U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

And that’s fine - but if you are only looking at one type of school, in theory you wouldn’t have ever compared them.

C of C is 10K, regional public and it’s on the regional university South list.

In the end, a ranking will reflect however its set up and the metrics that are used.

I’d like head to head. You gave a great comparison of two schools and you were looking for Jesuit or Catholic schools it seems. But perhaps another wouldn’t have found PC or Dayton or whoever it cross shops with - because of how they segment.

Other rankings seem to have one list…which I like…but it’s working for US News as they are the de facto leader (I believe).

Yep – I fretted over the borders.

1 Like

Admission rates do not tell the full story, since a college with a low admission rate from less competitive applicants may be less selective than one with a high admission rate from more competitive applicants.

I’d exchange UCLA for UVA.

1 Like

I took “age of rep” into account here. I had a hard time choosing UCLA’s tier. UVA has been great for a long time, while UCLA’s rise is fairly recent. They have strong program rankings but I suspect some of their recent surge in rep is due to their selectivity – since so many kids want to attend. I don’t consider selectivity in my loose methodology.

UVA meets need for all. UCLA doesn’t. In the end, both have regional audiences with UVA more OOS.

Most likely are not comparing the two. Some hunting for rating - but most - no. If they don’t get into UCLA but get into another UC, they’re likely to go there b4 UVA.

Just like someone from your state is more likely to choose UW over a UC or UVA - and I’m sure there are many that get into UW and one of the other two.

So again, it’s all silly. Fun…but silly.

2 Likes

UVa rep is based mostly on the undergrad reputation. Even they admit that their grad school and sciences are not as strong as other schools specifically UNC. A plan to spend big to remedy that fizzled as the top people they did recruit left after a few years. UVa can meet need because they skew heavily to attracting the wealthy.

1 Like

I was looking for a Catholic school? Nope. We were looking for a school that would support my child’s somewhat niche EC…and it had to appease my and my husband’s desire for her to go to a school that is “Good” enough since we dont think she should go to a school just for her EC interest.

FWIW my initial list to research started with schools who do well Nationally in her EC , but not so well that she couldn’t compete. And then it had to be a “good” school. There were 3 Catholic schools on her list, most were not.

2 Likes

Right – and these are my undergrad tiers. My grad tiers would look a bit different. (for one thing, I would combine private and public schools…)

exactly my point

All these college rankings, including USNWR’s, are just for fun. It’s like the AP Poll Ranking of top college football programs that come out after each autumn weekend.

No one truly thinks this ranking is deterministic for life, but it does give a sense to uninitiated parents and kids which schools are regarded more highly than others. Like Notre Dame is more highly regarded in college football than Northwestern. And that info is valuable to the uninitiated.

But small differences (like #4 vs. #5, or #18 vs. #21) don’t really matter. I assume most adults know that.

5 Likes

The colleges that had the largest changes are below. I am comparing new rank to a weighted average of the most recent few years, applying highest weight to most recent year and lower weight to less recent years. I only considered colleges ranked among top 50 on national list. They are ordered based on a combination of both ratio and number of place changes. For example, increasing 5 places is more impactful for 10 → 5 than 50 → 45.

The largest decreases show a clear pattern. All are publics. I expect publics tend to rank worse on the new earnings by major metric for a variety of reasons – tend to be less selective for a given ranking including more CC transfers, more likely to favor jobs within state, less likely to pursue finance/consulting, etc. Also note that most are what I’d consider minor decreases, as 5% weighting on this new metric limits the potential impact. For example, UCB / UCLA decreasing from 17 to 20 might be considered negligible, but this relatively minor decrease is part of a larger trend across many publics.

The largest increases show a more varied pattern. Tech colleges usually do well. As I noted earlier, MIT and Caltech are the 2 highest ranked colleges overall in the new “earnings by major metric”. CMU also excels and is among the highest ranked colleges by this metric. Some of the others show less clear patterns, such as Wake Forest. I expect they are pulled up by their highest weighted (largest) major in the College Scorecard sample – finance. It’s listed as having an extremely high earnings of $146k – higher than Yale economics, but Wake Forest is being compared to colleges that offer finance majors instead of economics, which are often less selective than Ivy+ type colleges.

Largest Increases (historical → current)
1 . CMU: 21.8 → 14
2. Villanova: 57.7 → 42
3. Wake Forest: 44.5 → 34
4. Caltech: 8.5 → 5
5. Boston U: 41.8 → 34
*. MIT: 2.0 → 1

Largest Decreases (historical → current)
1 . Purdue: 46.4 → 55
2. UCSB: 36.7 → 44
3. Florida: 29.4 → 34
4. Michigan: 21.3 → 25
5. UCB / UCLA: 16.7 → 20
*. Princeton: 1.0 → 2

1 Like

Keeping it real with you. Your perceptions are a bit off.

1 Like

UVA has been great a long time at exactly what?

2 Likes

Drop down UVA and put Georgia Tech and UCLA in its place. Then you’re good. If a school is that weak at STEM/Engineering/Tech then it does not need to be in Tier 1. To me that’s a non-starter in my tiers. It’s too valuable and popular as a field.

Purely for undergrad? Probably selectivity.

1 Like

Undergraduate education in the humanities, social sciences, and business…

Reputations take a long time to build and solidify.

1 Like

It’s 2027 you don’t need to look far to see the fields and subjects that will be shaping the world in years to come. Engineering, Tech, STEM are programs that are extremely hard programs to build up and build a reputation in. Takes years. It’s 2027. It’s all good though, you are entitled to your opinion. My tiers would look different. Need to be very strong in these fields.

According to Poets and Quants, UVA has the 2nd best undergraduate business program in the country and UCLA doesnt offer an undergraduate business program.

Business is probably the most popular college major.

1 Like

I understand that and it is a popular major. But even business focus is seeing changes. There is becoming more an expectation of companies wanting engineers and tech grads in these management high level roles as most business is heading in that direction. Schools that are good at tech usually are very good at Quant analytics Finance, Industrial Engineering, Supply Chain, Information systems etc as well. Most business degrees coming out of these schools is still very focused on engineering and tech. I like UVA and think it’s a great school. Just wouldn’t put it in Tier 1 in my opinion for these reasons.