U.S. News Anticipates Higher Year-Over-Year Changes in Upcoming Rankings

What does that have to do with what we’re discussing? Seriously, I’m not tracking.

Again, not tracking. What is a knowledge rate? Why do you think my kids’ alma maters have a “low one”? And how, pray tell, does one find out how much a graduate is making from LinkedIn? My daughter is now a mid-level person at a highly selective consulting firm. Lots of people from lots of fancy schools at this place. At this point, there is compensation variability among her cohort. All kinds of variables go into that. When you leave the analyst level and become an associate, your compensation close to doubles. Being on different sides of the practice and working with certain partners/principals also differentiates your comp. I may be missing something, but unless all those people self-reported, it would be hard to know, and I follow the firm on LinkedIn and have never seen anyone reveal their compensation. If my kid were to do it, which she never would, she’d hear from me within the minute to edit the information.

It’s generally limited to students receiving federal financial aid – Pell grants or federal loans. The federal database tracks earnings/debt for persons receiving federal financial aid. The public information only shows aggregate stats for the full college-major cohort, rather than listing stats for individual students; and they suppress the full cohort stat if sample size is very low to protect individual students’ privacy.

4 Likes

I see.

Under the condition that a student took out federal loans, this information becomes available to the federal government.

2 Likes

I put it up - based on this that you said - that school’s, I suppose, make up or in this case, manage a metric to improve their standing in whatever is being graded/ranked.

It just made me think of that story.

But to be clear- nobody who is consulting these salary stats really cares whether your kid is earning X or X plus 20%. They want to know what THEIR kid is going to earn. And that’s yet another reason why these faux analyses are so fraught with error.

There is limited predictability to salary outcomes with so many quirks in the data out of undergrad.

Med school? Certain marketplace realities are baked into the data, and therefore, the numbers can be used with a reasonable amount of predictability. Chop off the outliers, and it’s clear that Neurosurgeons make more money than Pediatricians, regardless of geography, tax issues, etc. Yes, some physicians will qualify for loan repayment programs, but in total, that non-cash compensation does not change the math by specialty.

But you’re trying to compare a poli sci major who is working as a lobbyist for Apple or Microsoft or Big Tobacco to a poli sci major who tracks legislation for the mayor of Gary Indiana? Or even more problematic- the engineer working with her college buddies at a startup where they are bootstrapping- so everyone is earning $60K but the promise of millions, compared to the engineer at GE earning $100K plus a 5-12% bonus, who will max out at $200K in ten years? Which college to pick-- the one that feeds into GE, or the one that already has 50 or more “my company went public and then was bought by Nvidia” millionaires before the age of 30???

2 Likes

I see.

1 Like

I agree with this 100% - but kids/families that are using these up front to judge a school are absolutely assuming their kid will earn that reported # (median, average, whatever) or more.

And those using ranking - whatever ranking they are using - whether US News or WSJ - are using that #.

It’s no different than I went to grad school - I turned down IU for a school making $3K less on average - but I saw IU was placing in Chicago. My school in Phoenix and Denver - so was the salary really different?

I looked deeper. Not everyone does.

btw - many schools provide $$ and $$ vs. the national average, etc. etc. But not many and not enough in my opinion drill into the weeds.

But many schools say stuff like this - their grads are prepared and other things. You don’t need to answer - it’s obvious as to why - but show no data.

Not many, especially LACs, lay it out like this but this did.

Yes, there’s a reason and yes some families are looking.

And yes, some rankings come on data like this.

Anyway, we’ll never agree - and that’s fine. Each kid chooses a school for their own reason - location (close to him), cost, sports, grew up rooting for them - whatever it is - and some based on rank or career data.

Accountability Metrics

Program Credential CIP Code Median Earnings Median Benchmark Earnings
Biology General Bachelor 2601 $59,985 $34,808
National HS
Cognitive Science Bachelor 3025 $78,782 $34,808
National HS
Economics Bachelor 4506 $103,164 $34,808
National HS
International Relations and National Security Studies Bachelor 4509 $70,394 $34,808
National HS
Mathematics Bachelor 2701 $88,080 $34,808
National HS
Natural Resources Conservation and Research Bachelor 301 $59,542 $34,808
National HS
Political Science and Government Bachelor 4510 $72,441 $34,808
National HS
Psychology General Bachelor 4201 $56,800 $34,808
National HS
Romance Languages Literatures and Linguistics Bachelor 1609 $71,779 $34,808
National HS
Sociology Bachelor 4511 $58,598 $34,808
National HS

This is definitely a problem for any sort of value added analysis. It is sometimes described as a type of self-selection problem.

