While online / distance learning can be helpful to some students for whom colleges are out of commuting range and residential attendance is too expensive, not all students adapt to online / distance learning well, and some subjects are difficult to teach in an online / distance format.
It sure would. And I recognize there is currently insufficient political will for such a policy in the relevant states. So, as with many things, I am resigned to this problem not being addressed any time soon.
You’re not comfortable with US News adding a financial outcome metric but think debt information is strange? Don’t the two things relate? Also, doesn’t the second thing relate to institutional resources? I have a vague recollection that you support the various “resources per student” measures as relevant considerations. Isn’t this one of those measures? The ability to help smart poor kids pay for school w/o having to borrow?
I get this point philosophically and I tend to be somewhat sympathetic, or at least make intellectual sense, of the libertarian “mind your own business” perspective. But I have no problem, and think it makes sense, to award an institution for its ability to financial aid people, and doing so w/o debt is more than just a detail to that story.
Back to the financial outcome measure - just to clarify - I recognize you hedged the statement by saying something like “as currently constructed” but I also recall a statement that such a measure (which I took to be a more generalized reference) was incongruent with how you think about liberal arts colleges.
But the data on loan defaults (so not an emotional “I regret it”-- but an actual datapoint) shows that it’s NOT the highly ranked colleges that are the suspects. It’s the for-profit, predatory institutions that have the highest number of “I cannot afford my loans and I’ve exhausted my Pell and I paid for a degree which did nothing for me, not intellectually, not professionally, not economically”.
So it is really an important general problem? The key offenders are NOT the kids who went to NYU and majored in theater. The key offenders (well, they were the victims, but they did sign their loan applications) are the kids majoring in Recreation Management and Forensics who cannot keep up with their payments working the reception desk at the local gym and clerking for their local police department maintaining the files in the evidence room (not a uniformed officer, not a member of the union, just a civilian clerical role).
And when you look at the actual “choice set”- if a kid picks NYU over Muhlenberg or CMU due to rankings- the delta on the costs is pretty trivial. I think we should be worrying about Pell recipients who are being exploited by for-profit colleges and their “you can get loans! college is free” advertising before we spill a lot of ink over the relatively trivial problem of “Duke is ranked higher than Brown, woe is me”.
Yes - but there are limits - and when one moves to an isolated place, they typically understand those limits. It might be a 60 minute bus ride to school or 20 minutes to the nearest grocery store, etc.
I believe HBCUs also are high on the default list.
But all colleges have some default rate and the hope would be to have no default rate.
According to this website, near 9 million student borrowers were at least 30 days in default at the end of 2025.
There’s a few things - defaults are bad - whether the rate is 4% at a named public school or much higher otherwise.
I suspect defaults are down over the past few years given all the relief that covid brought.
Yes, there is a segment that is far more guilty than other segment of schools but the default rates are still too high overall - even at the schools that statistically aren’t the cause of the super high rates.
And it would be very easy for someone to still overextend themselves. And even if they could pay back the loans, they could have had it much easier had they picked differently.
It is usually not the student’s choice that they live in an isolated place. Any choice in the matter is typically that of the parents.
As much as people here want to think of college choice as being based on student achievement and interests, for most students, it is their parents’ choices and circumstances that impose most of the constraints on college choice.
That’s correct - but society can’t be expected to shoulder the costs for someone based on where they live, etc.
There has to be a rule of reasonableness. So there are alternatives - such as distance learning.
I’m not quite sure what you are asking, but I would say I think all generic ROI sorts of measures are flawed on both ends when used as college choice inputs. You are not an average, you are an individual, and so both the average “R” and the average “I” may predictably not apply to you as an individual.
So I wouldn’t put it quite that way. I do think when making college choices, it can make sense to think about how much in institutional resoures are available for things you might care about. And then one issue when making college choices as a HS student is you don’t necessarily know what you might care about years later in college. So, assuming it was equally affordable, a college that had a lot of institutional resources being spread around to a lot of different things relevant to undergrads might be attractive, in the sense it could cover a lot of currently unidentified interests you might develop.
But even the most well-resourced institutions have different priorities, they can’t literally fund everything at the highest possible levels. So generic measures of institutional resources aren’t really going to get you far, I think you need to try to understand the priorities of each institution, and make sure they at least broadly align with your own, understanding you might well end up wanting to do things you don’t currently imagine doing.
So award in what sense?
That’s the basic point I was making above. First you have to decide what the point of these rankings even is. If it is to award institutions for doing more of things we think are good things to do, then cool. But that isn’t the same purpose as using them for individual college choice.
Like if a pickup truck manufacturer had a big charitable fund, I might agree that should be applauded. But if I am buying a fuel-efficient commuter car, I’m still not going to consider their pickup trucks.
I again would not put it that way. What I was expressing there was things like I didn’t love what it was doing to the rankings, but I also acknowledged that was a personal preference. For me this is pretty easy to say, because I think all generic rankings are inherently silly, so I don’t think there is any objective right or wrong that could be contrasted with personal preference.
That being said, I understand some people want generic ROI measures, notwithstanding my thinking they are a particularly flawed concept. So I understand for them, a measure that did a “better” job with the “R” part would be valuable. It appears to me, though, the new US News earnings-by-major measure didn’t do a better job in any notable sense than, say, just a plain old average earnings measure.
I certainly don’t think it is as big a problem as predatory for-profit colleges.
However, I do think it is a problem when people feel like they can’t do the major or next degree or the first job they would like because they are overburdened with undergrad debt. I do think it is a problem when they feel like they are delaying things like starting families because they can’t afford to yet. And so on. None of those scenarios may end up as a loan default, but I don’t think that means they are unproblematic.
