I’ve been admitted to UCB, UVA, and Rice (some waitlists), and am trying to decide between them. I’m a prospective Poli Sci major. Some things that are important to me in choosing a school:
Academic programs in Poli Sci and Social Sciences/Humanities
Atmosphere and culture (Friendly, fun, not too competitive)
Politically and socially active student body
Academic reputation
Good Model UN and Mock Trial teams
Accepting to LGBTQ+
Easy to find a community and make friends
Obviously I know it’s impossible to find a school with all of these qualities, but I would love to hear thoughts on my situation!
Academic programs in Poli Sci and Social Sciences/Humanities–probably all good
Atmosphere and culture (Friendly, fun, not too competitive)–probably all good
Politically and socially active student body–Berkeley!
Academic reputation–All good, but Berkeley has the strongest reputation internationally, world over, for sure. People know Berkeley everywhere. It’s huge.
Good Model UN and Mock Trial teams-- I’m a lawyer, went to Cal for law school, and have no idea if it has good programs for undergrads for this, but you don’t really need it, even if politics or law are in your plans. SO many activities on campus there, and probably at all 3.
Accepting to LGBTQ+ – Um, BERKELEY. It’s in the SF bay area. LGBTQ was mainstream there decades before anywhere else. But all of these schools are going to fall into this category to some degree. College towns tend to be accepting. But not on the level of Cal.
Easy to find a community and make friends-- you will do this no matter what. They will all be good.
Also, I’m guessing from your name that you are from Nashville, so you are going to feel comfortable at and fit in at UVA or Rice, as well as Berkeley. I would not say the same to LGBTQ youth looking to head to TX or VA from, say, Northern California.
Does this mean that you have these 3 plus you are on some waitlists for other schools, or that you have one of those three and are on the waitlists for 2 of them?
Agree with the others that all three tick your list of boxes. So then it comes down to the experiential differences, and they are substantial. How much- and what type - of campus experience do you want?
Not knowing you at all, of the three UVa seems like the ‘just right’ option: it is big enough that you can find your people (no matter who they are) and yet has a good central caampus and collegiate feel, is 2+ hours from DC, making even a day trip not impossible, decent weather, and Larry Sabato’s Center for Politics. But- I didn’t choose UVa for me, b/c I wanted different things, so take it for what free advice on the internet is worth!
My guess is that he means that he got into one of the 3 before May 1(and deposited) and got into the other 2 after May 1 off the waitlist. Might be wrong of course
The educational experience will be qualitatively different at Rice - and for the better IMO… It’s friendly, fun, and not too competitive - to the extent that any campus with top students and excellent can be, but it’s not very political at all. The residential colleges are effective at building a sense of community.
IF LGBTQ+ and politically/socially active are the deciding factors, then it’s Berkeley hands down. Otherwise, I’d favor Rice. It’s a special place.
A substantial share of my daughter’s friends at Rice were/are LGBTQ+, and Houston is a much more LGBT-friendly city than you might imagine. The mayor from 2010 to 2016 was a lesbian and Rice alum… and there’s a large LGBT community. There are plenty of opportunities to be politically active, but it’s true that in terms of the campus culture, Rice is far more politically complacent than Berkeley. It’s certainly a socially active student body, though. Students lean liberal on average but the Baker Institute leans moderate-to-conservative.
I hesitate to recommend paying the enormous OOS cost of Berkeley when full pay at Rice is less than 5K/year more, and it’s a far more personalized experience, guaranteed housing with residential college system, and tons of benefits like funded internships.
I guess a lot depends, though, on what kind of political context you want, for studying poli sci. Berkeley is going to be more of a liberal echo chamber (and I say this as a liberal… but my Rice kid found a lot of value in having both ends of the political spectrum intelligently represented, and having to defend her opinions)… but state and local politics provide a laboratory where liberal policies are actually implemented. In Texas, there will be a lot more barriers to putting liberal policy ideas into practice, although that does happen to an extent within Houston as a city. Virginia would be the most balanced political terrain, and the closest connections with DC.
In terms of the upcoming year… Rice is making tangible plans to bring students back to campus for a modified calendar. Berkeley is likely to be wholly online for a while. Not sure about UVA.
“Obviously I know it’s impossible to find a school with all of these qualities, but I would love to hear thoughts on my situation!”
Berkeley meets more of your requirements than the other two. Both Berkeley and UVa have excellent poly sci programs, better than Rice. Rice is less competitive and has a better sense of community. And accepting to LGBTQ+ would favor UCB by a large margin, the bay area has issues of course, but when it comes to acceptance of the LGBTQ community, and tolerance of gender identity, UCB is going to be the place. There’s not even a close second in this comparison. good luck!