I think your over thinking this. Decide which one that you want to do and you’ll have your answer. They are different fields. Simple as that, nor would I make it any more complex. Good luck!
The prestige and school size is equal. You should be weighing whether you want to do biochem or chem eng. They’re completely different fields that will give you completely different undergrad experiences.
THink about which school can the easiest land you top jobs
Think about the location, which college is at the best location especially if you want to find a job there after four years
The money label may be true in most cases but the aid office differs by school to school too. Like a state uni thats less competitive in terms of rank likely has a less financial aid package for you. School with higher ranking may has a higher financial aid for you and cancels more and left less in its amount.
Think about each’s national level ranking which affects tons (on USNWR).
Now left you to decide and look on the national rankings .