U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

I believe in 1960, occasionally a humorous irreverence might have outweighed strict accuracy . . . .

I haven’t read it, but supposedly the book Breaking Ranks does a nice job on this subject.

Then there is the classic 2014 Boston Magazine article How to Game the College Rankings, which specifically went after Northeastern.

ETA: Still linkable!

4 Likes

I am going to read that article! Northeastern is a great example. Ironically…there is an argument to be made that it actually paid off for them. The top students at our HS love Northeastern.

As an undergrad, I watched as college administrators would each teach 1 or 2 classes per year just to count as “faculty” to drive down the student-faculty ratio that was a component of the rankings at the time.

The fact that some of those classes were terrible didn’t seem to matter much.

1 Like

Until they (or anyone) can come up with a reasonable formula to represent the quality of education/teaching, to me, the rest is just window-dressing. They do tackle that to an extent, with the academic rep rating from the deans (and/or their aides…), but that has its own issues.

To me, that’s the Rosetta Stone. Ranking schools by ROI is foolish since it heavily favors schools with a preponderance of STEM (especially Engineering and CS) majors… and nearly every kid chooses their major. Early on post-grad, Humanities and SS degrees tend to lead to jobs that do not pay as well. That should not penalize a school great in teaching those things.

3 Likes

And “back in the day” the alumni office would set up a table with free iced coffee which they’d hand out with pledge cards as students marched in the commencement processional. There would actually be a $5 “gift” category, because various rankings measured “alumni engagement” (using the metric of what percent of the class gives to the fund). Now it would be overrun- even an iced coffee at the cheapest place in town costs $5!

2 Likes

I don’t think there is a question it paid off.

4 Likes

Indeed. And some of the schools that have been vocal in criticizing the rankings have been punished. Colby College is one that comes to mind.

3 Likes

Indeed.

I will say in general, in the 1980s, 1990s, and 2000s there was a big market opportunity that lots of colleges made use of. Basically, the traditional “top”/“elite” private colleges did not expand capacity to match the expansion in the highly-qualified applicant pool, particularly among women but also somewhat men.

And this was not least true in the most popular areas for college students in the rapidly growing national and international markets, like the Northeast Coast or California, and definitely not least Boston.

So my two cents is Northeastern was in a great position to benefit from this market opportunity . . . and then has gotten dinged up in the press for being a little too aggressive in its marketing strategies. Still, the opportunity was really there, and as you suggest, I think they really did make use of it.

3 Likes

Of course, it all depends on what % each metric counts, etc. We’ll know soon enough and it will be another ranking for robust debate :slight_smile:

I’m not going to claim this is truly a great measure, but I note US News does include an undergraduate teaching section in its administrator surveys . . . and then doesn’t use it in the main rankings. But it does publish some results separately, like here are partial lists for National Universities and National LACs:

https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/national-universities/undergraduate-teaching

https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/national-liberal-arts-colleges/undergraduate-teaching

They are interesting lists to check out in my view. Lots of the usual suspects do well, but then so do some less heralded institutions. In fact, I like to point out that there are a lot of Jesuit colleges in particular which do much better in these rankings than their general rankings, which to me reflects an actual reality people should take into consideration.

In the end, though, I personally think the question of where you will get your best undergrad education is obviously very personal. Different people thrive in different learning environments, with different mixes of resources, and so on. And one of the real virtues of the (very expensive) US undergrad system is there is so much variety.

So I don’t think there can be a good generic ranking. I think there can be information that helps you as an individual find the best bets for you as an individual, but they will never also be the best bets for every other individual. And that is good.

2 Likes

Does it surprise you that in our anti-intellectual/consumerist society the quality of teaching/academic excellence is no longer of interest to a big segment of the college-going population (and/or their parents)?

Kids want their ticket punched. Mom and Dad want to know that a lucrative career awaits (the much vaunted “ROI” and the obsession with “first salary” reports- as if what you earn at 22 is the be-all and end-all of your education). And the guy behind the counter at your dry cleaners needs to validate your choice (i.e. has he heard of it? which likely means a winning basketball team).

I get pushback every time I extol the benefits of Missouri S&T. I get nasty PM’s about what an elitist I am for claiming that attending a college with a rigorous program in Renaissance Studies (if that’s what the kid wants to study) is “worth it”. As if there is an actual job called “Renaissance Person” which is what these kids are gunning for.

So we get to plough through the popularity contests, the reams of “faux data” about earnings which does not normalize for urban/rural or state with no income tax vs. one with, and the blather about why majoring in “Entrepreneurship” has a better outcome than just majoring in biochemistry or robotics where you could learn an actual skill to develop a product which would make you an “entrepreneur”. We reap what we sow.

7 Likes

According to the article at https://www.usnews.com/education/blogs/college-rankings-blog/articles/2026-02-10/us-news-ranking-category-updates-for-2026 , USNWR is changing their old system based aligning rankings lists with 2021 Carnegie groupings. In the new grouping, Babson becomes a regionally ranked college along with numerous others such as Albany Pharmacy, Charles Drew University of Medicine , Culinary Institute of America, Haskell Indian Nations University, etc.

There are also switches between national and regional. For example, numerous Cal States switch from regional to national, while Alabama State switches from national to LAC.

1 Like

Perhaps the best response to such attitudes is, “Being able to think logically, perform research, and defend a point of view are useful skills, are they not?”

