj and more base results on pay.

But things are hard to qualify, so when you can quantify…..

There are other examples like this but people act as if us news, which created their own strategy metric wise, is the official source.

Someone can go to Trinity, save a boatload, and get a great outcome vs Bowdoin - but many think you can’t. Why ? Because of a ranking in which the criteria has nothing to do with the individual.

4 Likes

Does Trinity really save most of its students a significant amount compared to any other Northeast liberal arts college that enrolls a lot of upper middle class and wealthy students?

Are we talking about Trinity College in Hartford CT? Isn’t the COA there similar to that of Bowdoin, that is approaching 100K? I know Trinity has excellent income-based financial aid, but so does Bowdoin though I am pretty sure that only Trinity offers merit scholarships as well as financial aid. Still, I am not sure how many kids get merit scholarships.

2 Likes

I was thinking university in San Antonio but yes with merit, they may (CT). Tx def will. Whether that save or spend impacts someone is different. Someone may be equally as ok spending $40k or $90k.

The bigger point being though - people believe the #10 is always better than 20, 20 than 30 and it’s silly.

And as people point out to me, not everyone cares about the money. I believe the masses do tho.

I had one in school although now paying bills, that tune has changed a bit.

1 Like

The original comment about higher earnings among economic majors was for Trinity CT vs Bowdoin. College Scorecard reported median earnings for econ majors are $85 higher for Trinity than Bowdoin. For the 2026-27 year, net price is listed as $96,500 in direct costs at Trinity vs $95,400 in direct costs at Bowdoin. I expect the earlier comment about higher costs at Bowdoin related to comparing the default years listed on website, which is higher for Bowdoin because Trinity has not yet updated to 2026-27 on main website.

However, at all 3 of the discussed colleges (Bowdoin, Trinity CT, and Trinity TX), most students do not pay sticker price. At Trinity TX, 100% of students do not pay sticker price. With 0% of students paying sticker price (at Trinity TX), it seems irrelevant to compare sticker price. Among the 3 schools, Bowdoin is generally less expensive for typical income families. Bowdoin’s website list the following median net price by income. However, for highest income kids, Trinity TX would likely be least expensive, unless the student received a merit scholarship, then Trinity CT may be least expensive.

.

This touches on the futility of such ROI type comparisons. Who cares about an $85 difference in median income among federal aid recipients in a particular major? Desired career paths differences, individual student differences, cost of living differences, … all are far more influential. Why focus on a $1k difference in sticker price when most students do not pay sticker price? Focus instead on your cost, which is likely to differ.

We will have to wait to see how this influences USNWR ranking, but with the expected 5% weighting, my expectation is not much.

3 Likes