I note I am largely talking about costs, not major choice. If your family is very wealthy, or alternatively you get a lot of aid, and want to study theater at NYU, I will not give you any sort of grief for that.
But my sense is when people end up paying a lot more money to go to NYU, or wherever, than they could have paid to go to, say, a quality in-state college, AND their families are not very wealthy, and in fact maybe their families are making serious sacrifices to help cover the difference, then they might feel a lot of pressure to make it “worth it” by NOT majoring in theater.
Like, if the theory is it will all be worth it when they get a high-paying finance job, what if they are a couple years into college and realize they really hate finance? Will they feel free to abandon that path for something they realize would be a lot more fulfilling, but provide less immediate compensation? My sense is if they and their family feel like their “investment” in NYU, or whatever, required a lot of sacrifice, they may feel much more reluctant to give up on the “return” they originally used to justify that “investment”.
That depends, right?
Again, some kids will get their lowest cost from a highly-ranked private, which completely moots this particular concern. Some, though, would be able to get a much lower cost at an in-state public. And then some would also be able to get a lower cost from a lower-ranked private, thanks to merit.
So yes, if a kid would be full pay at NYU or CMU, and choosing between the two, that also moots my concern. But what if they could get a much lower cost from, say, UCLA because they are in-state for California? Or Mount Holyoke thanks to a big merit offer?
Again if their family is very wealthy, OK, do whatever they prefer. But if the difference would actually make a difference to their family, then I think it is a real issue for that family.
I think this is one of the basic tensions in US society. We sometimes talk about equality of opportunity, but then when kids have very unequal opportunities due to their parents and the choices their parents have made, we sometimes say that is just their tough luck.
And I don’t mean to suggest there is an obvious solution to all such problems. It is a very basic sort of problem that all modern “mixed economy” countries struggle with.
Still, I think sometimes certain countries, states, or so on are willing to try to create at least more educational opportunities for disadvantaged kids than others. And I generally feel that is a good thing.
A far more common scenario is the kid sticks with finance, ends up on the pricing team at a P&C insurance company (a fine job btw… but nowhere near I-banking or hedge fund compensation).
ROI has both a numerator and a denominator. And none of us can predict the labor markets.
I agree with this. Sometimes people talk about IB, hedge funds, quant, even MBB consulting as though it’s a matter of want.
It’s so competitive that 99% of college kids are not getting these jobs even if they want them.
As a former surfer, this seems a totally legitimate reason to pick a college. Giving up surfing for 4 years is a big ask for a committed surfer. Here in CA you have a variety of great schools with a range of selectivity that are close to surfing.
Yeah, personally I think once you are looking at affordable colleges with any academic programs you might want to consider, I think it is fine to turn to factors like being in setting/location with activities and such you would want to be a regular part of your overall life.
I agree with this. Let’s not forget that the ranking business has been running full throttle ever since 1983 and the various poses and feints and assumptions they’ve gone through mirror society in a strange way. Like the first one was basically a beauty contest; it reflected what a relatively small market composed of upper-middle class families who were familiar with a couple dozen colleges and universities saw as reflections of themselves. The big innovation came a couple years later when the idea of endowment per student was added. Let’s face it, this had a special appeal for a stratum of society that frankly was fascinated by personal wealth and for whom it was easy to superimpose those values on highly desirable destinations. No one was overly concerned with affordability, partly because colleges were, in fact, less expensive, but also because people had yet to wrap their heads around the idea that smart poor and working-class kids somehow had the same right to attend a T20 college or university. In fact, the colleges that were aggressively spending more of their endowments on need-based financial aid were being punished because in terms of accounting, financial aid tended to show up as nothing more than the lack of income from tuition.
Other magazines took up the cause of “affordability”, delving into such things as student debt, net costs, and in the case of The Washington Monthly things like the presence of ROTC programs, work in The Peace Corps, Teach for America (thus, earning it the sobriquet, “The Mother Teresa Poll”.)
Some forty years later, the T20s have never been more economically diverse; the term, FGLI has become familiar and everyone is struggling with high costs.
Agree - we don’t seem to have an issues when some students here looking for colleges post that they want it to be near hiking, skiing, have horse riding, etc… so wanting to be close to surfing seems totally legit to me.
But let me suggest some some counterexamples.
Suppose a kid had a choice between MIT and Pepperdine for a STEM major. And due to financial aid, the cost to attend is exactly the same. And she chooses the latter for two important reasons to her: for better dorm food because she is a foodie (I’m just making this up; I don’t know about the food situation at either), and for the fact that she wants to be close to her boyfriend.
Wouldn’t most parents and other caring adults try to knock some sense into her and persuade her otherwise?
In other words, fundamentally college is just “school” for 32 months of your life: a combination of adult formation and getting you ready for the next 70 years of your life.
Should we really be encouraging high school kids to think that ALL factors (e.g., ability to surf, great dorm food, proximity to significant other, etc.) should be equally important?
Shouldn’t some factors simply a MINOR part of choosing a college?
That’s the right word to put in all caps…what’s minor to one student could be very important or even most important to a different student. IMO, it’s not for outsiders to judge.
With that said, I do believe if parents are paying they do have a say in the decision. But how far should they push it?
If I strong armed my kid or forcefully asserted my opinion, I sure wouldn’t want hear about it at every family gathering for the rest of my life, especially if kid didn’t have a positive experience. Nor would I risk having my kid go no contact with me.
Bottom line, each student and family is unique in how they make this decision.