I think the other thing rankings miss are cost.
A student may get into Colgate, Tufts, Nova - but may not be willing to pay or want to pay.
They might end up for half the price at Providence/Fordham, Allegheny or Trinity/Connecticut College or Brandeis.
Or someone who goes to Bama for $25K a year or WVU a little higher instead of UVA or UCLA or UMich at more than $3x the cost.
Was that delta worth it?
Not to argue that here but none of that is accounted for in rank.
A one size fits all could never work.
Some people are forced to go to lower cost schools. Some people go by choice.
It takes a lot of money (before tax) to save $200 or $300K after tax to spend additionally (on college).
For many top colleges, it’s also the privilege of a few, not just because of achievement but because of financial inequity. Yes, some get significant aid - but some don’t and either it’s too much a stretch or like me - mom/dad simply weren’t willing to pay.
In my case, my son got, I believe a similar level job that he would have from more expensive schools.
My daughter is in a program that Ivy kids join too.
Earlier, on another thread, a parent noted their child was a free ride at Tulsa. Presumably they had other great choices at many places.
No rankings can incorporate any of this.
There’s so many, at so many schools, that excel. That’s all that really matters - for those who achieved what they desired out of their school.