So no, not really. That said, from what I have seen in survey data and such, the US News rankings are actually only popular in a fraction of the college-bound population. A lot of families don’t really use rankings, and then others are using Niche or other alternatives–US News has a plurality, but a small one, and apparently the alternatives have been closing the gap. Here is a representative report:
That survey also indicates that academic quality is more important than rankings for most students, including even those who use rankings, although obviously the gap is much higher among those who don’t. There are some other interesting patterns in there.
My point, though, is that the US News rankings, as essentially a niche-market product, are predictably shaped to give that niche market what it wants in a ranking. Including over time.
However, I think a lot of the families who are not in that market never show up in this sort of forum, because they feel no need. Like, lots of families are quite reasonably targeting their in-state system, they get the advice they need from their school counselor, and that’s that.
And even among those thinking of privates and/or “going away” for college, they may again either have good advice already available, or they are not thinking in terms where they really need our sort of help. Like, maybe they have a particular sort of specialty program in mind, and they might be talking to some people in that area. Or maybe they are doing QuestBridge, which I understand has its own advisory system. Or so on.
OK, so we do get some people who are not really rankings people, but they have a sufficiently unusual situation (or combination of circumstances) they can’t find a community dedicated to that. But then we also get a lot of “how can I be more competitive for T20s” sorts of people. The sort who think in terms like higher generic rankings = more prestige = better, and then who want to know what they can do to mold themselves into whatever those colleges want to see.
And that is the prime market for US News rankings, right? But I really don’t believe most college bound students think that way. They are just disproportionately represented around here, because of the role we (for good or ill) are often playing in the greater world of college choice and admissions advice.