So holding aside the food one for a moment, I personally see a strong underlying commonality between picking a college based on a HS romantic attachment and picking based on generic rankings. Just to be blunt about it, knowing teenagers and how they sometimes feel about things, I think both overvaluing your HS romantic attachments and overvaluing how your HS peers perceive your college choice is a predictable risk associated with a lack of life experience, and maybe just some basic hormonal/brain development stuff.
So “silly” is one word, but maybe “immature” is even better. I think it is potentially reflective of a lack of life experience and developmental maturity to pick a college primarily for either of those factors (HS romantic attachments or generic rankings/peer-perceptions/“prestige”).
OK, so do I think caring, experienced adults can play a role in trying to steer kids toward making their college choices for more mature reasons? I hope so! But I also understand it is a challenge, and not one limited to college choices. And I do think there is a constant tension between wanting to help, but also the possibility that if you intervene too much, you will interfere with kids actually acquiring the experiences they need, including making mistakes and facing consequences, to actually mature.
It isn’t easy navigating all this!
But at least between us adults, I have zero problem identifying when I personally think strong consideration of a certain factor would be reflective of immaturity.
Interestingly, I don’t really think it is so easy to peg caring about things like dining that way. I think potentially it could be taken too far, but in my experience there are also kids who don’t yet have the experience and maturity to understand how daily life stuff is related to stuff like academic performance.
Like if you are not sleeping and eating well, that can really be bad! There is plenty of evidence you will at least underperform your potential academically, and sometimes too much neglect of these things can lead to an actual crisis. Same deal with not getting enough physical activity, not enough socializing just for fun, or so on.
Again, there is some sort of Aristotelian Golden Mean involved in these practical wisdom things. Like, understanding all this is important doesn’t mean you can’t also have a “but that’s good enough” attitude, versus a maximalist attitude. Like, enough sleep, enough good nutrition, enough physical activity, enough just-for-fun socializing . . . lots of “enoughs” to cover, but that’s again just part of shaping a happy, healthy, successful life.
And then I think young people, and particularly ambitious young people, can sometimes be too quick to sacrifice some of these daily life things in the name of pursuing associating themselves with institutional “excellence” (or “prestige”), and end up self-sabotaging.
So at least specifically for these sorts of ambitious young people, I do feel like often caring adults can be a voice in favor of taking such basic things as seriously as they deserve–which I think is pretty seriously, at least until you are satisfied you are into the “good enough” range.