I think for questions like that, it all depends on what purpose you think these rankings should be serving.
Realistically, financial stuff is a strange fit for a generic ranking being used as a college choice tool, because financial stuff is very personal. If College offers you a no-loan full ride, why care if other students will be taking out loans? Or conversely, if you would need a bunch of loans to attend College, why care if other students don’t?
On the other hand, if you are trying to evaluate colleges from a more social policy perspective, like assessing which are overall doing a better or worse job fostering upward social mobility, then maybe that sort of thing should matter a lot.
There is a poster that was trying to decide whether to ED to Duke or Brown.
Yesterday, she was potentially pulling back on Brown - because I don’t want to full pay for #16.
That’s not even loan indebtedness - that’s value for the $$.
What happens to the schools that fall - like the other year Villanova, Wake, Wash U, Tulane - all fell pretty dramatically - although many that had fallen have regained their footing (perhaps figuring out to navigate the criteria).
How many kids out there are like the one yesterday, hedging / changing their list just because US News said something.
Admittedly, Brown was probably only on her list because of US News to begin with.
Now, she’s considering removing Brown - not sure of from the list but at least ED consideration, because 3 days ago US News made a statement via publishing their latest ranking.
So yes, it all depends on the purpose - but as we see all the time - I really want top 20, 30, or 50 - that’s it’s main purpose, forgetting the fact that these kids have no true idea what it means or how it’s determined.
Because we are all good people maybe? There is something very wrong with kids taking out loans they can’t afford to pay back. If a college needs to do that, that plays into my ROI anyway.
When colleges are facing an enrollment decline, it can have impact. Maybe not to an Ivy school but maybe to a 2nd or 3rd tier.
On another thread, there’s a discussion on Colorado College falling short. We know, before this enrollment cliff started, schools like Brandeis and American were falling short.
So as it keeps happening, who knows.
But in the case of a Brown,
It will always find applicants because it’s Ivy and worst case it can lower its selectivity to enroll more. There are always people willing to pay - if they can afford it or not - to say they went Ivy
It’s likely the student (any student) debating whether to apply or not will be a rejection anyway but if enough don’t apply, it can put pressure on the admit rate
I was simply noting the power of US News - without most any kids knowing why the rank is the rank - but yet utilizing it like its some kind of drug.
This method weighs all 629 factors evenly. It is designed to give all colleges and universities the opportunity to be top ranked.
Note: Critics have made the outrageous claim that this ranking consists merely of a random number generator and have transmitted an ugly rumor that the initials “JGGTC” in our algorithm stand for “Jerry Garcia Goes to College.” These unfounded claims are libelous and our battery of lawyers stands ready to attack anyone who makes such statements in the future.
Thank goodness she checked with us, so we could inform her that Brown and Duke are peers… and she should be looking at fit variables and cost, and be sure to have at least one safety she likes.
Yes, but US News > @prezbucky so it doesn’t mean “we” win.
In my mind, it’s a sad way to pick a school - and are you going to fly with the wind that next time a ranking comes out??
I mean, WSJ (I can only see the top 20) but doesn’t have either in the top 20 - but does have Babson, San Jose State and Loyola MD - so maybe Loyola MD should be a school in consideration. Linkedin rates both highly but Duke much higher than Brown. Time Magazine ranks Brown 25th and Duke 40th.
I hate snow. I hate the city - but boy US News says it’s wonderful
But as long as she wins, that’s what matters. If med school truly happens for someone, in many cases a $100K undergrad will make them “not a winner.”
But of course, most those that go for pre med will never touch med school.
Anyway, I wish her luck however she fares or whatever she decides to do and wherever she ends up attending.
There are a lot of sad ways to pick a college, but unless it’s your own kid, there isn’t much you can do about it!
Kids need a low humidity state because their hair misbehaves in certain types of weather. Kid needs to be near surfing (I told my own kids- I’m not paying for a four year vacation. Graduate, get a job, move to Waikiki beach and surf at lunch time). Or whatever. Rankings seem to me at least as rational/irrational as many of the things that folks post on here!!!
And we’ve all got recognize that there’s a Darwinian aspect to the coming higher ed shakeout. The demographic cliff is real. The changes to immigration policy and enforcement (at least for now) is real. I know HS seniors who are applying to zero colleges. They will keep their current parttime job and get fulltime hours because their employers accepted their immigration status (minor child who came here with a parent and got legal asylum; they’ve got a social security number and are paying taxes) and they can’t risk “exposing” themselves to ICE with a college application. Etc. So fewer college going kids means too many seats and beds. There will be a shakeout, that’s just the math.
I am more concerned about the public institutions which over-built, over-borrowed, have ludicrous bond issues to build state of the art sports facilities and luxury dorms in the face of declining enrollment. That’s going to be a LOT more destabilizing to higher ed than if Brandeis has to retrench a bit or if Clark has to combine a few departments.
Were you suggesting the hair/humidity thing was a BAD reason?
But yes, my main undergrad policy concern is that in various states, there are kids who can’t afford the residential colleges, and there is no four-year college with their degree program within reasonable commuting range. A problem which has gotten worse in some states recently. That’s not a college choice problem, but rather college availability.
That said, I think overpaying for degrees is also an important general problem, like this is by far the biggest source of regret in college graduate surveys. And to the extent generic rankings ever encourage people to think overpaying for specific colleges must be worth it because they are so highly ranked, I don’t love that.
Exactly. And not sure why USN can’t incorporate debt into their 5% calculation with salaries. Then, they would have something IMO. It’s is only 5% but it is a meaningful 5%.
Low population density areas are more difficult to serve with commutable colleges, since there may not be a large enough population within reasonable commuting distance of where a college may be located to support a college with a reasonable range of programs and majors. Terrain may also limit the reasonable commuting area / population (e.g. in rural PA and WV).
But how when so many are spending more to educate than their costs, hence the continued endowment withdrawals? The public schools rely on state support, which is waning.
But then some - like North Carolina and its Promise schools, have made affordability a key for all - in and out of state - but can they sustain them long run? How much state funding is involved - and could that go away?
This is why a ranking isn’t a one size fits all - but they’re perceived that way by so many (like the Brown/Duke student).