Ehhhh - some top b schools have become easier with work experience and some even waive the GMAT. A student I know is admitted to Harvard (from a non elite SEC school) as part of the early admission program. I think he still took the GMAT, but now schools (UVA is another) are now taking kids without the benefit of actually seeing the work experience and holding a spot for them.
Keenan Flagler, Ga Tech and more are putting the hard push on several colleagues at a few companies, more than schools like Wash U put ED in undergrad.
MBAs are cash cows - the world is now changed. They are reaching hard to get kids or rather adults that can pay - in.
They have merit aid. Maybe it won’t be half but there’s a good chance it could be less. At some of the 2nd and 3rd tier LACs, it will be half or less.
Both also award need aid to a much higher percentage although that’s based on who applies.
So less - very possible and even likely. Swap in the other Trinity - and they have even higher merit aid.
The point isn’t picking on these schools per se. The point is many kids choose schools that may be tiered lower but because the price is better - forgetting the names. So an overall rank is a nice thing, but how can you rank when everyone’s situation is different? Even the full pay is different. One family might pay in full and then be strained (their choice, of course). For others, it won’t dent their lives one bit.
Don’t get me wrong - I like rankings - these give something to talk about.
I think you’re missing the larger point. You don’t need a new metric to see what’s going on here. Wealthy colleges can afford more need-based aid and it’s relatively easy to figure out which ones they are by running a NPC. You can’t do that with merit aid. People are always going to go for the low hanging fruit first. If there’s not enough, they’ll do the next best thing and then the next best thing after that in order to make it all work financially. But the fact that wealthy private colleges tend to congregate toward the top is no accident.
Wealth is always going to have a multipler effect.
Most engineers are not doing real engineering further in their careers and many won’t even be engineers at the beginning of their careers . They eventually become high positioned executives. These are just really smart people. If you do not have an engineering tech background and you want to work for any top company these days heading into 2027 you will be limited. Even better, if you want, get your undergraduate engineering degree then go get an MBA.
Also doubtful PC would be cheaper than Nova. Both are notoriously stingy with merit aid. About 7 percent of Nova freshmen get merit aid. It tends to be either a full-ride for 25 students, or about $20K for the rest. About 9 percent of PC frehmen get merit aid and they told me the max they give is $30K per year (this was two years ago).
Evidence? Even McKinsey- the alleged star of the technocratic world- published an essay on why they are increasing their hiring of humanities and liberal arts majors.
McKinsey is actively expanding its recruitment of engineering and technical majors to meet a growing demand for digital, AI, and operations consulting.
The point I was making is not everyone can afford (or wants to afford) the high price school they get into.
Some purposely go where they can spend less.
That can’t be accounted for in a ranking.
All I was saying. I’m not saying the high ranked schools aren’t great schools.
My TFA kid was going to be $44K a year but we got lucky after she enrolled - and it was just $16-18K a year with endowed scholarships.
W&L was double the initial price (after merit).
Would that extra $180K a year have been worth it? So far, no. Long term - who knows.
Same with my son - spent $16-17K a year or so on average. Could have gone to Purdue with merit for $ under $40K (had $10K merit) - but would the $80K delta be worth it long run. No one knows the future - but making $115K or so 3 years out, I’m guessing not. But no one knows the long term.
I put forth a set based on what was being discussed - but it can be Nova vs. Temple or UVA vs. U Wyoming.
I was simply noting - everyone’s situation is different. Rankings are generic but real life isn’t one size fits all.
There are many tools to view career path by major. A simple one is at Where do college graduates work? . While there is variation by field of engineering and other factors, by far the most common career path for engineering majors was to work as engineers. A significant minority also worked in CS or as managers. People on this forum often talk about elite finance/consulting, but extremely few engineers work in McKinsey type consulting. The whole “business and financial” category was quite small in link above.
This fits with my personal experience as an EE major from Stanford. The vast majority of engineering majors I am familiar with still work in engineering, although increasing management responsibilities with more experience is common. Some I’d consider primarily managers with engineering expertise, rather than primarily engineers with some management responsibilities. There are also a significant minority who have done all kinds of non-engineering things. I know one who switched to a career as a musical performer. I know multiple who have gone in to real estate rentals or buying/selling (I live in VHCOL area). I know multiple have retired or semi-retired at a relatively young age, often focusing on travel instead of working.
