U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

ROI has no place in my rankings because kids choose their majors (generally…) and the professions that follow, and due to misleading salary variance based on differences in COL.

I like the (relative to most other flagships) intellectual vibe of UVA. Their strength in related areas, to me, overcomes the lack of big-name Engineering.

3 Likes

I note in my circles, Villanova, Wake Forest, and BU all would count as relatively strong preprofessional choices.

4 Likes

you are forgetting that at many colleges, business degrees become the default for kids who can’t cut it in engineering or tech. Kid is managing a C average in CS? His or her advisor is going to suggest a sitdown and explain the virtues of a business degree. Kid has three W’s in engineering and still has an incomplete from freshman year? Down the block to the business program she goes.

Not every kid majoring in business can hack anything even close to quant finance or something analytically heavy. Their course selection is heavy on content (some outdated) and not analysis. When the toughest stats course they took was “market research tools” and not a rigorous stats sequence- that’s a “tell”. And not every econ major is qualified to work in an analytically rigorous role either. Let’s not kid ourselves…

5 Likes

I wouldn’t trust another businessman for president if my life depended on it.

5 Likes

Those three schools are often safety schools for the top quartile kids.

4 Likes

BU: ~12% admit rate

Wake: ~18%

Villanova: ~29%

These are not safeties unless the applicant is an athlete or is otherwise supremely hooked.

7 Likes

Yep. “50% of students who start college intending to major in engineering ultimately finish an engineering degree. The rest switch to other majors (like business or general sciences) or leave school due to the heavy course load and weed-out classes.” Read "Understanding the Educational and Career Pathways of Engineers" at NAP.edu

That’s why top Engineering focused schools that excel at this and focus in this area get my vote.

Wake is 19-20%. Regardless, the average of those three schools is around 20%. That is significantly higher - double - compared to the 10% average of schools like Tufts, BC and NYU.

And it is at these levels that it makes a marked difference, not between 52% and 62%.

Not saying they are bad schools but there is a significant difference - certainly %wise - when it comes to selectivity.

The most selective (or most selective for engineering) colleges have higher retention and completion rates in engineering majors because the students have effectively been pre-screened for high academic strength that is necessary to complete an engineering major.

An engineering major cohort of frosh with 4.0 HS GPA in hard courses (particularly math and science) should be expected to have a higher completion rate than an cohort of frosh with 3.0 HS GPA in regular courses.

2 Likes

We may define “safety” differently. These are my selectivity definitions:

High reach: <5% chance

Reach: 5-15%

Low reach: 15-25%

High match: 25-40%

Match: 40-60%

Low Match: 60-90%

Safety: 90+%

To me, no school with an admit rate under about 50% can reliably be called a “safety”, barring auto-admit situations or major hooks. The certainty level of chancing is muddy at best, and it’s made even more difficult with the rising phenomenon of yield protection.

5 Likes

Top quartile of college bound students?

I believe that would be consistent with something like a 1200 SAT. I believe the lowest reported 25th SAT among those three is Wake at 1410, which is something like 94th percentile among college bound students.

4 Likes

It sounds more sadistic when you put it in terms of rejectivity; like, the college with a 20% admit rate is actually rejecting 80% of the people who apply to it. Better?

3 Likes

I largely agree with all your definitions, with a slight difference in opinion on your overall assessment…

I think your “no school with an admit rate under 50% is a safety” is a bit overly cautious. I’d put it more at about 40 percent. Meaning…if someone has grades, rank, test scores above the 75th percentile at a school that has a 40 percent admit rate, I’d call it a safety. AND I’d say that can be adjusted to be specific to a particular applicant’s school if they know longitudinal admission data from their school.

One of my kids went to a Catholic school that punches above its weight for kids applying to Notre Dame, meaning about 20% of our applicants get in…maybe not surprising from a Catholic School. But our admit rates to BC and Georgetown are well below their 11-12 percent admit rates…more like 2-3% from our school. In contrast, our admit rate to UT Austin is closer to 40 percent and A&M is 80 percent…and these are averages over 5 years. So, I like your break down and would just adjust it with (High) school specific experience whenever that is known.

