agree, and honestly, when I look at some schools on my kids list and I see grad almost entirely stay near the university (not somewhere I see my kid living long term for a variety of reasons) I have second thoughts…(e.g., Case-Western) BU or Santa Clara or GW would be a win there for our family.
Yes, I agree with your comment that most people don’t know where most colleges are, or have even heard of them. It’s not really an area of focus for most people, after all, unless they have a junior or senior in high school. IMO that is one of the reasons the US News rankings are useful.
People love to criticize the US News Rankings because they are supposedly a big money-maker for US News. I would assume that’s true because otherwise they wouldn’t put so much into them. I’ve also heard (and believe) that they are big money-makers for some schools…donations increase when their rank increases.
I still think they serve a meaningful purpose, even if there is nothing perfect about their ranking. There are thousands of colleges, most of us have never heard of most of them. And yet at some point we need to guide our kids to find the right one for them. It’s for this very reason that having some sort of sense of how “good” a college is can be helpful. The rankings aren’t really precise but they do give a sense of some things..in particular a sense of graduation rates and peer reputation. If you’ve never heard of [college name] but it’s ranked highly, it may well be worth researching to see if it’s a good fit.
The most influential factors in the ranking methodology are peer assessments and 6-year graduation rates. Those both seem pretty important to me and I’m glad they are weighted heavily. There’s lots of other factors too and they tweak them all the time. But at bird’s eye level, the changes in rankings are pretty small. When a school moves up or down 15-20 places on the list it feels like a “big” change, but hontestly that’s pretty small movement compared to the 427 national universities being ranked.
Villanova…was ranked as a (top) regional university for decades until the University made an intentional effort to increase their focus on faculty research. Ever since then they have been ranked anywhere from #42-#67 nationally, and typically have been in the mid-50’s. The methodology has changed a lot of times over the last decade but the movement has been pretty small honestly (even though it feels “big” sometimes). Which one is correct? Is it #42? Is it #67? It doesn’t really matter. But what the rankings are really useful for is to alert people who might not otherwise have heard of it that it might be worth a look.
I have a kid there now. We are Catholic and that was a bonus for us (or for me, anyway) but not the major driver to go there. But it’s relatively high ranking (#51 when I first started reasearching) put it on my list to research further. So glad I did, it’s been a great fit. My kid also applied to other “lower-ranked” and some “higher-ranked” schools. But Villanova was her #1 choice because the research we did on it, which was partly driven by the awareness we acquired through US News rankings, made her realize it was the place for her.
That a school like Wake Forest with a 22% acceptance is even close to a schools like NYU, BC and Tufts with 9-12% acceptance is silly at best. Worse yet is that schools like UC Davis, UC Santa Barbara, UC Irvine, UC San Diego, UC Merced,… are included in the top 50. These are schools with no testing requirements, with acceptance rates of 30-50% and with documented cases of a large portion of their incoming class not being able to do middle school math.
If acceptance rate is the main driver of what makes a college “good” to you, you are in luck! USNews also publishes a list of colleges with the lowest acceptance rates. Enjoy!
https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/lowest-acceptance-rate
Who said acceptance rate “is the main driver of what makes a college good”?!?!
Let’s not start manipulating comments. We have enough of that going on already, unfortunately.
Not manipulating at all! Just a lighthearted joke…I hope you take it as such. This whole thing is about rankings and I think any method of ranking is inherently a little “silly” (agree with you there!) but I still find them useful for the reasons I spelled out in my post. Just trying to start the day with a smile…and actually to share the ranking by acceptance rate, which I also find very interesting. ![]()
Not likely exclusive to them (lack of math) - but yeah.
I think any ranking, if it helps give someone an indicator to put someone on a list - it’s fine.
Other rankings use different metrics and that’s fine too.
US News helped @Bruno99 identify schools, and the one they found has worked out well, so it’s great. Should Villanova be in a different category that College of Charleston, Providence or Loyola MD - no…IMHO. They should be compared head to head.
The entire regional / national thing is silly in my opinion.
If you want to segment, I’d do by size - but many consider schools across various lists. Research institution or not impacts so few of the overall student population.
Bottom line , US News has done a good job of making themselves the default list for many, whether or not there’s substance behind it.
That’s why there’s always so much discussion - until the next ranking hits, of course.
Reasearch institutions typically receive significantly more grant $$$, which in turn attracts more researchers, and more resources…whiich can enhance student undergraduate experience and post-grad opportunities.
I’ve never been to CofC nor know much about it but I am familiar with Providence (my kid also applied there and I used to live there) and IMO the overal level of resources and opportunities available to students at Providence and Villanova are vastly different. Both are great schools, and they are two fo the few non-Jesuit Catholic schools with substantial core curricula, and they both have great bball teams. But PC feels WAY smaller, and has way fewer academic/class offerings than Villanova. PC has about 5,000 total students and Villanova has over 10,000 (including graduate), which may drive the difference in feel. But for sure the level of resources to students available at Villanova feels a lot more than at PC.
