U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

@Mwfan1921

And yet, we as parents and adults feel perfectly comfortable telling a kid NOT to choose a college based solely on “prestige” because we feel it is silly or shallow.

Said another way, we express opinions on all sorts of life decisions for our children (and to even those high school kids we hardly know on these forums).

I don’t think you can have it both ways when it comes to “each student and family is unique in how they make a decision”. I generally support that attitude, but surely you see we are not being consistent.

On the one hand, we say picking college based on rankings or prestige is silly, then on the other hand, we say picking on the basis of proximity to surfing or dorm food or a boyfriend might be okay – “it is your choice / your life”.

1 Like

People come here to ask advice. They often get a variety of opinions because people think differently. But they ask. So they get answers - some think prestige is worth paying high amounts for. Others don’t, especially if it’s not easily affordable. Some think the school matters more than the major. Others don’t. All are different.

We aren’t in their homes so ultimately they make the final decision.

1 Like

I’m not sure who you mean by ‘we’. If a student has a balanced list including at least one affordable highly likely school, I don’t think it’s ‘silly’ if they use rankings to finalize said list. They have to narrow down the list somehow.

Once my kids were in HS, I was careful not to give my unsolicited opinion. For college decisions, both kids used an independent counselor, both were recruited athletes, and we were full pay. Aside from many discussions about recruiting strategy/tactics because both sought out my opinion, I stayed out of the rest of it.

ETA, I chose not to express a viewpoint in a recent thread where the kid is deciding between Duke or Brown for ED and was concerned about Brown’s new, lower USNWR ranking. If that’s how that kid wants to make his choice, it’s their prerogative.

1 Like

I don’t know if this is the best example because MIT is such a “fit” school. If a student doesn’t love MIT and really have the desire to go there over another school, they might be better off at the other school.

I know what you mean to say, but the example would read better to me if the two schools in the example were similar in terms of fit, but with one being generally thought of as a better choice for most kids on the whole… if that makes sense.

1 Like

And some are, but who are we to dictate what that should be? There are kids who won’t consider a college without a marching band or intramural sport in x, how is that different from surfing? Some kids have food high on their priority list and others like mine don’t care the slightest about that. Some have very strict requirements about distance from home, I haven’t seen anyone arguing “a few hours extra to get to college or a flight instead of a drive shouldn’t matter because it won’t affect your 70-year outlook on life”. No one is saying any of these should be top priority but assuming you have a range of colleges that fit the basic requirements in terms of academics etc, what is minor to one may be an important lifestyle issue to another. It is still 4 years of your life, after all, at an age where that is a very significant chunk of your lived experience.

Where in what I wrote did you infer that I said this?

I can pretty much guarantee that as much as we might say this here on CC, many families do not. And that prestige arguably is one of the factors that might follow you through life. Whatever my own opinions on this, I can see how some families might consider it a very valid factor in choosing a school.

1 Like

This seems less a counter example to surfing, hiking, skiing, horseback riding, than an example of different factors that you do not find valuable when comparing MIT to Pepperdine with hypothetically better food.

Surfing, hiking, horseback riding are often significant parts of such students lifestyle, physical health, community and mental wellbeing. Giving them up when there is a good option where you do not need to can be very significant.

If you kept the hypo on a surfing STEM kid, I’d wonder why they did not apply to UCSD, UCLA, Stanford and others if they wished to continue surfing. For your food example, why didn’t they look at other STEM schools with good food? If they got into MIT presumably they could have been admitted to some other STEM schools beyond Pepperdine assuming they/their family thought Pepperdine was a no go in comparison to MIT. I don’t know enough about Pepperdine, but am not even sure it is a fair assumption that a family should try to persuade their kid to go to MIT over Pepperdine if the kid is STEM. That is not inherently true to me.

1 Like

In this hypothetical construction of ONLY a choice between 2 schools (and not introducing other schools into the equation), I think it would be ‘inherently true’ to 99% of college-bound families that MIT is the better choice for STEM than Pepperdine. :slight_smile:

The main point is, I don’t think I would be as open to my child choosing Pepperdine over MIT for STEM if she was allowing surfing | dorm food | boyfriend to play a central role, as opposed to a minor role, in the decision. .

I’m suppose this back-and-forth has surprised me that you folks would be so ‘hands off’ for a child who wants to use these (hypothetical) reasons for picking a school.

