U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

Bottom line: USNews makes a bundle in increased eyeballs.

2 Likes

I think changes of eight positions or so will appear here and there from the changes being when combined with typical variability.

Any ROI sort of generic ranking is likely going to basically ignore the possibility of getting big merit awards. But of course many individual families should NOT ignore big merit possibilities.

A “better” summary review of LACs would thus at least contain some basic information about merit programs, say the sort of stuff you can just scrape from the CDS.

1 Like

With respect to earnings information, I like the four-years-out figures over, say, ten-years-out figures. Grads seeking to consolidate their hard work and choice of major will be happy to establish suitable employment within this length of time. Income information can help measure this. Further, since medians will be used, graduates specifically seeking highly renumerative positions will not unduly influence the data to the exclusion of those to whom renumeration represents a smaller aspect of their goals.

I am curious why you would say that Bucknell and/or Richmond would ascend?

If the rankings consider earnings by major…those schools will not longer get the boost in average overall earnings that they previously had by having a lot of business grads.

Don’t get me wrong. My daughter is at Richmond. I feel that the school is underrated and I sincerely hope that you are right. I just don’t understand the logic.

The article mentions that the new earnings by major metric replaces the existing borrower debt metric. There is no change in anything related to previously being boosted by having a lot of business grads.

On the new earnings by major metric, Bucknell and Richmond rank typical for somewhat selective LACs in Economics. For CS/tech majors, Bucknell ranks a bit ahead of comparable colleges and Richmond a bit below. I don’t care to check every available major, but there is a lot of variation, sometimes ahead of comparables and sometimes below. It’s unclear how this will be scored.

I estimate that Bucknell and Richmond have the following scores on the existing USNWR borrower debt metric that will be replaced. Bucknell stands to gain with the new metric because they do so poorly on the existing borrower debt metric that will be replaced, ranking among the lowest of all LACs. In contrast, Richmond seems to do fairly well on both metrics, so little potential for change.

  • Richmond – 81/100
  • Bucknell – 8/100 (low score relates to unique USNWR methodology that does not consider portion of students taking out loans, when calculating “borrower debt”)
2 Likes

Very Interesting. I did not consider the metric being deleted.

Still…I am not a fan of any earnings metrics that don’t consider the market the earnings are coming from. $80K in NYC is pretty bad for an econ major while $80K is Charlotte is outstanding.

I might be wrong. I was thinking those majors might get them a boost as they do well in all the other rankings.

Of course should they be compared against Williams ? No

Yeah, the lack of geographic market controls is a big problem analytically. Cynically, though, it might help the marketing team in that there will be a Goldilocks amount of shifting in rankings, not too little to fail to make some news, but also not too much such as to undermine branding.

Edit, I can see some of the 2027 ranking now, and I don’t have the paid version.

1 MIT
2 Princeton
3 Harvard
4 Yale
5 Caltech, Stanford
7 UPenn
8 Duke
9 Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, UChicago
12 Dartmouth, Columbia
14 Cornell, CMU
16 Brown, Rice, Vandy, WashU
20 UC Berkeley, UCLA, Notre Dame
23 Emory, Georgetown
25 Michigan
26 UVA
27 UNC, USC
29 Georgia Tech, UCSD
31 Boston College, NYU, Tufts
34 Boston University, UC Davis, UC Irvine, UF, UIUC, UT Austin, U Wisconsin, Wake Forest
42 Northeastern, Villanova
44 Case Western, Lehigh, Ohio State, Rutgers, UCSB
49 UMD, U Rochester, U Washington
52 UGA, Virginia Tech, William & Mary
55 Penn State, Purdue, Santa Clara, U Miami
59 Brandeis, Florida State, GWU, Stevens, Stony Brook, Texas A&M, Tulane, UMass, UMN, Pitt
69 Michigan State, RPI, UC Merced
72 Syracuse
73 SUNY Binghamton, Howard, Indiana, NC State, Rutgers Newark, UConn, WPI
80 Clemson, CO Mines, Drexel, Pepperdine, UC Riverside
85 Fordham, NJIT, SMU, SUNY Buffalo, UDel
90 Baylor, Gonzaga, Marquette, TCU, Yeshiva
95 American, RIT, Rutgers Camden, UIC, Missouri
100 Auburn, Chapman, Creighton, Elon, FIU, Saint Louis U, Iowa, U San Diego
109 Fairfield, LMU, Temple, UC Santa Cruz, CU Boulder, UNH, Tennessee

3 Likes

Looks like UF fell some and at first glance maybe some other publics like UGA. Wake seems higher too but need to check last year’s rank. Was 51.

Seems Emory and Wash U have recovered their debacle of a few years ago. Nova too.

UC Santa Cruz took a fall but people will still choose it over the despised but much higher ranked Merced and Riverside.

east-coast engineering schools seem to have done VERY well

Stevens went up 21 (!!!) , WPI 11, Carnegie Mellon 6 (which is a LOT when already that high up). And, of course MIT went up…

(I just looked at my 27s list, and only one that went down was UMD)…

2 Likes

BU rose 8 places. Northeastern rose 4 places.

1 Like

Villanova rose 15 paces

4 Likes

one of highest I have seen called out besides Stevens which I imagines wins on salaries due to location)

4 Likes

As recently as 4-5 years ago LMU and SCU used to be similarly ranked in the 60s. LMU has fallen a lot to 109 and SCU has risen to 55.

4 Likes

The new earnings by major metric is weighted at 5%. It sounds like their default methodology for national universities is to compare the majors for which earnings majors are available. For each available major, USNWR reviews how that school’s earnings compares to the median for all ranked colleges in that major assigns a corresponding score. They use a weighted average to determine ranking on this criteria.

For colleges with fewer earnings information available, the procedure is described below. Options include using overall median earnings across all majors rather than earnings by major, or substituting graduation rate.

In other categories, schools failing to meet this threshold – primarily smaller institutions awarding degrees in few majors – were assessed on overall median institutional earnings compared to peer averages. If institutional earnings were unavailable, the factor’s weight was reallocated to the metric measuring college graduates earning more than a typical high school graduate. As a last resort, for institutions without College Scorecard earnings data, such as those not participating in federal financial aid, the weight was reallocated to average graduation rates.

Among higher ranked colleges on national ranking, CMU had the largest advancement, reaching #14 when they had been consistently ranked #20+ in previous years. This is CMU’s highest ranking since the original list in 1984. I expect the new metric contributed.

Among higher ranked LACs, Smith had one of the largest changes. Smith dropped to #22 when they had been previous ranked ~#15. This is Smith’s lowest ranking ever. Again I expect the new metric contributed.

3 Likes

And yet Villanova, UMD and more - are the same schools they were yesterday. And Wake Rose and Florida fell, etc. - that’s why it’s all silly.

Stevens will never be seen as a national U and short of knowing they have a basketball team, few would know where Villanova is.

Nothing changes but people are jumping up and down over it.

What’ll be interesting - those who are going to apply to all the top 20. I didn’t look but who moved into it and who dropped out? Maybe they have to change a few.

2 Likes

Seems that this could skew the points a small college gets significantly depending on its major mix, unless they make it relative to the expected level of post-graduation earnings for its major mix.

Nova is well regarded in the northeast and mid atlantic.

4 Likes