ETA - the endowment at Villanova ($1.5B), while low compared to many big name national universities, is 5 times higher than the endowment at PC ($300M)…I’m sure that also dramatically affects the level of resources available to students. Villanova also has graduate schools of business, law and nursing, and they offer abet-accredited engineering. Also reasons it may feel much more resource heavy than PC
I think this is a very fair analysis.
I’ve recommended Providence to a lot of kids I know IRL. It certainly punches above its weight for kids who are interested in government, public affairs, etc. (regardless of what they major in- a nice feature of a Catholic U, you aren’t tied down to “you must study X to do Y”). Its proximity to the state house, lobbyists, etc. in a small state makes for VERY attractive internship and part time job opportunities. This is just one domain area where P has terrific resources. Providence is a cool theater town as well.
But overall, Villanova just has “more stuff”. You’ve got a kid who just wants their ticket punched and doesn’t care about research opportunities, faculty mentors, etc.? Doesn’t matter. But for a more “academic” minded kid, I agree with Bruno that V is in a different category than P.
I agree the segments are really odd at this point…
https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/regional-colleges-north
Are some VERY niche schools for example, not really regional at all at the top of list.
Boston University published this story first thing this morning, trumpeting their 8-place rise in the USNews rankings.
Meanwhile, Northeastern makes no mention in their campus media of their 4-place rise.
Who is playing the rankings game now?
All of them!
In the 2 of the previous 3 years Caltech was ranked 6th and 7th, bringing perspective to the increase to 5th. That said, Caltech did benefit from the new earnings by major metric. The 2 highest ranked colleges in the US on this metric are MIT and Caltech.
In my earlier post I mentioned that USNWR may use alternative measures when few earnings are available, such as comparing median earnings across all majors rather than comparing earnings in specific majors. It’s unclear if they did this for Caltech, which as you note only has earnings listed for one major (Computer Science).
But even acceptance rates have to be looked at very carefully.
Some schools attract lots of international applicants (through financial aid policies, brand, outreach, etc..) and then reject 99% of them.
A school could have an US out-of-state (OOS) acceptance rate of 25% and an overall acceptance rate of 12%.
When D26 and I looked at schools…we always looked at OOS rates to gauge the school’s actual selectivity.
I always like to point out that Carleton College has a 36% OOS acceptance rate, which blew my mind.
My undergrad tiers are unchanged. They can monkey with their formulas all they want to, but mine endures. hehe. My ranking is based mainly on my perception of overall academic quality and resources (yes, I feel silly doing this. But this is the place to deposit it…)
Private:
T1: Harvard, MIT, Princeton, Stanford, Yale
T2: Caltech, UChicago, Columbia, UPenn (CCCP!)
T3: Brown, Cornell, Dartmouth, Duke, Hopkins, Northwestern
T4: CMU, Emory, Georgetown, Notre Dame, Rice, Vanderbilt, Washington U
T5: BC, BU, NYU, USC, Tufts, Wake
T6: Brandeis, Case, Lehigh, Northeastern, Rochester, Villanova, Tulane
(some of these could be combined… but that’s the fun of tiers – you have to almost arbitrarily decide where to draw the lines…)
Public (much simpler, IMO) –
T1: Berkeley, Michigan, Virginia
T2: UCLA, UCSD, Georgia Tech, Illinois, UNC, Texas, Washington, William & Mary, Wisconsin
T3: A bunch more – UCD, UCI, UCSB, Florida, Indiana, Maryland, UMass, Minnesota, OSU, PSU, Purdue, Pitt, Rutgers…
LACs:
T1: Amherst, Pomona, Swat, Williams
T2: Barnard, Bowdoin, Carleton, CMC, Hamilton, Haverford, Midd, Smith, Vassar, Wellesley, Wes
T3: Bates, Bryn Mawr, Colby, Colgate, Davidson, Grinnell, HMC, Mac, Oberlin, Reed, Richmond, W&L
T4: Bucknell, Colorado College, Connecticut College, Holy Cross, Lafayette, MHC, Scripps, Trinity (CT)…
IMO, Haverford, Oberlin, Reed, and Smith are underrated…
Absolutely.
UVA has a very different acceptance rate for students applying out of state vs the 68% of students being admitted from Virginia.
Well, so much for controls in the new earnings approach. If you told me they were just using uncontrolled average institutional earnings such that it favored disproportionate engineering and business placement, as enhanced by disproportionate placement in higher compensation locations, I’d believe you based on what happened.
As always, though, I don’t believe there is a “right” generic ranking such that any generic ranking could be “wrong” in comparison. And in cases like Villanova, Villanova does seem quite good at placing kids in a variety of higher-compensation career paths.
Well Im glad that settles it then.
I strive to provide clarity! hehe
I dunno. I think your tiers imply a false precision. I’d keep all your T1-T3 together, I’d keep your tiers 4-5 together as tier 2. And I think your tier 6 (which is my tier 3, is broader than just those.