1 Like

I hear you, my point is if I were to be “hands on,” it would be in constructing an application list so that those were not my STEM kid who loved surfing or food’s only 2 choices. So, my problem with the hypothetical is how did the “hands on” parent let themself get into that situation? My assumption is if you can get into MIT, you can get into some good choices that have good food or surfing near by. And if we are talking Pepperdine, some of those choices are in state UCs that are likely to be affordable. But you have to do that work on the front end. I will take it that you are correct that on the back end most families would choose/force MIT. But, presumably surfing did not just become a significant part of said kid’s life spring of senior year, so where was the parental planning before?

Edit: by the way, I am 100% with you on the boyfriend, but others may not feel the same as me on that either.

1 Like

In fact I feel like one of the constants over the years I have been in these conversations is the tension between those who are concerned about the relatively poor representation of disadvantaged college students at “elite” colleges (including prominent private colleges), and those who are concerned about a “donut hole” effect in which they believe disadvantaged kids actually have it better than middle/upper-middle class kids (this isn’t really supportable by raw enrollment data, but you can put together a colorable argument to this effect if you do things like control by test scores first). I note largely missing, for good reasons, are people concerned about truly upper class kids being underrepresented at these colleges–there appears to be no danger of that happening.

OK, and then I feel like in recent years, the US News has de facto been tacking back and forth over this underlying tension. So, a few years ago, it adopted measures which awarded relatively more representation of disadvantaged students. It started chipping back on some of those effects in the very next edition, but this new measure appears to have swung way back toward rewarding colleges for having the biggest pipelines to the upper middle class, as defined by earnings, no questions asked on how they get there.

And cynically, I might suggest they are operating in a “safe” range with all this in the sense that some people will be more or less happy with any different version, since there are major constituencies for all this. So such changes will always have supporters who think it is an improvement, providing them with some insulation from blowback until the next time they decide they need to “make news” again.

3 Likes

So holding aside the food one for a moment, I personally see a strong underlying commonality between picking a college based on a HS romantic attachment and picking based on generic rankings. Just to be blunt about it, knowing teenagers and how they sometimes feel about things, I think both overvaluing your HS romantic attachments and overvaluing how your HS peers perceive your college choice is a predictable risk associated with a lack of life experience, and maybe just some basic hormonal/brain development stuff.

So “silly” is one word, but maybe “immature” is even better. I think it is potentially reflective of a lack of life experience and developmental maturity to pick a college primarily for either of those factors (HS romantic attachments or generic rankings/peer-perceptions/“prestige”).

OK, so do I think caring, experienced adults can play a role in trying to steer kids toward making their college choices for more mature reasons? I hope so! But I also understand it is a challenge, and not one limited to college choices. And I do think there is a constant tension between wanting to help, but also the possibility that if you intervene too much, you will interfere with kids actually acquiring the experiences they need, including making mistakes and facing consequences, to actually mature.

It isn’t easy navigating all this!

But at least between us adults, I have zero problem identifying when I personally think strong consideration of a certain factor would be reflective of immaturity.

Interestingly, I don’t really think it is so easy to peg caring about things like dining that way. I think potentially it could be taken too far, but in my experience there are also kids who don’t yet have the experience and maturity to understand how daily life stuff is related to stuff like academic performance.

Like if you are not sleeping and eating well, that can really be bad! There is plenty of evidence you will at least underperform your potential academically, and sometimes too much neglect of these things can lead to an actual crisis. Same deal with not getting enough physical activity, not enough socializing just for fun, or so on.

Again, there is some sort of Aristotelian Golden Mean involved in these practical wisdom things. Like, understanding all this is important doesn’t mean you can’t also have a “but that’s good enough” attitude, versus a maximalist attitude. Like, enough sleep, enough good nutrition, enough physical activity, enough just-for-fun socializing . . . lots of “enoughs” to cover, but that’s again just part of shaping a happy, healthy, successful life.

And then I think young people, and particularly ambitious young people, can sometimes be too quick to sacrifice some of these daily life things in the name of pursuing associating themselves with institutional “excellence” (or “prestige”), and end up self-sabotaging.

So at least specifically for these sorts of ambitious young people, I do feel like often caring adults can be a voice in favor of taking such basic things as seriously as they deserve–which I think is pretty seriously, at least until you are satisfied you are into the “good enough” range.

2 Likes
1 Like