1 Like

Oh, it really depends on the student. You can not do a one size fits all like you did there. There are so many variables. A student with great grades and a rigorous course load, great essays, great individual projects, 1550+ SAT score,… is going to be looking at schools with 20-25% as a safety more so than a reach, while a student with a 3.2 GPA and a 1300 SAT and decent extra curriculars will see a college with a 20-25% acceptance rate much more as a reach than a safety.

Among the top quartile students I know (and I don’t claim to know hundreds or even dozens) they all have that mentality. For them, a school like Wake Forest or Villanova is a safety schools.

Whether they ended up getting in or not is another story :rofl:

1 Like

Good financial stewardship for one.

1 Like

A particular student’s admit rate is often completely different than the overall admit rate of the college, so it makes little sense to classify whether a college is a safety/reach/match for a particular student based on the overall admit rate of the college.

For example, UT Austin had a 22% admit rate last year, but it would be considered a safety for an in-state resident with a top class rank. MIT had an admit rate of ~4% last year, yet many consider admission near a sure thing for applicants with achievements in IMO or similar. There are countless other variables that may influence chance of admission for a particular student – choice of major, test scores including whether submitted or not, residence, transcript including rigor, early decision, awards/ECs, LORs, etc. Some students applying to a particular college with 30% admit rate may have an extremely high chance of admission while other students applying to the same college may have near 0% chance of admission.

I’m not sure what this has to with the recent USNWR rankings. USNWR specifies the formula weights and criteria they use to calculate ranking. This criteria does not include the admit rate of the college.

Ahem. UVA’s law school has been top tier like forever US News currently ranks it 5th which is equivalent to Hahvahd

1 Like

I think the other thing rankings miss are cost.

A student may get into Colgate, Tufts, Nova - but may not be willing to pay or want to pay.

They might end up for half the price at Providence/Fordham, Allegheny or Trinity/Connecticut College or Brandeis.

Or someone who goes to Bama for $25K a year or WVU a little higher instead of UVA or UCLA or UMich at more than $3x the cost.

Was that delta worth it?

Not to argue that here but none of that is accounted for in rank.

A one size fits all could never work.

Some people are forced to go to lower cost schools. Some people go by choice.

It takes a lot of money (before tax) to save $200 or $300K after tax to spend additionally (on college).

For many top colleges, it’s also the privilege of a few, not just because of achievement but because of financial inequity. Yes, some get significant aid - but some don’t and either it’s too much a stretch or like me - mom/dad simply weren’t willing to pay.

In my case, my son got, I believe a similar level job that he would have from more expensive schools.

My daughter is in a program that Ivy kids join too.

Earlier, on another thread, a parent noted their child was a free ride at Tulsa. Presumably they had other great choices at many places.

No rankings can incorporate any of this.

There’s so many, at so many schools, that excel. That’s all that really matters - for those who achieved what they desired out of their school.

Prediction Results

The spread turned out to be 10 places, from 12th to 22nd. The prediction came very close in both range and limits to the actual results.

The predictions for the individual schools were not accurate overall:

Actual Order

:black_small_square:︎1. Vassar (prediction off by 4)

:black_small_square:︎2. Hamilton (prediction off by 1 or 2)

:black_small_square:︎2. Wesleyan (prediction off by 3 or 4)

:black_small_square:︎4. Davidson (prediction not off or off by 1)

:black_small_square:︎4. Grinnell (prediction off by 3 or 4)

:black_small_square:︎6. Barnard (prediction off by 3 or 4)

:black_small_square:︎6. Middlebury (prediction off by 4 or 5)

:black_small_square:︎8. Smith (prediction off by 1)

2 Likes

Engineering jobs top out very quickly and CS is dying fast. And you don’t get into a good B school with Ws or poor grades. It is very competitive. Maybe at a crap school like Radford but not at UVa or top 25 B school.

1 Like