U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

More like they do that because that is what the data source College Scorecard provides, even though the reduction of influence of hooked (in terms of jobs) graduates happens to be an unintended benefit for those looking at job pay outcomes by major.

However, smaller majors at smaller colleges (particularly those with fewer federal financial aid recipients) may have small sample size issues, as indicated by lack of visible data on College Scorecard.

They’ve shown that they understand the benefit, which might be interpreted as a form of intent.

1 Like

Or that they got the data that was available, and then realized that it had some benefit, so they add that to the marketing of using it in their rankings. They don’t mention the drawback, which is smaller sample sizes, particularly with smaller majors and smaller colleges.

They’ll have to make determinations regarding significance, right?

For smaller majors and smaller colleges, more often than not the drawback is no reported earnings at all due to privacy suppression. For example, according to College Scorecard, 792 colleges offer a bachelor’s degree in physics. Of that 792 colleges, only 107 have earnings information available – 13%. Even among more popular majors like computer science, earnings information is only available for 45% of colleges.

5 Likes

A new Earnings by Major ranking factor credits colleges for delivering strong early-career outcomes.

And here comes Babson … again!!!

I’ll repeat what the president of a LAC one of my kids attended said at convocation (or invocation): “If your son or daughter is doing 10 years out from graduation what they were doing immediately after graduation, then we’ve failed them.”

Liberal Arts Colleges: the last of the big picture people.

Everyone wants assured employment and $100,000 / yr. right out of school. If you can’t hang with the high end finance bros, don’t see yourself in sales or can’t hack engineering, go to a cheap school and major in accounting. It will give you what you seek, though it’s a different type of education altogether.

IDK. Maybe the “classical education” is a luxury for the wealthy (or the really poor) after all. Perhaps time to give up the fight.

I’m so excited to see Babson in the T10. Should be a hoot.

3 Likes

We will see if Babson, Bentley, Richmond and Bucknell rise up.

If so, that would be US News agreeing with other rankings that already show that.

But we’ll find out in Sept.

My gut feel is those who place well in IB are the rich and connected, not those taking loans - but we shall see.

Any liberal arts college with engineering and/or business will get a boost.

As for me and mine, I’m thrilled with the results, both in terms of what I value in education and in terms employment and how my kiddos are making their way in the world. Could not be happier and don’t regret a single check written.

2 Likes

Babson will be ranked in the Regional Universities North category.

1 Like

Bentley will remain in the Regional Universities North category, in which it currently places first.

1 Like

It’s odd - because it is Babson, without the top rank in entrepreneurship.

I wish they had one rank.

If you want to say, one 10K and under and one 10K or over, etc. I get it.

You need apples to apples - Babson, Bentley and in some ways Bryant are similar but one is best known. All are regional, etc as most colleges are.

All three of these schools will appear in the Regional Universities North category.

2 Likes

Am I reading correctly that today Babson is only ranked in Entrepreneurship but not vs. other colleges - such as nationally or regionally? That’s odd.

Then there’s the entire regional college but then regional university.

Their entire classification is very odd. And how do you compare Cooper Union with Elmira College, etc.?

It’s just very odd.

For 4 year median earnings in business major, Babson had the 18th highest earnings – in between UIUC and SMU. With the presumed low weighting in the new earnings criteria, it’s certainly not going to drive Babson to top 10, if Babson was ranked as national university (it’s not).

It wasn’t in previous years.

Correct. Babson is treated as a specialty college, rather than national or regional college.

That’s why it’s goofy - because it’s not really different than Bentley - and a Bentley will compete against Babson and UCONN and UMASS, etc. - so it’s another reason their rankings are silly. No different than Babson which will compete against those schools and maybe even more.

It’s amazing that US News has this hold on people. When I was looking at MBAs at least, it was Business Week.

2 Likes

USNWR is basing their ranking list selection on 2021 Carnegie. In the 2021 Carnegie, Bentley was listed as Master’s Colleges & Universities: Larger Programs, while Babson was listed as Special Focus: Business. Unlike Babson, Bentley offers many non-business degrees even though only 7% of students choose them.

However, this changed in the new 2025 Carnegie for which both colleges are listed as Special Focus: Business. If USNWR switches from 2021 Carnegie to the 2025 Carnegie this year, then I’d expect both Bentley and Babson will not appear on the regional (or national) rankings.