Like, English majors at College A are relatively more likely to become HS teachers, English majors at College B relatively more likely to become lawyers. Is this value added by College B? Not all HS teachers secretly want to be lawyers, even if lawyers average more earnings. And maybe College A often costs less for these future teachers, so it makes sense they disproportionately choose College A. And meanwhile people who see College B doing well in law school placement studies end up more willing to pay for College B . . . .

Controlling for all this would be a nightmare, and as others are implying, I am skeptical the data even exists to really try. But I agree at least some people these days are asking this question–which college if chosen will add more value in terms of my individual career earnings?–and so places like US News will try to give them some sort of answer. Even if it is not a good answer.

Personally, though–I am fine with the part where people who want to be HS teachers maybe choose different colleges sometimes than people who want to be lawyers, including for cost or other practical reasons. But basically once I am convinced a college is going to be comfortably affordable and capable of providing appropriate support for the sort of career path a given individual might want, I am not really interested in cateer earnings statistics, not in the current state at least.

In other words, I basically trust that if you get started and then are actually good at being a teacher, lawyer, or so on, you will be able to get fair compensation for your services, regardless of where you went to college. Which is my professional experience, in fact.

Just as the federal government has found a way to get income data on student loan recipients (so a potential picture on ROI), it has additional resources to get data on academic quality. For instance, if a school wants to be eligible to receive disbursements from federal student loans, then the government could require the colleges to provide information on the academic quality. Here are two such indicators that could be used:

2 Likes

Knowledge rate is the % of grads they know about. For example, Georgia Tech says 35% so they have data from 35% of their students. They don’t break it out by major so you can’t say by major.

An Alabama breaks out by major. They show 82.2% overall but let’s say you wanted Mechanical Engineering for Spring 2025, Bachelor Degree, they are telling you they know the outcomes of 91.2%.

As I noted, you might have reporting on X students but only Y report salary - so it may or may not be on all. In other words, they show 114 total responses but only 44 salaries shown. But of those 114, 71 are working so they are in essence getting salaries on 44 / 71 people.

Now - you asked questions and my answers will be subjective:

  1. Why do I think your kids alma maters don’t report? Well, if they’re not being asked, that’s an easy reason. But when I see a school with a low knowledge rate in general, it makes me wonder - why? Are kids not having success not wanting to report, ie being embarrassed? At the same time, why did only 44 of 71 kids at Bama who reported give a salary? I would have similar pause - that’s me. But I think people who are looking for data aren’t digging deep like this - they are comparing the # from various schools - not whether data is reported from 35% of 91%, etc. If Bama is showing $81,294 and Ga Tech $82.5K - and btw Bama is an average and Ga Tech a median - I don’t think people look at those differently either. They just see a # - and not what % of kids are participating. Then, there are some, like Pitt that shows a $77K median, so it can be compared to Techs $82.5K but they also show a $77.7K average - which then can be compared to Bama. Pitt, by the way, shows a 74.1% knowledge rate so they have info on 3 of 4 MechEs that year.

I can’t speak to your school specifically, but it can be any number of reasons your kids weren’t asked - from an email went to junk to the school didn’t ask - to who knows.

As for linkedin, some schools report how they aquire data and some have listed that they get from the students, but also linkedin scrapes. Those that do that, I assume are grabbing the title and company but obviously not the salary.

I’m not in career management - so I can’t speak to what or why they do - but just reading that they do it.

Does your kid’s school put out a career management database like this ? Many do but many do not - including top schools. Here you can see Cornell, overall, reports knowing about 72% of its grads through response but when I chose Mechanical Engineering, it went up to 80%. I put the link below - if you have interest. Scross down on the left side and you’ll see the various filters.

Student Career Outcomes Dashboard – Cornell Career Network

What is this? Can you cite a source? otherwise I see a bunch of numbers on a table with zero context.