7 Likes

So no, not really. That said, from what I have seen in survey data and such, the US News rankings are actually only popular in a fraction of the college-bound population. A lot of families don’t really use rankings, and then others are using Niche or other alternatives–US News has a plurality, but a small one, and apparently the alternatives have been closing the gap. Here is a representative report:

That survey also indicates that academic quality is more important than rankings for most students, including even those who use rankings, although obviously the gap is much higher among those who don’t. There are some other interesting patterns in there.

My point, though, is that the US News rankings, as essentially a niche-market product, are predictably shaped to give that niche market what it wants in a ranking. Including over time.

However, I think a lot of the families who are not in that market never show up in this sort of forum, because they feel no need. Like, lots of families are quite reasonably targeting their in-state system, they get the advice they need from their school counselor, and that’s that.

And even among those thinking of privates and/or “going away” for college, they may again either have good advice already available, or they are not thinking in terms where they really need our sort of help. Like, maybe they have a particular sort of specialty program in mind, and they might be talking to some people in that area. Or maybe they are doing QuestBridge, which I understand has its own advisory system. Or so on.

OK, so we do get some people who are not really rankings people, but they have a sufficiently unusual situation (or combination of circumstances) they can’t find a community dedicated to that. But then we also get a lot of “how can I be more competitive for T20s” sorts of people. The sort who think in terms like higher generic rankings = more prestige = better, and then who want to know what they can do to mold themselves into whatever those colleges want to see.

And that is the prime market for US News rankings, right? But I really don’t believe most college bound students think that way. They are just disproportionately represented around here, because of the role we (for good or ill) are often playing in the greater world of college choice and admissions advice.

3 Likes

I note I have seen some discussions lately about what AI really is most likely to be doing sooner rather than later, and that seems to be maybe shifting the winds back a little in favor of a more fundamental skills and abilities mindset, as opposed to thinking terms of specific technical training for specific technical tasks.

That said, this sort of stuff seems to ebb and flow to me in potentially unpredictable ways, so who knows where it is really going next.

2 Likes

LACs generally have smaller sample sizes, so earnings information is usually not available for the overwhelming majority of majors. For example, earnings information is only available for 2 majors at Pomona – CS and economics. At Caltech, earnings info is only available for a single major – CS. Wesleyan also only has earnings info for a single major.

How well smaller LACs do in this earnings by ranking metric is highly dependent on how USNWR handles the missing earnings information. In certain other rankings, USNWR penalizes colleges for which earnings information are not available, such as assuming a number on the lower end of representative colleges. However, this may be intentional to encourage colleges to submit stats to USNWR. Missing earnings by major being no fault of the college, USNWR might be more generous in the new metric, such as assuming all missing majors have the average earnings value for the college, or giving the new ranking a weight of 0% in the formula and instead increasing weight of a different stat. Or USNWR might choose to not attempt to use the earnings by major metric for their LAC ranking and instead only include it in their National University ranking.

1 Like

You forgot to mention the problems with controlling the quality and veracity of the data. I asked, and none of the colleges my kids attended have reached out and asked how much they are making. Not even the ones with graduate degrees, where a smaller cohort would be much easier to manage. I don’t know if schools just have a place on their career placement websites that say, “tell us how much you make” or if there is an outreach effort. If the latter, like I said, it hasn’t reached my kids as far as we know. And even if there is outreach, who’s verifying the information? Seems like you could just make it up to help your school’s scoring for ranking (and bragging rights) purposes.

1 Like

U.S. News relies on a federal database, College Scorecard.

1 Like

So I’ll admit that when my kids have been looking at colleges, I haven’t paid any attention to USNWR or to earnings data for that matter. But if one is going to pay attention to that information, I do think it is better to make an apples to apples comparison (within a major instead of between majors) for the reasons that you state However, I am not sure that it will be as useful as we’d hope if the majority of humanities and social science majors at some universities end up going into management consulting or finance. At least at D22’s college, I’m unclear if there is a very strong relationship between majors & their career or even first job anyway. I guess it is useful to know if Art History or English majors have landed a high paying job but maybe not that useful if the student would like to go into a field like art conservation or creative writing or teaching. My sense is that some careers just don’t pay very well and it is not really about the major.

There was a school 10, 20 years ago - a big public - can’t remember - everyone gave a $ as they crossed the stage and they had a high alumni giving percentage.

It was something like that.

I don’t think kids lie on stats and I don’t think schools lie. Maybe I’m naive. But I appreciate the ones that provide a knowledge rate. Your kids schools likely have a low one. My son was asked multiple times for his and his school reflects a high knowledge rate. They also have some kids that report the jobs but not the salaries so the salary survey may include a lesser denominator than the overall reporting.. And they also find others on their own, from linkedin. It depends on the school - they will tell you how they source. But schools definitely have differences in capturing data.

And yes, there are factors that go into something - companies pay by geography.

IU Kelley actually breaks this out - but that’s why, of course, schools in the Bay Area will generate higher salaries.

And even with this - it’s still - how large is the sample size - clearly not the same in each city.

But there is so many factors.

Would that UCB guy get paid the same in Indianapolis that they do in Palo Alto?

Tell me more about this. Is there a federal database that is (1) listing where my kid graduated from college, (2) tracking how much she’s making and (3) sharing that information?

That doesn’t sound great.