U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

One thing is for sure, Adcoms and school admins up to the President level will be crossing their fingers that they don’t plunge.

As schools of interest, Rollins will forgo its #2 position in Regional Universities South to appear among National Liberal Arts Colleges, and SUNY–Geneseo will leave Regional Universities North, at #17, also to appear in the NLAC category. By the standards of the publication, this suggests a greater national reputation for both of these schools.

4 Likes

Odd for a SUNY, especially one College Factual estimates is 98-99% in state. The school doesn’t say that but notes 11 states are represented. No SunyS are truly diverse.

I wish there was one category or one LAC category. Honestly very few are truly national in scope vs the entire list. Most are regional.

2 Likes

It sounds like they are using CollegeScorecard information derived from earnings by major as a new ranking metric. There are a large number of ways this could be presented to draw misleading conclusions. My expectation is the weighting formula will be selected in such a way to not shake things up much, particularly towards the top of the list. I suppose we’ll see in a few weeks.

As an example of this metric, the colleges with highest 2 year out median earnings among different majors in the fed database (mostly Pell or loans) are below. Key limitations include stats for most colleges are not available and small sample size when available.

The more fundamental issue is the college name is usually not the primary driving factor for differences in these stat. Controlling for differences in individual students is particularly relevant. If you don’t control for individual student differences, you’ll generally see the larger the portion of students at the college that are academically high achieving, the higher the earnings for graduates of that college. This is well correlated with selectivity and to a lesser extent being private, so highly selective private Ivy+ type colleges tend to do well. As such, USNWR can add this metric to their formula at a low weighting %, without shaking up the college rankings much.

Computer Science
1 . CMU – $160k, 94 students
2. Brown – $154k, 59 students
3. Harvey Mudd – $143k, 43 students
4. Stanford – $137k, 63 students
5. Pomona – $129k, 13 students

Music
1 . U Houston – $49k, 63 students
2. UT Rio Grande – $49k, 46 students
3. TAMU: Kingsville – $48k, 13 students
4. UT El Paso – $48k, 13 students
5. Texas Tech – $44k, 40 students

3 Likes

Note that the intended point of evaluation is four years after graduation.

1 Like

Yes, the 4 year median earnings data for students who receive federal financial aid (which does include those who only took federal student loans) is also from College Scorecard.

Let’s hope ED continues to populate these data. I’m not confident about that as college navigator have been down all week. IPEDs had also been down, but seems functional again.

2 Likes

For the fraction of people interested in comparisons between the overall demographics at colleges and the demographics of students on sports teams, Geneseo’s (typically excellent) men’s hockey team includes students from Illinois, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Texas, Colorado, Ontario, British Columbia, Sweden, Norway and Finland.

1 Like

The US News categories have always been misnamed. They were using Carnegie Classifications, so basically they translated enough doctoral degrees into National Universities, enough masters-level into Regional, mostly bachelors with lots of Arts and Sciences into National Liberal Arts Colleges, and mostly bachelors with mostly an arts, tech, or whatever focus into Regional Colleges.

Quite obviously, using labels like National and Regional for what they were doing really didn’t make sense, and generated a lot of anomalies where quite obviously some institutions they were calling National mostly drew their undergrads locally, and some they were calling Regional had significantly wider incoming undergrad distributions than those sorts of “National” institutions.

In 2025, Carnegie overhauled its classifications, and US News is partially adopting those changes–and partially not. And still using misleading labels.

One might then ask why they don’t just use the actual Carnegie classifications and actual Carnegie classification names. And I assume it is basically because the marketing team said no.

5 Likes

Probably how they got to 11 states where students come from.

A distinction without a meaningful difference. While there is some reordering due to small sample size, the same types of colleges rank well or rank poorly at either sample time. Continuing with the Computer Science example, increasing from 2 to 4 years, the top ranked colleges change as follows:

1 . CMU – still #1
2. MIT – up from #7
3. Cornell – up from #9
4. Princeton – no earning info at 2 years due to below minimum sample size of ~10
5. Pomona – still #5
6. Stanford – dropped from #4 to #6
7. Brown – dropped from #2 to #7

As a comment on U.S. News generally, its college guidebook deemphasizes reliance on its rankings. It’s largely the public — of whom most, it seems, have not read the guidebook — that has magnified the rankings beyond their significance.

2 Likes

USNWR would probably cease to exist without its college rankings.

They’ll probably always tweak the formula (and make changes) to keep people engaged.

10 Likes

I kind of agree with this. Do people buy guidebooks anymore?

1 Like

I do, but not USNWR’s!

4 Likes

I was going to add that the whole idea of a “national” LAC would have been an oxymoron 50 years ago and is partly a creation of USNews and an exploding upper-middle-class willing to travel across the country in order to cherry-pick the top dozen or so.

1 Like

I didn’t even know USNWR had one!

My kids found Fiske’s guide a useful thing to have around… I didn’t buy a new version for kid 2.. but was worth the price to pay for 1 for 2 kids.

4 Likes

Would you consider Wellesley a LAC? or Dartmouth? or Tufts? I certainly personally know people traveled across country for those 50 years ago…

1 Like

or Vassar, Oberlin and Mt Holyoke… come to think of it…more people i know personally that travelled very far to attend

1 Like

The guidebook is at its best when it extends from the journalism on which the original magazine was based. Recurring features have included profiles of 10 students from a particular high school, noting the colleges they considered and ultimately chose, and a road trip to a particular state to visit five colleges. The rankings of which most people are familiar are included. It’s not obligatory to read them or care about them. And for those interested in the rankings, the guidebook’s narrative introductions place them in context.

2 Likes

I was in the middle of creating this thread when you posted:
An Outsider’s Guide to National LACs - College Search & Lists - College Confidential Forums

1 Like