1 Like

The link is right above the table - but I’ll put for you here again in case it can’t be seen. It’s just Cornell’s career outcome database. Many schools, as you know, and many don’t.

Student Career Outcomes Dashboard – Cornell Career Network

When Bill Gates and Blossom have dinner together, the average net worth at their table is several billion dollars.

You admit the “data” is incomplete, unverified, mixes up median and mean, and in some cases with a sample size too small to be useful. And yet you keep grinding away at this.

I’ll order dessert and make Bill pay for it.

And fyi- a BIG topic of conversation right now in talent management circles is the explosion in fake/AI produced bio’s on Linkedin. Literally- Bots claiming to be Wharton grads with 12 years experience in M&A.

1 Like

@blossom - schools are putting it out and people are using it.

That’s what’s out there.

It’s certainly directional and it’s certainly was a floor for my kid and all he knew.

But there’s a reason schools put this out - just as all top MBA programs do.

I’ve never said otherwise.

It’s marketing - when you have a story to tell, you tell it. If someone isn’t, then they’re not going to look good.

This is the reality of life - whether or not you want to believe it.

Anyway, we don’t need to continue to rehash - you think differently.

Many families seek this data and many rankings now rely on it - totally or partially - which is why this thread came to being a day or two ago.

No, it means they are telling a different story. And there are many families who are interested in THOSE stories, not the ones you claim everyone wants to hear about.

I took my kids to see Dartmouth (it was on the way to somewhere else). The tour guide, the adcom, the Director of Admissions who stopped by the presentation all talked about three things- skiing, Winter Carnival, and the “D Plan”.

My kids reaction? “Don’t they have a bio department?”

3 Likes

Please don’t put words in my mouth. I’ve never said everyone.

But when I’m comparing two schools for an OP, I’ll use it - and others, like the CA 4.0 1470 CS person is clearly seeking them as they choose schools outside their area.

Some care. Some don’t.

But just like seeing how many majors a school has or how much it costs or anything else, it’s data. It’s something quantitative that can be compared - and you can be assured people going to schools like Bucknell and Richmond are well aware - because they schools are telling them and that’s why in non US News rankings, schools like they and Babson and Bentley are rising to the top.

You choose not to use it. I don’t begrudge you. That’s your choice.

Cornell, Ga Tech, Alabama, Berkeley, UNC, UVA and many many others have decided salary is useful. And I’m appreciative they do.

I choose to use it. So I’m not sure why you begrudge me doing so. That you don’t like it - so then don’t use it. But you don’t speak for all potential students, many of which are interested.

Let’s move on please as debating is not allowed.

1 Like

Stats being imperfect is different from implying stats are useless. The earnings stats may be more or less useful for different individuals depending on their prospective major, career plans, and what information they hope to obtain.

As an example, the earlier Cornell link shows the following stats for class of 2025 CS majors. This gives grads some idea typical salary range for grads working in different types of industries. It also gives grads some idea of which employers were likely recruiting on campus or attending career fairs. One can also look up things like is there a significant difference in outcome for BA in CS in College of Arts & Sciences vs BS at College of CS? Or with MS? Or …? It’s far from perfect, but it’s better than no information for many students.

Overall

  • 149 full-time earnings reported, 80% Response Rate
  • 66% Employed at 6 months, 30% Continuing Education, 1% Seeking Employment/Education
  • Mean = $128k, Median = $129k, Overwhelming majority are >$120k
  • Most Common Employers = Amazon (by far), Meta, Google, and Bloomberg

Working in Software Engineering/Development

  • 123 full-time earnings reported
  • Mean = $132k, Median = $131k, Overwhelming majority are >$120k
  • Most Common Employers = Amazon and Meta (by far), followed by Google and Microsoft
2 Likes

I’m sure we’re all a bit burnt out on ranking threads, especially when they get overly detailed. Let me gently remind everyone to keep things on-topic (saving salary breakdowns for another thread) and keep it friendly. We don’t need a formal debate here—just share your thoughts concisely and kindly.

4 Likes

On another forum, an educational consultant said “when parents tell me that this or that school has a high ROI, I always say it’s the student who makes the ROI, not the school”.

2 Likes