I don’t see where you offered your opinion as to their admission chances.
Why don’t you do that instead of criticizing my answer?? That’s what she’s asking you to do. I’ll respect whatever guidance you’ll give.
Ultimately, none of us are AOs and that will come in a few weeks - the real answer.
And no- i did not state it incorrectly. Nor have you. We said the same thing.
Typically, one does not want to sit below - what you called the sweet spot.