3 Likes

So we’ll have to see the details, but theoretically what US News suggested it would be doing is that if, say, College A had a lot of Business majors and College B had a lot of English majors, their Earnings by Major score would not automatically favor College A. Instead, they would be looking at how College A’s Business majors compared to Business majors in general, and how College B’s English majors compared to English majors in general.

So if, say, College B’s English majors averaged more than most English majors, whereas College A’s Business majors just averaged normal for Business majors, then it would actually be College B that got the higher Earnings by Major score.

There are a lot of important details when doing something like this, but this is why I am not at all sure this will hurt every liberal arts and sciences college, or universities with a lot of liberal arts and sciences majors, versus schools with a lot of business and/or engineering majors. We know the latter tend to have higher earnings before you do this sort of control, but after? It is not hard for me to imagine that English majors, and Math majors, and Econ majors, and so on, average a lot more at some colleges than others. And this sort of approach may actually reward those colleges more than just having a lot of Business or Engineering majors who only are doing normally well for Business and Engineering majors.

4 Likes

By the way, I always find this Life Magazine college guide from 1960 to be really illuminating about how people thought about US colleges back that far:

If you read through that, for sure there are more indication of regionalism than you might see today, and this is actually very well-documented in various broader studies: over recent decades, more students are traveling outside of their locality, state, and region for college than they used to.

Still, a minority of students back then did go farther away for college, for one reason or another.

And so right from the start, with Amherst, the first narrative comment (these are “sometimes irreverent comments . . . given by top U.S. high school guidance counselors, who have the broadest view of the colleges”) is: “One of the nation’s strongest liberal arts colleges.”

And then if you look a little down to Beloit, you will see, “Distinctly Midwest, often incompatible with the sophisticated eastern student.” Aside from me chuckling at the distinctly Mad Men vibe to all this, what is happening here is this “irreverent” comment is implicitly acknowledging that some students might consider traveling from, say, the east to the midwest for an LAC, but warning that Beloit might not be a good fit for “sophisticated” eastern students.

Kenyon, on the other hand, is, “The eastern men’s college moved westward,” although it is then warned, “Standards are high. Expensive social demands.”

Carleton, in contrast, is described as, “A real academic challenge without social pressures or status seekers,” but then they warn, “A candidate should understand the climate–ice skating year round,” and that they “Accept only top candidates from the east.”

Anyway, getting back to US News, I find it very interesting that Life certainly saw no reason to treat colleges and universities as two separate markets for undergrad programs. They are all just lumped together narratively, and then in the chart on the next page which has a variety of data but tiers colleges by SAT range (alphabetical within a range, though).

If you are wondering, the top tier (again this is alphabetical) was Amherst, Carleton, Columbia, Harvard, Haverford, Princeton, Reed, Rice, Swarthmore, Williams, and Yale. Some interesting stories about who was included, and who not, in 1960. Stanford, for example, was still in the second tier. Narratively, Stanford was, “The Yale of the West Coast except it is fortunate enough to be coeducational,” and “Students from Midwest and east have a good chance for admissions with 600-700 SAT scores.” If you are wondering, MIT and Caltech are entirely missing, as are women’s colleges (men’s, sure, women’s, no . . . welcome to 1960).

Anyway, my two cents is then that the sharp divide some people see between universities and LACs when it comes to undergrad choice really is an artifact mostly of the US News deciding to publish its rankings like that. Just about every other system I have seen which does not simply assume that distinction does not actually reproduce it, and I feel like this Life article confirms it was not really the historical attitude either. Not that Life was unaware of the distinction, it just didn’t assume people would not freely cross-shop them as they might choose.

Less natural? Including tech specialists on these same lists. And the recent 2025 change to the Carnegie Classifications also split them back off. It would therefore be very interesting if US News followed suit–they have not yet, but next time they want to make a lot of “news” with their rankings, they could consider it.

6 Likes

Comparing salaries by major is a big improvement. I just wonder if they will regionalize the salaries and turn them into an index. Earning $80K in Manhattan is not the same as earning $80K in Iowa.

That might require individual level data and be impossible.

Still, I am over the rankings. So many metrics are meaningless or “flavor of the month” and so many can be gamed by the schools. The metrics actually have to change every few years because the schools game them so badly.

Someone should write an article about all of the foolishness that occurs because schools want to rise in the rankings. That would be an interesting article.

3 Likes

Year round ice skating? I guess that climate change is worse than I thought. Apparently the Bald Spot was frozen over all year in 1960. :wink:

4 Likes