With respect to U.S. News rankings, Colby has a history of its own:
Here’s the story - how the ranking is gamed - Clemson U. I read about it a long time ago but it’s still happening. Their “alumni” giving % is rigged - and they seem open about it.
Your First Gift Back to Clemson!
Clemson Alumni have a long-standing tradition of making gifts to Clemson each year.
Anonymous donors have made a gift of two $1 bills in honor of each graduate. By simply saying “Yes, I want to participate,” this gift will be credited to your giving record for the Class of 2026 project and will represent your first gift back to Clemson. You will help Clemson move up in the rankings, and all you have to do is say YES!
Congratulations to Our Newest Clemson Alumni – Clemson Alumni Association
Babson is currently ranked in Business Programs and the business specialties of Accounting, Entrepreneurship, Management and Marketing. Its primary category, Business Schools, is an unranked category. Its primary category for the upcoming year, Regional Universities North, is a ranked category.
It’s a shame they aren’t ranked with schools they cross shop which are national universities.
If someone wanted to know - UCONN, UMASS, Rutgers, Penn State, BC, BU or Babson.
Oh well, it’s their ranking.
Other rankings include with all other.
No, it’s broader than this. The College Scoreboard database includes students who received any federal financial aid…so Pell grants, work-study, FSEOG, the direct student loans and I think TEACH grants too.
The database only includes students from Title IV schools. So if a school doesn’t accept federal financial aid, the student is not in the College Scorecard database.
If a student is full pay or if parent stool out parent plus loans, they would not be in the College Scorecard database.
I provided one condition.
I think it makes more sense to rank in tiers. But even that is fraught with controversy: where do you draw the borders between tiers?
Yep, and I shared more ways how a student gets into the college scorecard database.
This was the source post:
Adding…the federal financial aid recipients by college are matched up with their tax returns to populate the income piece of the database.
Glad I was able to pay my kids’ way. That’s quite a privacy trade-off IMO, but then again, I’m Gen X and have found that I’m generally more sensitive to that sort of thing than those making up the generations that have come after me. The people who were adults when I was young would turn over in their graves. I really learned how different generations view and react to matters concerning privacy and the government when I was an appellate court law clerk. What the young law clerks and the much older justices viewed as a privacy issue often varied wildly.
Sample questions from the CLA appear to be here: https://cae.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/2-Sample-Assessment-Community-Service-112125.pdf
The NSSE questions appear to be here: U.S. English: Survey Instruments: NSSE: Evidence-Based Improvement in Higher Education: Indiana University
However, what those measure may not cover the full range of what may be seen as academic quality. There may also be variations within a college due to variations across departments or divisions.
I think the basic problem is there are many different dimensions on which college choice is made, and different people weight them differently, and sometimes even reverse the signs.
This is why customizable rankings at least make some sense. You have a bunch of datasets and then the user can decide which factors to include, how to weight them, even possibly change the sign, and so on. You provide value added by collecting and updating the data, and also norming it so that you don’t introduce distortions based on different factors having wider or narrower distributions.
But that isn’t really something you can use to generate headlines. It is also useless for the purpose of treating college like a game in which you get a higher score for higher-ranked colleges. So . . . here we are.
Yeah – I would use USNews and other rankings for a basic identification guide to some of the great schools in this country, basic info about them, etc.
But then I’d create a spreadsheet with the things that are important to me, weighted appropriately, and form my list that way. Only schools that would be affordable and offer my major(s) of interest would be included, and I’d use my fit variables to rank them.
When in doubt, I might favor a school offering more majors over one offering fewer, since so many kids change their minds – I would want ample room to maneuver academically.
I don’t know by whom I’m more disgusted: Colby, assuming Mr. Hershey’s accusation of massaging the numbers is accurate, or Mr. Hershey, who not only violated a employment confidence but saw fit to write it into a published letter. Caution to Cornell: this guy works for you now.
As to the 54/80 matter, while I’m no advocate for US News, I hardly think their failure to audit data submitted by an institution of Colby College’s stature because of a 20% metric variance year-to-year is sufficient reason to fault them for his mistake.
It’s going to be interesting. The one guarantee is that a lot of people will be pissed.
- Will schools with higher earning majors (engineering, business…) do better than those without? US News says they are taking measures to compare apples to apples, but the categories are filled with oranges, bananas, limes and others. They have to be compared somehow.
- Will schools with wealthy student bodies be disadvantaged? If US News only counts those students that get federal loans, will that hurt some schools that have reputations for high earnings, but wealthy students? It’ll depend on how their federal loan students do. But keep in mind, most of the top LACs have rich student bodies. Someone in the thread mentioned Colgate where only 13% get federal aid, but Amherst, Colby, Williams, Bates, Haverford to name a few I quickly checked have similar or even less students getting federal aid. I thought it was interesting that Bucknell (also a reputation for rich kids) has 33% of the student body getting federal loans. Much higher than most of the LACs above it.
- Will there be some way to adjust for region / cost of living?
I would be shocked if that were not the case.
Quite possibly, not. For example, Richmond will be compared to LACs without business majors partly by the earnings of its majors in economics. And, under this scenario, Richmond places well after schools like, in order of graduate earnings, Williams, Claremont McKenna, Amherst, Hamilton, Colgate, Swarthmore, Middlebury and Bowdoin.
Yep. It is going to depend on those “statistical transformations” they mentioned.
My personal guess is it might be best for colleges with fewer explicitly “pre-professional” majors and yet lots of people actually going into lucrative professions. But we shall see.
They didn’t mention one.
This has had interesting patterns in other things I have seen. Obviously colleges that generally place a lot of high-earning professionals in VHCOL metros would benefit. But in things I have seen before, a college that was actually very local but in a VHCOL area could also benefit.
Like if College A and College B both place a lot of English majors into K-12 teaching positions not far from each respective college, but K-12 teachers are paid a lot more in College A’s area than College B’s area, College A could get a higher earnings per major score than College B.
Good point.
Hofstra’s new teacher salaries (either NYC or Long Island) can be more than double that of University of Tulsa, which feeds into Tulsa, Oklahoma City, or one of their suburbs.
In the end, the schools that fall are the same schools they were yesterday - they didn’t forget to be a good, mediocre or poor school overnight (they might be any of the three regardless of their perceived rating). It’s just that their cache is lessened a bit.
I think the other year when Tulane, Nova, and Wake fell…maybe Northeastern too - they whined but they are the same schools.
I think Rutgers and Illinois and a few other state schools rose a bunch - and I’m sure they bask in it. Of course with that rise, they likely let the world know - as they should.
UF has flags/banners all over campus touting their ranking. In the other rankings that base on salary, they seem to do very well so it wouldn’t surprise me (depending on the weight of that metric) that they perform well again.