U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

Now that we’re done…

Does anyone know how their methodology accounts for ROTC grads? Seems to me that whether an ROTC student majored in engineering or a foreign language (both popular ROTC majors among kids I know who have done it) their “earnings” are going to be much lower than other grads in their majors.

How does this new ranking deal with this?

1 Like

The “earnings by major” metric uses College Scorecard reported earnings. College Scorecard earnings include students in the federal database, such as those with Pell grants or federal loans. College Scorecard excludes persons serving in the military from earnings stats in the older 2016/17 sample, but not the 2017/18 and 2018/19 samples that USNWR is using. Earnings are based on federal reportings, such as on W2, which would include military pay. That said higher ranked “national” colleges tend to have a very low % ROTC, usually <1%.

“That said higher ranked “national” colleges tend to have a very low % ROTC, usually <1%.”

correct

To me, that’s quite optimistic. Consider that a lot of academic superstars’ 20-30% (even higher…) admit rate “safeties” hate being thought of as such and require demonstrated interest to consider a kid who doesn’t apply ED. Case Western is an example.

But even with demonstrated interest, many of these schools don’t want to be wasting their time by admitting kids who are very unlikely to attend (yield protection) – they don’t want to be stuck scrambling to complete their class by heavily relying on the waitlist, and they want kids who really want to attend.

(Tulane is maybe the best example of this – their ED admit rate is like 58%, while their combined EA and RD admit rate is 11.5%. (RD is likely a fair bit lower than EA, but they do not break that out in the CDS…)

I don’t think academic superstars should be considering the Cases and Tulanes (Lehigh, Rochester, Brandeis, etc…) of the world as safeties… unless – maybe – they apply ED.

7 Likes

Most - if not all - top quartile students I have spoken with (mostly New England private/boarding schools) consider schools such as Tulane, Lehigh, Wake Forest as safety schools.

As I said, another convo is whether they should and whether they end-up being accepted.

1 Like

This is where naviance etc is helpful. Our school shows close to 100% admit rate for the small sample that applied ED, something like 80% for EA (so still a big advantage at least for our kids), and mostly red dots for RD.

That figures.

This may be where the two of you were potentially talking apples to oranges. Top quartile of students at New England boarding schools is very different than top quartile of students.

My kid went to a top CA private school where the vast majority of students enrolled in colleges with sub-20% admissions rates. And that does not even include the students like my kid who were admitted to such schools, but chose one with a higher admissions rate. But her bestie went to a well regarded local public. The top quartile of students there could not all get into such highly selective colleges.

6 Likes

Entrepreneurship requires risk-taking – whether your funding is debt or equity, or a mix, you’re on the hook for a lot of other people’s money.. and there is no guarantee of success. Most individuals, whether Stanford grads or not, lack the courage to start a business. If I had an EE degree from Stanford (or anywhere, really), I’d be content to work 8a-5p for an established company.

I 100% agree with you - top quartile can mean different things to different people, which is why I gave a short profile of what I meant by it (a student with great grades and a rigorous course load, great essays, great individual projects, 1550+ SAT score,…). For this profile of student colleges with 20-30%+ acceptance rates are often viewed as safeties. That at least has been my experience.

What you are saying makes sense for your definition. I think most people (at least I did) think of top “quartile” as meaning the top quarter of students though (I.e. top 25% of students). Most of the top 25% of students generally, or even college bound ones, do not have those stats.

6 Likes

I live in this world, too. For one, this depends on the boarding/private school. A HUGE difference between the top 25% at Deerfield/PEA and CSW or at Commonwealth/BBN and many other day schools. Now we are talking about a SUPER small sliver of US students.

At the top ones, they would think Tulane is a likely, sure. especially ED and especially full pay.

I don’t think anyone tells those kids Wake Forest is a “safety”. Certainly the counselors at my kids schools would NOT. They might call it a target for some kids even with its low admit rate but fewer than top 25% I think, but maybe at Andover/Exeter level.

Lehigh would be a likely for a few kids too, sure, probably top 20% at a really top private, but that make sense as they would have top top grades, top rigor and probably 1550 SATs. It would be so for almost anyone that resume honestly…

4 Likes

I should add, Wake Forest might be close to a likely ED for some, but not RD…big difference IMO and should have added.

One of my kids does have some academic superstar classmates and for ED they have been told of counselors that some pretty darn highly ranked schools are “likely” but you just never know…This would be in top 10% of a top school though, not top 25%. Their school never calls anything under 10% as anything but a reach for anyone RD. (except northeastern :roll_eyes:)

1 Like

I don’t think there are many high schools where a 1550 is only 75th percentile, but I will admit no direct experience with what college counselors say at such schools.

What I do know is that at S24’s feederish day school, top grade, 1550+ sort of applicants were usually still treating places like Wake as a type of Target. Part of this is just semantics, though.

Meaning if a kid like that was a good fit and had counselor support for choosing Wake for their list, probably they would agree the chances were significantly higher than 50%. But if sometimes such kids were not admitted, even infrequently, even if not recently, there would be reluctance to reclassify it as a Likely (we didn’t use Safety as a term).

For example, suppose someone like that had, say, a plan to apply early rolling to Pitt. That would be considered a Likely, and of course could become an actual offer before that kid needed to apply anywhere else.

I think the practical reluctance would be if such a kid wanted to actually drop that rolling application to Pitt, didn’t get in anywhere ED/REA/SCEA, and then said they were going to apply to Wake RD and a bunch of Ivy+, claiming that Wake was a sufficient “Safety” for them given their strong numbers. Although that might well work, the advice would probably be Wake wasn’t really safe enough.

Hence Target, although really the name doesn’t matter. Just the concept that maybe using Wake that specific way isn’t appropriately cautious even for high numbers kids.

I’m guessing Wake appeals to a certain subset of kids, it is not popular at all among the kids at our local high school. (4 applied for 2025 and 10 for 2026, out of a class of around 300). What is interesting is that other than the one ED applicant (admitted with middling stats - 3.7, 1330 sat but I guess may have applied TO), almost all the other kids - most with better stats -were waitlisted. I would guess yield protection is a big thing with them. Of course this is “just” a public school with, clearly, very little if any relationship with the college.

2 Likes

Wake in my circles tends to appeal to a certain sort of kid–very good at academics without necessarily being driven to get to the absolute top, general work hard/play hard sort of mindset, sporty and interested in sports, kinda preppy/polished, maybe interested in greek life, probably thinking professional careers in business, law, medicine, that sort of thing . . . .

It also doesn’t have the best reputation for need aid, so skews to full pay parents resigned to their fates.

I think this is probably a little narrow in terms of the overall population at Wake, but we’re not in their backyard (although close enough it isn’t too far either).

2 Likes

I don’t know much about how Wake Forest et al is regarded by East Coast kids, but for the West Coast, a top 10% kid at a strong public school might consider USC a “safety”.

But, counter to being a ‘safety’, USC also has the reputation of regularly turning down such top kids who are able to get into multiple Ivy Plus schools, even when they demonstrate interest. As someone above said, this might simply reflect USC’s desire for yield protection.

3 Likes

Sorry if someone already mentioned, but are others also disturbed that USN eliminated student indebtedness as a 5% criteria? They claim they did it because the government does not update the data frequently enough. There are other sources for that IMO. It holds much more meaning within ROI than the sexy part of who makes the most money. Step backwards IMO.

Furthermore, the salary information by major seems to be somewhat neutral across schools. Nothing better than neutral to give more influence to their 20% school survey.

1 Like