For the purposes of USNWR’s new ranking, the earnings are measured at 4 years out, so only career distribution at 4 years out is important. If a particular college has engineering majors who tend to go in higher/lower earning careers than typical at 4 years out, that may impact their relative ranking. This could also apply to things like new grads being more likely to focus on jobs in Silicon Valley area rather than jobs within home state. The former is common at many Ivy+ type colleges. That latter is common at many publics.
3 of my BFs from HS did engineering degrees at Penn/CMU/Northwestern. None are engineers in disciplines they studied (one is a CS academic, one is in finance, one is in consulting (not even tech-related)). Maybe something in water at Stanford.
I am shocked more Stanford EE alums aren’t entrepreneurs in pure tech/software honestly, though may depend on exact job market/year you graduated? I knew an EE in the PhD there, who dropped out to work as a consultant at a big firm..way more $$ and everyday new challenge, they say. They have been there 25 years now, never looked back.
I do 100% agree there is something different at certain top programs though, where more graduates go into banking and consulting from engineering… the VAST majority of engineering degrees/programs students at least start as engineers. I do think a lot end up as managers though, and then they need engineering knowledge, but their day-to-day is management, in reality.
I also know how to google…This from Bob Sternfels interview with HBR…
"In his interview with HBR, Sternfels said AI models have developed an expertise in problem-solving, and that the company would be “looking more at liberal arts majors, whom we had deprioritized,” for potential sources of creativity as the firm moves to find creative solutions beyond “logical next steps.” It’s not just McKinsey, other leaders are looking to hire liberal arts graduates like CEO of IT firm Cognizant Technology Solutions Ravi Kumar S, who says he’s recruiting candidates with liberal arts degrees. "
While Stanford has a reputation for entrepreneurship and creating companies, that only represents a small minority of grads. A far more common path for Stanford engineers or tech majors in general is to work for a large and often well known company, as an engineer (software engineer for CS). Over time responsibilities and companies may change, but I expect most still fall in the engineering umbrella.
I expect a similar statement could be made about engineering majors at other Ivy+ colleges. Stats for many years after graduating are limited, but there is plenty of information available about recent grads, which is also more relevant to the thread topic. I’ll use Cornell as an example, as their stats are particularly detailed.
Among ME majors, by far the most common industries were tech and manufacturing. The most common employers were SpaceX, ASML, Lockheed Martin, and Apple.
Among EE majors, by far the most common industry was tech, followed by manufacturing. The most common employers were Apple, Lockheed Martin, Microsoft, and Google.
Among CivE majors, the most common industry was architecture, followed by consulting/professional practice. The most common employers were Clark Construction, WSP USA, Kimley Horn, and McLaren Engineering.
Among ChemE majors, by far the most common industry was manufacturing, followed by consulting/professional practice. The most common employers were Merck, Proctor & Gamble, Air Products & Chem Inc, and Intel.
My partner was a CS major as they moved up the chain from “engineer”, they would say their job was no longer engineering/software… and that they entire changed careers, their day was ENTIRELY different. They were an manager/executive/business. YES they had to have software knowledge, of course That was my bigger point. (and yes they went to an Ivy+ ) Anyway, their friends who were pure engineering majors are all in software or law or consulting actually. My experience may be very different, obviously.
I also worked at a software compay, 2 of our execs was an MIT ees. they never worked as an engineers either … I guess I just know lots of engineers that went it software.
Yeah, not to put too fine point on it, but since we are discussing this very specific poll, one of my biggest takeaways is that despite a 5% re-jiggling of metrics to emphasize ROI, the top most academicky LACs maintained their relative positions.
That is an odd article. On the one hand it mentions your quote about “looking more at liberal arts majors” and on the other hand there’s a lot of discussion about the AI interview,
“In the McKinsey AI Interview, you are expected to prompt the AI, review its output, and apply judgment to produce a clear and structured response,” the Casebasix post said.
So I guess when he talks about liberal arts majors, he is specifically talking about ones who work very well with AI agents?
It makes me think of all the articles out there about liberal arts folks who are currently working at short term contract jobs to train AI on their skills.